Ruben Amorim’s time at Manchester United will forever be defined by his refusal to bend on a single tactical idea, regardless of the results piling up against him.
He arrived in November 2024 with a rigid 3-4-3 system that had worked wonders at Sporting, only to be warned from the outset that reshaping United’s squad to fit it would take money the club simply didn’t have.
That stubbornness produced some genuinely painful moments, from being mocked for pulling out a tactics board during the infamous Carabao Cup exit at Grimsby, to insisting even a defeat to Newcastle wouldn’t change his approach, famously declaring “not even the Pope” could make him switch systems.
He was eventually sacked in January after 14 months in charge, leaving with a win percentage of just 32%, the worst of any permanent United manager in the Premier League era, having lost a third of his overall matches at the club.
His first meeting with his old side since then came in a pre-season friendly last month, where his AC Milan side came from behind twice to beat Michael Carrick’s United 4-2.
Amorim’s Milan side picked up a convincing 3-0 win over Lecce on Sunday, but the biggest talking point wasn’t the scoreline, it was the Portuguese coach appearing to move away from his usual system entirely, something he never once did during his time at Old Trafford.
Milan had fallen to defeat against Benfica in the Europa League last week and were winless in three across all competitions, prompting Amorim to react by fielding a flat back four for the first time this season.
Mario Gila operated as a right-back within a clear midfield three, a structural shift that would have been unthinkable during his rigid final months at United.
Speaking after the win, Amorim admitted, “These are different times, but we’re improving.
“Today the players had more freedom; in recent games we were a bit too static, stuck.”
He went further still, addressing his past directly, “I can’t repeat my mistakes from Manchester. If we don’t have the characteristics to play a certain way, we have to adapt.”
Reports in Italy suggest the shift followed an emergency meeting summoned by Milan executives after the Benfica defeat, with Gazzetta dello Sport indicating the club’s hierarchy still retain confidence in their coach for now, even if the sudden nature of the meeting hinted at growing unease behind the scenes.
It’s a strikingly different tone to the one Amorim struck throughout his final months in Manchester, when he repeatedly insisted he would rather change his players than his philosophy.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!