Manchester United's humiliating Carabao Cup exit to League Two Grimsby Town has left fans upset. The obvious question: Is Rúben Amorim going to get fired?
The Reds were 2–0 down at halftime and fought back to take it to penalties but ultimately lost 12–11 after Bryan Mbeumo missed his penalty. It was a night to forget and it's sparked all the usual speculation about Rúben Amorim's job.
No manager since 2010 has taken fewer games to hit 15 PL losses, excluding those who took charge of a newly-promoted club during that period, than Ruben Amorim pic.twitter.com/ptAx8Asn43
— Transfermarkt.co.uk (@TMuk_news) August 18, 2025
For now though, it seems Amorim is still in place. There's been no word from Sir Jim Ratcliffe or the Manchester United board that they're about to get rid of him.
And while patience is wearing thin among fans, the hierarchy hasn't budged. Unless Amorim resigns, he should be in charge for the rest of the new Premier League season.
That doesn't mean his position is safe. Manchester United have now lost their first three games of the 2025/26 season, to Arsenal, Fulham and Grimsby.
Add in last season's struggles, seven wins from 29 league games, 15 defeats and 15th place, and it's a mess.
Amorim has lost 15 Premier League games faster than any United manager in over a decade, a stat that raises questions about his ability to turn it around.
The Grimsby defeat is particularly bad because of what it means. United has been humiliated in the cups before, most notably the 4–0 loss to MK Dons in 2014, but this last defeat is worse.
Fans have been ruthless, with social media cries for his head growing louder in the hours after the game.
Sir Jim Ratcliffe has a very tough decision to make... pic.twitter.com/K4Ozlhn4aG
— SPORTbible (@sportbible) August 28, 2025
But after the Europa League final loss in May, sources had confirmed that the board continues to back Amorim as part of a long-term project. And that patience hasn't snapped yet, even after the embarrassment at Blundell Park.
One major reason the board may be reluctant is the financial outlay. If United sack Amorim, they could owe him around €14m million in compensation and close to £20 million when you include his backroom staff (Footballtransfers).
That payout clause makes any rapid decision costly. Amorim has publicly maintained that he would leave without charge if he felt unwanted, but without walking away himself, dismissing him would be an expensive decision.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!