On Flipboard
Rash of questionable replay decisions cast doubt on utility of replay review
Is replay review working?
Replay officials are tarnishing sporting events by altering the outcomes of games with inaccurate, subjective determinations.
Calls made by officials on the field are supposed to stand on replay review unless the calls are refuted by indisputable video evidence. Conversely, calls and non-calls on the field are supposed to be reversed when indisputable video evidence demonstrates the calls were incorrect. Unfortunately, however, the "indisputable video evidence" standard has proven elusive to replay officials.
For college football, the objective review standard is set forth succinctly in the NCAA Football Instant Replay Coaches Manual: "There must be indisputable video evidence for an on-field call to be changed by the Instant Replay Official."
The comparable standard of review applied by replay officials in Major League Baseball provides that on-field calls are only to be reversed due to "clear and convincing evidence."
Despite these clear, strict, mandatory standards, replay officials regularly spark controversy by rendering seemingly standardless determinations. A bevy of such controversial replay determinations impacted sporting events on Saturday, Oct. 5.
In the seventh inning of Game 1 of the Kansas City - New York AL divisional series, Yankees' third baseman Jazz Chisholm Jr. attempted to steal second base. As he slid foot-first, Royals' second baseman Michael Massey applied a tag, but the umpire on the field ruled Chisholm safe. Kansas City challenged the call, and the call was upheld despite video evidence showing separation between Chisholm's cleat and the bag while Massey's glove was on the cleat.
Safe or out? pic.twitter.com/Un5sZonGZi
— Baseball Quotes (@BaseballQuotes1) October 6, 2024
Viewing video footage of the play, TBS announcers Bob Costas and Ron Darling said the call would be reversed because Massey applied the tag when Chisholm's cleat was off the bag. However, the replay officials allowed the on-field safe call to stand. Later in the inning, Chisholm scored the game-winning run.
Former Royals player Eric Hosmer sharply criticized the replay ruling on X (formerly Twitter).
Disgusting ❗️who’s in the replay center tonight ⁉️ we deserve to hear what he saw #KCRoyals
— Eric Hosmer (@TheRealHos305) October 6, 2024
Other enigmatic replay determinations were made in college football games involving ranked teams.
In an ACC clash between SMU and Louisville, the Mustangs benefitted from a perplexing replay reversal. With the score tied in the fourth quarter, SMU's running back Brashard Smith fumbled in Louisville territory, and the Cardinals recovered the ball. The on-field call was a turnover. However, despite a lack of indisputable video evidence to justify reversing the call, the ACC replay crew in Charlotte, N.C. did precisely that.
ESPN rules analyst Matt Austin told the ESPN broadcasters that the reversal was improper.
"Yeah, I don't see how they got there. You really can't see the ball. The shin does go down, but you can't tell if the ball's coming out at that point."
A fumble from SMU RB Brashard Smith was overturned after review, with officials ruling that it was "clear and obvious" that Smith's shin was down with possession before the fumble.
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) October 5, 2024
Bob Wischusen on the ESPN call, with rules analyst Matt Austin chiming in. ️ pic.twitter.com/qi3dXQZDRd
The ACC replay crew then served up a nightcap of botched replay review in Miami's 39-38 comeback win over Cal. In a game-altering decision, replay officials allowed an on-field non-call to stand in the fourth quarter when Hurricanes linebacker Wesley Bissainthe delivered a brutal blow to Golden Bears quarterback Fernando Mendoza.
For anyone who missed it, this was the play in question. pic.twitter.com/5ubAy5xRpl
— The Comeback (@thecomeback) October 6, 2024
Trailing by 25 points in the third quarter, the Hurricanes had cut the deficit to 38-32 at the time of the controversial play. With under two minutes remaining, it would have been difficult for Miami to finish the comeback had targeting been called and Cal awarded a first down.
Replay review was instituted to help rid sports of incorrect calls that impact the outcomes of games. Instead, we're often left with more questions than answers, with controversial officiating remaining fron and center across sports. Replay officials need to get it right. Otherwise, what's the point?
