x
Panthers Should Avoid Pursuing Stuart Skinner This Offseason
New Pittsburgh Penguins goaltender Stuart Skinner (Wendell Cruz-Imagn Images)

After being crippled by injuries this season, the Florida Panthers missed the playoffs for the first time since 2019. Winning back-to-back Stanley Cups and reaching three straight Stanley Cup Finals comes at a cost, but the extended break should give them plenty of rest and time to heal.

In the meantime, management must decide the team’s future between the pipes. Both goaltenders, Sergei Bobrovsky and Daniil Tarasov, will be free agents this summer, and it is unknown if either of them is coming back. It does not help that rumors are speculating that talks have not gone well with Bobrovsky when it comes to a possible contract extension. As a result, it looks like there will be a new sheriff in town when the smoke clears.

According to The Athletic, the Pittsburgh Penguins and former Edmonton Oilers goaltender Stuart Skinner would be a good fit in South Florida (from ‘NHL free-agent targets: One player each team should sign this offseason’, The Athletic, May 16, 2026). But that’s the exact type of move general manager Bill Zito should not make.

Skinner Massively Inconsistent Throughout His Career

Skinner has a reputation for being one of the most streaky goaltenders in the NHL. While he has had All-Star-level performances here and there, his struggles are borderline season killers. In his run to the Stanley Cup Final with the Oilers in 2024, he won 11 of his first 16 starts, including one shutout.

In his first three games against the Panthers in the Cup Final, he was Swiss cheese, allowing nine goals and finishing below a .900 save percentage (SV%). He then put together three great performances with a .970 SV%, allowing one goal in Game 5 and one goal in Game 6 with a .952 SV%.

The following postseason, he earned three shutouts but only a .889 SV%. In his first postseason with the Penguins this season, he had a 3.08 goals-against average (GAA) and a .873 SV% through three games. His inconsistency will spell trouble for the team, especially in the postseason.

Skinner Might Be Looking for a Raise

Skinner signed his current contract in Dec. 2022, a three-year extension worth $2.6 million per year. He will be a free agent this offseason, and after being part of multiple playoff runs, he could ask for a raise. Now, there is nothing wrong with wanting more, but Zito should use that money on a better player or to fill another need on the roster.

Better Goaltending Options on the Market

Winnipeg Jets goaltender Connor Hellebuyck could be looking for a new home after his brutally honest assessment when asked about his future with the team, and he might want to be reunited with his former head coach, Paul Maurice, and his gold medalist teammate, Matthew Tkachuk, in Florida.

Minnesota Wild goaltender Filip Gustavsson will also be a free agent this summer. The Wild are expected to put their future in the hands of 23-year-old Jesper Wallstedt, so Gustavsson might be looking for a starter’s role somewhere else.

Finally, Bradley Knowing is arguably the best goaltending prospect out of this draft class, and the Panthers should consider selecting him if he happens to fall into their laps.

Will Zito Make the Move?

Unless Zito is desperate, Skinner shouldn’t even be on his radar. While it would be a funny case of “if you can’t beat them, join them”, signing him would cause more harm than good in the long run. The last thing this team needs is more inconsistency.

This article first appeared on The Hockey Writers and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!