NHL News

Home

Teams

Quizzes

Newsletter

Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images

Trade Analysis: Maple Leafs Bring Home Scott Laughton

Originally posted on Trade Talk Sports | By Old Prof | Last updated Mar 8, 2025 2:35 PM ET

The Toronto Maple Leafs made a significant move just ahead of the NHL trade deadline, acquiring Scott Laughton, a versatile and dependable third-line center, from the Philadelphia Flyers. In return, Toronto sent Nikita Grebenkin and a 2027 first-round pick to the Flyers. With the Maple Leafs needing a solid third-line center, this trade brings immediate impact and long-term results.

Good Points of the Trade for Toronto

Immediate Impact on Depth: Laughton fills the team’s need for a solid third-line center. It also helps the team ease the pressure on Auston Matthews and John Tavares. His defense will help the team, especially as they push into the playoffs, which is more defensive-focused.
Cap-Friendly Deal: The Flyers retain 50% of Laughton’s salary. This means his cap hit for the Maple Leafs is just $1.5 million for the rest of this season and next year. This helps the Maple Leafs make more moves before the deadline or add depth next season.
Offensive Contributions: Laughton is known for his defensive game. But he also can add offense. He’s registered 27 points (11 goals, 16 assists) in 60 games this season. In past seasons, he’s hit the 40-point mark. If he can maintain even 35 points at this cap hit, it’s a steal for Toronto.
Additional Draft Picks: Toronto also picks up a fourth and a sixth-round pick. These help keep the organization stocked over the long term. Now the team has to trust its scouting.

Bad Points of the Trade for Toronto

Loss of First-Round Pick: Toronto gives up a 2027 first-round pick, even with the top-10 protection. While this pick is far in the future, it is still a valuable asset, especially for a team in a potential rebuild like Philadelphia, which could use a high pick.
Potential for Grebenkin’s Development: Nikita Grebenkin, though a long shot to make the Maple Leafs in the near future, is a promising energy player who could have contributed to their bottom six if developed further. His departure means the team loses some organizational depth.
Pressure to Perform: While Laughton brings strong defensive capabilities, he is expected to perform well on both ends of the ice. If his offensive output falls short of expectations or he struggles to adjust to the team’s system, it could be seen as a lost opportunity for what they gave up.

Maple Leafs Trade Analysis Table

Aspect	Good for Toronto	Bad for Toronto	Good for Philadelphia	Bad for Philadelphia
Immediate Impact	Strengthens third-line center depth.	Gives up a future first-round pick.	Secures a future first-round pick.	Loses a key leader and solid contributor.
Cap Flexibility	Laughton’s $1.5 million cap hit is ideal.	May need to replace Grebenkin’s energy.	Clears salary and adds assets for future.	Loses a key defensive presence in Laughton.
Offensive Contribution	Laughton adds scoring depth.	High expectations for offensive output.	Grebenkin has potential for growth.	Grebenkin is unproven at NHL level.
Draft Capital	Adds fourth and sixth-round picks.	Loss of 2027 first-round pick.	Adds a future first-round pick and prospect.	First-round pick may not materialize.
Long-Term Value	Potential steal if Laughton contributes.	Future draft pick could be valuable.	Grebenkin could thrive in a new system.	Team may not be competitive in short term.

The Bottom Line for the Maple Leafs

The trade between the Maple Leafs and the Flyers seems a win for both teams, though with different foci. For Toronto, acquiring Laughton fills a need for a third-line center and gives the team some valuable depth going into the playoffs. The cap-friendly deal and the potential for Laughton to add offense make this trade a solid move for the Maple Leafs.

On the other hand, while the Flyers do give up a leader in Laughton, they secure a solid return in the form of future assets, including a first-round pick and a promising prospect in Grebenkin. This trade helps set them up for a more successful rebuild, although they may experience a short-term setback in terms of competitiveness.

In conclusion, this trade should help Toronto now and in the near future, while giving Philadelphia the tools to build their future foundation. The long-term success for both teams will depend on how these new assets develop and impact their respective rosters.

This article first appeared on Trade Talk Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: