The NFL is on trial, but the proceedings apparently are not resonating with fans.
The league is a defendant in a federal class-action lawsuit brought by "NFL Sunday Ticket" subscribers, who accuse the NFL of violating antitrust regulations.
Here are three reasons why fans should be paying attention to the trial:
The NFL sells game television rights under its 1961 antitrust exemption for broadcasting. It claims the right to sell "NFL Sunday Ticket" under that same exemption, but the plaintiffs in this case say that it only applies to over-the-air broadcasts and not pay TV providers such as DirecTV or YouTube TV.
After years on DirectTV, "NFL Sunday Ticket" moved to YouTube TV last season for residential customers.
The jury's verdict will either solidify the NFL's legal monopoly or completely overhaul 63 years of legal precedent.
On Monday, Pro Football Talk's Mike Florio, who holds a law degree, explained the significance on "The Pat McAfee Show" on ESPN.
"The NFL has an exemption dating back to 1961 as it relates to selling packages to broadcast networks..
— Pat McAfee (@PatMcAfeeShow) June 17, 2024
I wish we had more coverage of this thing but what I've seen so far this feels like a tough case for the NFL" ~ @ProFootballTalk #PMSLive https://t.co/Ig9jhio8dB pic.twitter.com/k2R0AkfDfR
During the court proceedings, it was revealed that when the NFL was searching for a new "NFL Sunday Ticket" provider after its deal with DirecTV ended, ESPN proposed offering it at a substantially lower rate as well as a single-team package for customers.
The league declined and chose YouTube TV instead because, according to New England Patriots owner Robert Kraft's deposition testimony, ESPN's lower-price model would hurt league TV partners CBS and Fox, who pay billions to air regional NFL games.
The plaintiffs point to this being a prime example of the league colluding to price gouge customers to save lucrative TV contracts with networks.
Wall Street Journal reporter Joe Flint reported on X that CBS Sports chairman Sean McManus confirmed Kraft's testimony while on the stand Tuesday.
Former CBS Sports Chairman Sean McManus said at Sunday To let trial that network has never been fan of Sunday Ticket or RedZone as they cut into cbs viewership. Says CBS used to get compensated for their feeds being used for Sunday Ticket but not anymore.
— Joe Flint (@JBFlint) June 18, 2024
If the jury rules in the plaintiffs' favor, the NFL could be forced to pay up to $21B in damages and also reform its "NFL Sunday Ticket" structure to allow for multiple providers at competitive pricing. That's a potential win for consumers.
Per the Associated Press, the presiding judge is frustrated with the lawyers for the plaintiffs, admonishing them for unnecessary questioning and unrelated arguments. Flint posted a quote from the judge Tuesday.
“You really have nothing,” Judge on Sunday Ticket case tells plaintiffs’ lawyers. Says Plaintiff lawyers over complicated a simple case. “It’s a total disconnect.” Jurors about to be led back in for day 2 of Jerry Jones followed by Sean McManus.
— Joe Flint (@JBFlint) June 18, 2024
If the league wins, which is appearing more likely, it could be a green light for other leagues to explore a similar business model to the "NFL Sunday Ticket" — especially with regional networks such as Bally Sports reportedly on the verge of ceasing operations.
The NHL already offers a "Power Play" package with an ESPN+ subscription allowing customers to stream any game from any regional market.
Regardless of the outcome, football fans should pay attention to rest of the proceedings as the ruling could impact their finances and potentially affect the future availability of games.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!