During the summer of 2025, Andre Onana endured the most difficult spell of his Manchester United career as injuries and mistakes cost him his place in the side. After a season full of inconsistency, his hamstring problem kept him out of most of the preseason and meant he was unprepared when the campaign began. His absence gave Altay Bayindir the chance to claim the goalkeeping spot.
The Carabao Cup defeat to Grimsby Town, where Onana’s errors proved costly, became the breaking point for Ruben Amorim. The club reacted swiftly by signing Senne Lammens on deadline day, while Onana moved to Trabzonspor on loan. In the background, the board continued exploring long-term planning. There are whispers of possible replacements for Amorim, and even the club has shortlisted three possible replacements for Ruben Amorim. There is serious uncertainty surrounding the club.
Fabrizio Romano has offered a clear assessment of the Onana saga. He insisted on his YouTube channel that both Manchester United and the goalkeeper see their relationship as virtually over. He reported that Onana felt deeply disappointed with how the summer unfolded and that the club views Senne Lammens as the main option both now and for the coming years.
Romano added that unless something remarkable happens, the Trabzonspor loan leads to a permanent exit rather than a comeback. This perspective leaves little doubt that United intend to move forward without Onana. In the same vein of ongoing stories, reports reveal that Tottenham Hotspur lock horns with Manchester United to sign Yehor Yarmolyuk. The club’s transfer activity remains aggressive and wide-ranging as they attempt to reinforce several areas of the squad.
“My understanding is that both sides – Man Utd and Andre Onana himself – see this Man Utd chapter as almost closed.
“So it’s very difficult to imagine Onana staying at Man Utd beyond [next summer]. Very difficult because Onana was quite disappointed with the situation this summer.
“Man Utd believe that Senne Lammens is going to be the goalkeeper for the present and future, so unless something extraordinary happens, [Onana’s deal] is a straight loan and he might go somewhere else in the future, but it’s over between Man Utd and Onana probably.”
Manchester United’s decision to consider a full parting with Andre Onana is both justified and overdue. He never delivered the confidence and the performances that United fans demanded. The fans watched mistake after mistake erode confidence, while the Premier League exposed his weaknesses under constant pressure.
Such flaws hurt the team’s results, and Amorim’s trust in him quickly faded. The costly gamble to sign the 29-year-old goalkeeper has not paid off, and if United keep him, it would only prolong the uncertainty. The current loan move to Trabzonspor may help the Cameroon international rediscover form, but for United, it only matters if it boosts his value and lets the club secure a permanent transfer in 2026. United need that clarity to avoid another prolonged saga that distracts from genuine progress.
The arrival of Senne Lammens on deadline day showed intent, yet we strongly believe the club cannot afford to stop there. Manchester United require a goalkeeper of proven calibre to challenge Lammens and provide a dependable presence. Mike Maignan at AC Milan fits that mould perfectly with his pedigree, consistency, and contract situation, making him an achievable target in 2026. His qualities would give United the security Onana failed to provide, and at the same time push Lammens with the competition he needs to develop. A strong goalkeeping department is the backbone of a title-challenging side.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!