
Sometimes, owners say the darnedest things.
On Wednesday, Buffalo Bills owner Terry Pegula sat behind a podium and delivered one of the worst end-of-season NFL news conferences in recent memory.
From his reasoning behind firing former head coach Sean McDermott to a stunning admission regarding 2024 second-round pick Keon Coleman, here are the five wildest things we learned as the Bills embark on a pivotal offseason.
The biggest doozy was Pegula interjecting when general manager Brandon Beane was speaking to tell reporters that Coleman, the No. 33 overall pick of the 2024 NFL Draft, was "pushed" onto Beane by the previous coaching staff.
Per ESPN Bills writer Alaina Getzenberg, Pegula emphasized that Coleman wasn't Beane's first choice and that Beane was simply being a "team player" by acquiescing to the coaching staff's wishes.
Bills owner Terry Pegula on Keon Coleman: "The coaching staff pushed to pick Keon." Said Coleman wasn't at the top of Beane's list and that he was being a team player with the pick. Pegula interrupted a Beane answer to make that known.
— Alaina Getzenberg (@agetzenberg.bsky.social) 2026-01-21T15:14:46.973Z
I’ve never seen anything like this publicly before: #Bills owner Terry Pegula just said that WR Keon Coleman was a draft pick that the coaching staff pushed for, and that GM Brandon Beane had other players higher on his board.
— Arye Pulli (@AryePulliNFL) January 21, 2026
Can’t imagine that Coleman will be back after this. pic.twitter.com/2JSUzdgKY6
That's absurd on multiple levels. As former Wisconsin quarterback Nate Tice wondered aloud on Bluesky, "Isn't a member of that coaching staff one of the lead candidates for the HC job?"
lol isn’t a member of that coaching staff one of the lead candidates for the HC job?
— Nate Tice (@natetice.bsky.social) 2026-01-21T15:32:07.993Z
Indeed, The Athletic NFL insider Dianna Russini shared earlier Wednesday that offensive coordinator Joe Brady will interview for the head coach opening.
The Bills will interview offensive coordinator Joe Brady for the team’s head coaching vacancy, per source.
— Dianna Russini (@DMRussini) January 21, 2026
Brady, who has received interview requests and met with other teams in this cycle, will get a look in Buffalo. pic.twitter.com/nlN4XKP5nf
It's even worse that Pegula commented on a player with two years remaining on his rookie contract. Coleman has by no means lived up to expectations, finishing his first two seasons with 960 receiving yards, but it's far too early to close the book on the 6-foot-4 wideout.
That's what Pegula may have just done. The next coach is inheriting a player the front office doesn't even want, making it unclear what kind of future, if any, Coleman has in Buffalo.
Pegula also revealed the decision to fire McDermott came down to the divisional-round overtime loss against the Denver Broncos.
Bills owner Terry Pegula said his decision to bring in a new coach was "based on the results of our game in Denver."
— Alaina Getzenberg (@agetzenberg.bsky.social) 2026-01-21T14:57:39.633Z
Basing a decision on one result is a foolish way to run an organization. And it isn't as though McDermott told quarterback Josh Allen to inexplicably fumble late in the second quarter to gift the Broncos three crucial points or had any control over the referees' (correct) interception call in overtime that erased a potential deep completion to Brandin Cooks.
McDermott coached well in tough circumstances, with his defense making key stops off turnovers to keep the game close enough to send it to overtime. Overall, the Bills out-gained the Broncos by 100 yards, 449-349. McDermott was the least of Buffalo's problems against Denver, making the decision to fire him because of the result even more perplexing.
McDermott's dismissal came without consulting Allen beforehand.
"He didn't have any input at all," Pegula said. "I didn't talk to Josh about this. I talked to him afterwards."
Bills owner Terry Pegula said that QB Josh Allen didn't have any input on the decision to fire Sean McDermott, but that he did talk to Allen about it after, and he'll keep that conversation private.
— Alaina Getzenberg (@agetzenberg.bsky.social) 2026-01-21T15:17:44.096Z
Terry Pegula says he did not talk to Josh Allen ahead of the firing HC Sean McDermott
— Jenna Cottrell (@JennaCottrell) January 21, 2026
"he had no input in it"@buffaloplus #bills pic.twitter.com/T5DGViZqtB
McDermott is the only NFL head coach Allen's had. It would seem like a smart choice to go to the franchise quarterback before making the consequential decision, yet that's not what Pegula did.
Allen and ownership need to be on the same page. As integral as he is to the team's success, Allen should have been plugged in from the start.
Pegula wasn't alone in spouting nonsense. Beane gave insight into the team's restructured front office after he was given the title of president of football operations on Monday to go along with his previous role as general manager.
When asked for clarification about the setup, Beane said, "We're gonna operate very similar to what we've been doing."
Asked Brandon Beane to clarify that the new coach will be reporting to him: "Yes." And will someone else take over the GM role under him at some point: "No, I'll be the GM. ... We're gonna operate very similar than what we've been doing."
— Alaina Getzenberg (@agetzenberg.bsky.social) 2026-01-21T15:58:33.085Z
If the Bills think firing McDermott is all that's necessary to get over the hump, they're sorely mistaken. Beane hasn't had much success acquiring difference-makers via trade, free agency or the draft in recent years, helping explain the team's shortcomings. Buffalo needed to shake up the status quo. Instead, it's leaning into it.
As if those comments weren't bad enough, Beane also shared that Allen could undergo a procedure on his right foot this offseason.
Beane attempted to assuage concerns by saying Allen should still be available for OTAs, but any time a mobile threat like the 2024 MVP has lower leg problems, that's a red flag.
Bills GM Brandon Beane said that QB Josh Allen may have to have something done to his right foot, in terms of a procedure, but that it wouldn't impact his availability for OTAs if he does.
— Alaina Getzenberg (@agetzenberg.bsky.social) 2026-01-21T15:45:22.308Z
Like Los Angeles Rams quarterback Matthew Stafford's back this past preseason, Allen's right foot might be much ado about nothing by the time the 2026 season arrives. But during a Bills offseason that's already wild, we should expect the unexpected.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!