Oilers Goaltending: Solid Foundation, But Room to Grow

One of the great stories of this Edmonton Oilers era has been the emergence of Stuart Skinner as a legitimate NHL starter. A hometown kid who once watched the Oilers from the nosebleeds at Rexall Place, Skinner has now backstopped the team to two consecutive Stanley Cup Finals and earned a trip to the NHL All-Star Game. He’s calm under pressure, team-first in his mindset, and still just entering his prime. It’s easy to root for him, and it’s clear the organization trusts him as their number one.

Calvin Pickard Has Been Great, But Wasn’t Signed to Be a 1B Goalie

Backing him up, Calvin Pickard has been one of the most dependable surprises of the 2025 playoffs. Originally signed as a third-string option, Pickard stepped in when needed and played with poise and reliability. His calm presence gave the team a boost when Skinner faltered. He deserves credit for helping stabilize things in key moments.

But here’s the thing: if the Oilers want to get over the final hurdle and win the Stanley Cup, good goaltending has to become elite goaltending. And that’s where proactive support becomes critical. Neither Skinner nor Pickard is the problem, but both could benefit from a structured plan to get to the next level.

Skinner Needs a System Around Him to Be His Best

For Skinner, the next step may not just be technical—it may be psychological and developmental. Goalie coaches are vital, but so is mental support tailored to the unique pressures of carrying a franchise. We’re not suggesting he needs a psychologist following him around the rink—but having someone available, someone who understands the nuances of elite performance under pressure, could be invaluable. This isn’t about fixing a flaw. It’s about maximizing potential.

For Pickard, the team has to decide how long they can rely on a veteran backup in key moments without overextending expectations. He’s earned a spot. But they may need to shore up depth behind him, either with another trusted veteran or a young prospect who can develop under the radar.