More must-reads:
- Texas No. 1, Alabama falls to No. 7 in AP Top 25 poll
- Vanderbilt stuns No. 1 Alabama behind gritty effort from QB Diego Pavia
- The 'NFL all-time touchdown receptions leaders' quiz
Breaking News
Trending News
Customize Your Newsletter
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!
TODAY'S BEST
Colorado's Deion Sanders reveals massive medical problem he's been battling this offseason
Texas is One of Four College Football Teams With Top-5 Offense and Defense
A primary reason the Texas Longhorns are receiving significant hype this offseason is due to how talented the roster is. While many are focusing on quarterback phenom Arch Manning, Texas has several of the top players in the country at their respective positions. Linebacker Anthony Hill Jr. and pass rusher Colin Simmons are just a couple of names that fit that bill. When you take into account the talent and depth at each position, the Longhorns easily boast one of the best rosters in the country. According to PFF, Texas is one of only four schools to have a top-five offense (No. 3) and top-five defense (No. 2) this season. Alabama, Clemson, and Penn State are the other three programs. With so much hype surrounding the offensive playmakers for Texas this season it's easy to overlook the defensive side. However, it looks to be the strength of this team. The Longhorns have the No. 1 secondary led by safety Michael Taaffe and cornerback Malik Muhammad, while Hill and Simmons are returning All-Americans. One of Texas' few weaknesses last season was the special teams unit. Head coach Steve Sarkisian improved in that area this offseason by signing kicker Mason Shipley and punter Jack Boumeester. All that's left is for the Longhorns to go out and prove they're one of the best teams in the country.
OPINION: Which players need to take the biggest step for Alabama from year 1 to year 2?
Deion Sanders Jr. Gets Real About Coach Prime’s Struggles Since Shedeur Sanders’ Draft Slide
Kirk Cousins makes notable leadership move after Falcons practice
Kirk Cousins might be relegated to the job of backup quarterback, but he is showing veteran leadership to his Atlanta Falcons teammates. Following Sunday's practice, Cousins pulled aside rookie defensive end James Pearce to encourage the first-round pick after his fourth practice in the league at Flowery Branch, Georgia. "QB Kirk Cousins pulled aside Pearce after practice to compliment him on a pass batted down," wrote Marc Raimondi of ESPN. Cousins reportedly had a solid day of practice on Sunday, going 7-of-12 passing against the first-team unit. If Cousins wants out of Atlanta, he's not showing it at practice. The four-time Pro Bowl quarterback is competing on the field and being a good teammate around the facility. Cousins' actions on the field backed up what Falcons general manager Terry Fontenot praised Cousins for before the team's practice on Sunday. “Outside, it's a lot more of a deal than it is in the building,” Fontenot said to the media about the idea of friction between the Falcons and Cousins, per video from D. Orlando Ledbetter of the Atlanta Journal Constitution. “He shows up, he does his job, just like anybody ... We've gotta build the best 70-man roster so we can go win games. "That's what we're focused on, and Kirk, just like all the other players, is focused on coming in here and doing their job. That's what he's been doing." Fontenot didn't dismiss the idea that Atlanta would trade Cousins before the season. He said the Falcons will do whatever it takes to make the team better, but stressed that Cousins has been a professional throughout the process of being replaced by Michael Penix Jr., a first-round pick from the 2024 draft. “In terms of making moves, whether it's trades or acquiring players, we're always looking at those factors," Fontenot said. "We're gonna do whatever we can do to make this team the best it can possibly be. But he's been a great professional, and he's handled himself well.” Cousins is coming to work in a manner that will make another owner want to take a chance on the veteran quarterback. That could be one of his best-selling points before he plays in his 13th season in the league.
