
Josh Allen and the Buffalo Bills are going to have to wait at least one more year to try to win a Super Bowl. Their season came to a brutal end on Saturday night in a 33-30 loss to the Denver Broncos, and there are countless plays Allen and the Bills are going to be replaying in their minds this offseason.
Anytime a team loses by three points in overtime, there are going to be countless plays they look back at and play the "what if" game with. Allen is going to have a lot of regrets from this game.
Specifically, as it relates to turnovers.
Allen turned the ball over four times on Saturday, including two game-changing fumbles that bookended halftime.
With the Bills already trailing by seven points, and with 17 seconds to play in the half, Allen tried to do a little too much in a high-risk, low-reward situation. He ended up fumbling the ball, handing Denver three points it never would have had before halftime.
Broncos ball!
— NFL (@NFL) January 17, 2026
What a break before the half
BUFvsDEN on CBS/Paramount+
Stream on @NFLPlus pic.twitter.com/317eodiE90
He then opened the second half by again fumbling the ball away, leading to another Broncos field goal.
Those are six free points that Allen handed Denver. You simply can not do that in a playoff game.
He was also intercepted twice in the second half, including once in overtime.
That overtime interception was just one of several close calls the Bills came out on the wrong side of.
The first borderline call in overtime came on Allen's second interception of the game when wide receiver Brandin Cooks nearly came down with a catch, only to have the ball wrestled away from him by Ja'Quan McMillian
What a play in OT by Ja'Quan McMillian
— NFL (@NFL) January 18, 2026
BUFvsDEN on CBS/Paramount+
Stream on @NFLPlus pic.twitter.com/noqikIoPQC
Did Cooks have possession of the ball when he hit the ground? Buffalo would certainly argue that he did. The officials and replay officials did not agree. That gave Denver the ball with a chance to win the game.
It was at that point that the Broncos were moved down the field by a pair of defensive pass interference penalties. That includes a really controversial one that put Denver inside the Buffalo 10-yard line. Those are the calls that are going to be controversial in Buffalo, even more than the Cooks non-catch.
It is just another gut-punch loss for a franchise that has known nothing but gut-punch losses.
The big question for the Broncos was whether or not their offense could score enough to complement what has been an outstanding defense. A lot of the pressure was going to fall on second-year quarterback Bo Nix, who was widely regarded as the weakest quarterback remaining in the playoffs.
He silenced a lot of the doubters on Saturday by throwing for three touchdowns and matching Allen point for point. Now he has the Broncos one win away from the Super Bowl.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!