All Players in Madden 25 99 Club

Back-to-back Super Bowl champion quarterback Patrick Mahomes is the only one at his position in the Madden 25 99 Club. Mahomes has a 99 Awareness rating, as does every member of the 99 Club. Sitting undefeated, it is unlikely the quarterback will drop in ratings this year. The elusive Quarterback has an 87 rating for Speed, Agility, and Change Of Direction, ranking him among the best in the game.

Tyreek Hill the star Wide Receiver from the Miami Dolphins is currently at 99 overall putting him in the Madden 25 99 Club. Being one of the fastest players in Madden 25 Hill has multiple assets that put him above the rest. Strength is the weakest point in the players’ game with a 64 rating, every other general statistic has a 90 or above rating. Hill is an offensive threat despite the injury of Miami QB Tua Tagovailoa.

Cover Athlete

The cover athlete and star 49er Running Back Christian McCaffrey remains at the top with a 99 overall rating. While dealing with injuries recently McCaffrey still has some of the most consistent ratings in rushing and receiving. This combination of being able to catch and run makes him a massive threat to defenses. A lot of fans are concerned about the health of the star Running Back but whether the Madden cover curse is real or not the 49er is bound to remain at the top.

More 99s

Two more players are currently in the Madden 25 99 Club, one of them being the Tight End and teammate to Mahomes, Travis Kelce. A 94 Toughness rating makes him difficult to tackle for defenses, and Kelce is one of the best Tight Ends in Madden history. The final member of the 99 Club and teammate to Running Back Christian McCaffrey is Trent Williams. This Left Tackle is nearly impossible to get past, every rating in blocking is above a 90 rating.

No players on defense are currently in the Madden 25 99 Club, a lot of games remain for a defensive player to step up. With 4 of the 5 players in the 99 Club being on either the Kansas City Chiefs or San Francisco 49ers, the 2 teams who met in the Super Bowl last year have a clear advantage. The ratings in Madden 25 update every week, and the chance of another player joining the 99 Club is high. As a player can rise up to 99 overall they can fall in ratings as well. Kelce for the moment is having a rough start to his season, and if it continues, he may drop.