Oilers to Acquire a Top-Tier Goalie. An Official Trade Offer Is on the Table in a Blockbuster Deal
Steelers reporter shares big claim about how Aaron Rodgers has looked in training camp
Quarterback Aaron Rodgers spent the bulk of the spring as an unsigned free agent and, thus, only began officially practicing with Pittsburgh Steelers teammates during the team's three-day mandatory minicamp in June. During a Monday appearance on Pittsburgh radio station 102.5 WDVE, Steelers reporter Gerry Dulac of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette addressed how Rodgers looked during his first few training camp practices with the club. "His release is just astonishing to watch," Dulac said about Rodgers, as shared by Ross McCorkle of Steelers Depot. "Everybody knows about it, and when you see it in person, you see it every day in practice, you just marvel at it. To me, he's the greatest thrower of the football I have ever seen, even at 41 (years old). That flick of that wrist and that ball comes out, it's moving and it is something to see." Rodgers was with the New York Jets when he suffered a torn Achilles four offensive snaps into the 2023 regular-season opener. He was then slowed by a nagging hip issue, injuries to both his knees, a low ankle sprain and a serious hamstring problem as the 2024 Jets went 5-12. According to Pro Football Reference, Rodgers finished last season ranked 28th in the NFL among qualified players with a 48.0 adjusted QBR and 26th with a 43.9 percent passing success rate. That said, he was also eighth with 3,897 passing yards and tied for seventh with 28 passing touchdowns. Rodgers and Jets wide receiver Garrett Wilson endured some struggles during training camp sessions last summer before the two allegedly "never saw eye-to-eye" during the season. It sounds like Pittsburgh fans should be encouraged by how Rodgers performed in recent practices. "That guy can get rid of the ball as quick as anybody," Dulac added. "He made three throws in seven-on-seven (drills) the other day that the cumulative total I bet couldn't have exceeded 2.1 seconds. And two of those were for touchdowns." Rodgers wants to finish his career "the right way" and help the Steelers notch at least their first playoff win since January 2017. As of Monday morning, DraftKings Sportsbook had Pittsburgh at -150 betting odds to miss the playoffs for the upcoming season.
Cubs in danger of making enormous trade-deadline mistake
Boasting a 62-44 record in the NL Central, the Chicago Cubs are still searching for a way to pull ahead of the Milwaukee Brewers. The Brewers took sole possession of first place in the division from the Cubs in an 8-4 win on Monday. Chicago will get its chance before the three-game set is over, but if the Cubs should fall to the Brewers, the trade deadline will be viewed as essential for their World Series chances. Several rumors of Chicago’s interest in starters, relievers and third basemen have swirled nonstop. And while they have shown interest in several quality names — Mitch Keller, Eugenio Suárez, MacKenzie Gore — some of their other trade targets are less than ideal. Among their worst sources of interest (if not, the worst) is struggling Braves reliever Raisel Iglesias, who is in his walk year. Hiding behind his shining 2.99 career ERA is a rather shocking, career-high 4.97 ERA, to which he has pitched this season. He is still a strikeout pitcher, having accumulated 46 Ks in 41.2 innings, but his run prevention capabilities have seemingly deteriorated. It was only last season when Iglesias posted a stellar 1.95 ERA. Since then, his home run total doubled, from surrendering just four last year to eight so far this year. His opponent batting average has also jumped, from .160 to .250. Iglesias is no stranger to success. He threw to ERAs south of 3.00 in eight of his 11 MLB years. However, this season, he just doesn’t appear to have it. Any team that trades for Iglesias in the last year of his contract would be betting that he can return to elite form before the season is over. Taking a risk on a pitcher like Iglesias in his current condition, especially when there are several other more reliable arms on the market, would be ill-advised. And for the Cubs, who are in a win-now position, having secured one guaranteed year of Kyle Tucker, taking a gamble on Iglesias could easily risk everything they worked for this season.
PRIVACY POLICY EDITORIAL POLICY CONTACT US
ABOUT YARDBARKER TERMS OF SERVICE
Use of this website (including any and all parts and
components) constitutes your acceptance of these
Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
This site is for entertainment purposes only.
There is no gambling offered on this site.
Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-Gambler.
