x
Declining Inter Miami, rising Colorado Rapids meet as equals
Colorado Rapids midfielder Paxten Aaronson. Denny Medley-Imagn Images

Declining Inter Miami, rising Colorado Rapids meet as equals to show off MLS' ever-changing power structure

The 2026 Major League Soccer season has been full of surprises, but few have raised more eyebrows than the decline of Inter Miami and the rise of the Colorado Rapids.

Miami entered the season as the league's defending champion but failed to integrate new players and lost its charismatic coach. Colorado entered the season as a low-investment, small-market team, but blew past its expectations thanks to smart gambles on talent.

The two sides meet on Saturday, and in a shocking twist, they meet as literal equals. They're level on points with 12 apiece, and their opposite journeys prove that there's more than one way to be successful in a league as dynamic as MLS.

But how did those journeys come about?

Miami's big-money meltdown

On paper, no MLS team should be riding higher than Miami. It won the 2025 MLS Cup in grand style, then built on that victory by signing four league-leading players across the field: Dayne St. Clair in goal, Sergio Reguilon in defense, Rodrigo de Paul in midfield and German Berterame in attack. All four had lifted their teams in 2025; all four looked set to make Miami unbeatable in 2026.

It didn't quite work out that way. Miami's new hires have struggled to find their footing in South Florida. There's a growing sense that St. Clair, Reguilon, De Paul and Berterame are all excellent players, but not necessarily excellent Miami players despite their splashy arrivals.

Miami's new-look side kicked off its season with a humiliating 3-0 defeat to LAFC that hinted at drama within the squad. (Captain Lionel Messi was seen following the referees into their locker room after the match, something other MLS players have received multi-game bans for attempting.) The team then crashed out of the Concacaf Champions Cup — North America's biggest and most prestigious soccer tournament — to MLS rival Nashville SC. Miami crushed Nashville in several competitions in 2025; it was sobering to see the reverse happen after Miami spent so much money to improve.

Miami coach Javier Mascherano shocked the league by announcing his mid-season departure from the club. No one knows what drove his decision — there are reports of a bust-up with Messi, but they are not definitive — but his departure leaves Miami in a difficult place.

All the investment but no stability to speak of: That's been Miami's unfortunate path in 2026.

Colorado's risk-forward rise 

While Miami was busy winning the 2025 MLS Cup, Colorado was at home, licking its wounds after missing out on the Western Conference playoffs on a tiebreaker. The Commerce City side, one of MLS' Original 10 franchises, had done well to even get itself that close to the postseason. It kicked off 2025 with a piecemeal roster of largely domestic players, and it couldn't compete with most of MLS on a man-to-man basis. Talent matters in the end, and Colorado simply didn't have enough of it.

The club rebuilt, staking its future on former Tottenham Hotspur assistant Matt Wells. It was Wells' first time coaching a senior men's team, but the Colorado staff believed he had the guts to get things done. 

"From literally the very first meeting we had with Matt, we finished up, and when Matt logged off, the five of us looked at each other like, ‘Woah, we’ve got a guy here,’” said Colorado president Padraig Smith. “With each passing meeting, it became crystal clear he was the right guy for us.”

Wells was a risky appointment, and he compounded that by bringing a risky style to the table, one biased toward aggression and excitement despite Colorado's clear talent deficit. 

"The word I use a lot with the players is ‘Dominate,’” Wells said. “Every game starts with the mindset that we are the big team on the pitch."

It's worked. Colorado has struggled against big MLS teams this season — it was always expected to do so — but it has hammered its peers using Wells's philosophy. 4-1 over the LA Galaxy. 6-2 over Houston. This Colorado team is closing its talent gap through pure, unbridled mental strength.

It's closing it on the field, too, but it's doing so in an unorthodox way. Colorado signed USMNT fringe candidate Paxten Aaronson on a Designated Player contract, then brought in ex-Seattle winger Georgi Minoungou to service him. Both players are young and relatively untested — Aaronson is 22 and Minoungou is 23 — but they've got the speed and athleticism to mold perfectly into Well's desired system.

Building the team around them was a gamble, but it was a gamble that paid off almost immediately, and one that highlights just how poor Miami's big-money recruitment wound up being.

Inter Miami will visit the Colorado Rapids on Saturday at 4:30 p.m. ET.

Alyssa Clang

Alyssa is a Boston-born Californian with a passion for global sport. She can yell about misplaced soccer passes in five languages and rattle off the turns of Silverstone in her sleep. You can find her dormant Twitter account at @alyssaclang, but honestly, you’re probably better off finding her here

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!