
In last year's Eastern Conference Finals, the New York Knicks blew a huge lead late in the fourth quarter of Game 1 and lost in overtime, thanks to hot three-point shooting from the Indiana Pacers and the heroics of All-Star point guard Tyrese Haliburton.
In Tuesday's Game 1, the Knicks flipped the script. They were the team that made a huge fourth-quarter comeback behind three-point shots and the heroics of All-Star point guard Jalen Brunson, beating the Cleveland Cavaliers in overtime, 115-104.
The Knicks were down by 22 points with under eight minutes to play, which left their win probability for the game at a minuscule 0.1 percent. The Pacers had a win probability of 0.2 percent last year when they trailed by 14 points with 3:44 to go. What changed the mathematics for both teams was three-point shooting and a guard who couldn't miss.
Brunson spearheaded an 18-1 run that got the Knicks back in the game, scoring 13 of the Knicks' points and assisting on another basket, forcing a Cleveland timeout when his three-pointer cut the lead to five points.
JALEN BRUNSON IS CLUTCH.
— ESPN (@espn) May 20, 2026
18-1 RUN FOR THE KNICKS pic.twitter.com/NASzU8hPX0
Brunson was untouchable, but the Knicks breaking out of a wretched three-point slump was huge. After starting the game 4-of-24 behind the arc, they went 5-of-6 from deep in the last eight minutes, with Landry Shamet and Mikal Bridges each hitting twice from distance.
Last year, Haliburton looked like he beat the Knicks with a three-pointer at the buzzer of Game 1, only for it to be ruled a two-pointer since his foot was on the line. Sam Merrill almost ruined the big comeback when his three-pointer went in and out in the final seconds, nearly relegating the Knicks' effort to a footnote. By contrast, Shamet's game-tying three-pointer a few possessions earlier went in thanks to a bounce almost as improbable as the Knicks erasing a 22-point lead.
Landry Shamet gets the friendly bounce on a 3-pointer to tie the game, James Harden hits the turnaround jumper over Brunson to give the Knicks the lead, Brunson scores to tie the game.
— MrBuckBuck (@MrBuckBuckNBA) May 20, 2026
Sam Merrill's 3-pointer goes in and out and WE ARE GOING TO OVERTIME IN MSG pic.twitter.com/12eJhZkepM
The comeback seemed to affect the Cavaliers like a gut punch. The Knicks scored the first nine points of overtime and outscored the Cavs 14-3 in the extra period. Perhaps it was the exhaustion of playing two seven-game series catching up to them, but it was an absolutely brutal loss.
Especially since the last three Eastern Conference NBA finalists won the first game of the conference finals. The Cavaliers may have missed their best chance to steal a game in the series. The Knicks exorcised the ghost of last year's Game 1 meltdown at Madison Square Garden and have now won eight straight games. They can't rely on erasing a 22-point lead every game, but they can rely on Brunson.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!