Three potential head coach replacements for Maple Leafs

That connection matters more than people sometimes admit. This isn’t a roster that needs drastically retooled. It’s one that needs clearer structure and more consistent accountability. Malhotra has been around this core, seen where things break down in tight playoff games, and likely has a decent feel for what needs to change, due to his success at the AHL level.

He is considered to be a detail-oriented coach. Which might sound simple but can actually be a strength in a market where everything tends to get magnified. The question is just whether this is too big of a leap, going from AHL head coach to one of the most scrutinized jobs in hockey.

Bruce Cassidy

Lastly, if Toronto wants the most proven name available, it’s Bruce Cassidy. There’s not really much debate around that. He’s won a Stanley Cup with the Vegas Golden Knights and had sustained success during his time with the Boston Bruins.

He’s structured, demanding, and not especially interested in managing comfort levels. If a star forward isn’t tracking defensively, he’ll sit them. It’s that straightforward. That edge is part of why he stands out in a discussion like this, especially for a team that has, at times, looked like accountability fades when the pressure spikes. His systems are built for playoff hockey but in a different way than Berube’s were. Cassidy wants tight gaps, disciplined structure, and everything funnelled outside. It isn’t always flashy, but it tends to hold up when games get heavier and space disappears.

Chayka has a big decision to make with this hiring. Typically, a new GM doesn’t get many chances to fire and hire a coach. So, this is massive. On paper, Cassidy looks like the best option, but there are other viable options like Woodcroft and Malholtra that could benefit the Maple Leafs more.