Mid-Season Grades: Arsenal Defender and Goalkeeper Player Ratings

At the halfway point of the season, it is time to hand out mid-season grades to the Gunners. We begin with the goalkeepers and defenders, whose performances have played a major role in Arsenal’s campaign so far.

Goalkeepers

David Raya (GK) – 9

The Spaniard’s concentration levels have improved dramatically in 2025. Due to the defensive structure in front of him, the 30-year-old often has matches where he has very little to do, meaning his focus must remain world class throughout. Whether acting as a sweeper or judging when to come and collect a cross, Raya regularly takes the pressure off the back four. Raya claimed back-to-back Premier League Golden Glove Awards in 2023-24 and 2024-25.

Kepa (GK) – 6

Kepa has not disgraced himself in his three EFL Cup starts so far. He will feel far more integrated after his penalty save against Crystal Palace, which helped Arsenal reach the semi-finals.

Defenders

Lewis-Skelly (LB) – 5

The consensus since the teenager made his debut has been that he is excellent going forward but prone to defensive mistakes. This explains why Mikel Arteta has trusted the left-back to start only once in the league this season. Even in cameo appearances, opponents appear to target him due to his positioning. As a result, the 19-year-old has lost his place in England’s squad, although learning through this period will be part of his development.

Calafiori (LB) – 9

It is strange to think that this time last year some Gooners were suggesting the defender should be allowed to return to Italy. The issue was never the 23-year-old’s talent, but his ability to enjoy a sustained run in the team. The Italian continues to redefine the left-back role, carrying the ball forward while also knowing when to step into midfield. He is also a constant aerial threat.

Hincapie (LB/CB) – 7

Hincapie appears more comfortable at left-back. His first Premier League start did not arrive until the North London derby, where he played at centre-back. Due to injuries, the 23-year-old has rarely had a settled partner in central defence. The Ecuadorian can handle physical opponents when teams go direct, although he can be a little rash in possession. Arsenal are obliged to make his loan permanent for £52 million, and it remains debatable whether he has fully justified that fee so far.

Timber (RB/CB) – 9

The Netherlands are spoilt for choice at right-back, but on current form Timber may be among the best in the world, particularly in one-v-one defending. That reliability explains why he can also be trusted as a centre-back. His understanding with Bukayo Saka continues to improve.