It’s important not to get too worked up over players your team could have drafted. Unless you’re in a situation like the Dallas Stars were in 1999, taking Patrik Stefan first overall as the Sedin twins went second and third, respectively, missing out on draft gems is usually something that affects a lot of teams in hindsight. Still, that won’t make this story from former NHL general manager Gord Stellick any less painful.
Stellick joined Nick Alberga and Jay Rosehill on Monday’s edition of Leafs Morning Take, where he revealed that former scout-turned-general manager Floyd Smith made a last-minute pitch for the Toronto Maple Leafs to select Joe Sakic with the seventh overall pick after the rest of the management team had already settled on defenceman Luke Richardson.
JOE SAKIC WAS ALMOST A LEAF?
In short, according to @GordStellick, who worked in the #LeafsForever front office in the 80s, yes, there was a pathway in the 1987 draft that would've seen Burnaby Joe land in Toronto. @TLNdc
I didn't need to hear this story today..or ever: pic.twitter.com/DbNBEgnar0
— Nick Alberga (@thegoldenmuzzy) June 9, 2025
Stellick notes that then-Maple Leafs head coach John Brophy was adamantly against the decision, which is funny for a couple of reasons. First, as Stellick says, it’s crazy to think that their coach had that much say in who the Maple Leafs drafted, but the connection between him and then-owner Harold Ballard was too strong for his word to be left in the dust. Second, Brophy didn’t want Sakic because he ‘didn’t want a small centre’. They both stand at 5-foot-11!
The Quebec Nordiques, who had two first-round picks in the first round of the 1987 draft, ended up using their second of those two picks to select Sakic as 15th overall. He undoubtedly got the last laugh in this situation, putting together a career of over 1300 games with 625 goals and over 1600 points. He also won two Stanley Cups, one in 1996 and the other in 2001. Richardson, on the other hand, only lasted four seasons with the Maple Leafs before he was involved in a blockbuster trade with the Edmonton Oilers that saw Grant Fuhr, Glenn Anderson, and now-Maple Leafs head coach Craig Berube.
As noted off the top, there were 12 other teams who could have taken Sakic, so this wasn’t just a fumble by the Leafs. Still, if you routinely struggle with the lack of success the Leafs have had in the past half-century, don’t imagine the idea of Sakic and Doug Gilmour playing on a line together.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!