Originally posted on The B1g Time  |  Last updated 6/27/13


One of the most widely help opinions about Penn State's future success is it's inability to win with the scholarship limitations that came as a result of the Evil Jerry scandal. Penn State will be limited to 65 scholarships where as a normal FBS school is allowed 85 scholarship players. 

I like to introduce topics and viewpoints counter to those that become widely accepted and this one really got me thinking. Why can’t Penn State succeed with 65 scholarship players when an NFL team plays with a 53 man roster every Sunday?

Enter Bill O’Brien. Why couldn't a guy who coached in the NFL not succeed with a larger pool of players at the collegiate level? 

To be sure, the NFL vs. College models are different, but Bill O'Brien's NFL experience is key to this argument. He rose through the college and pro ranks and gained an intimate knowledge of how rosters work at both levels. He understands that there are positions on the field that require full time starters with significant experience. But he also recognizes that there are places where a non scholarship player (free agent) can fit in and contribute. 

Before I go any further I threw the question out on twitter a couple days ago and I got a few arguments against this point:

@TimTolleyFS: @TheB1GTimePSU because they're not playing against teams with 53 man rosters and have no flexibility, i.e. free agency.

@TheB1GTimePSU Really? NFL is 53 vs. 53. PSU is 65 vs. 85.

@TheB1GTimePSU The talent of free agents in the pros is much higher than walk ons.

@TheB1GTimePSU injuries will destroy PSU depth and force too many walk ons into action


I can offer some support to the argument that O'Brien could not only succeed with 65 scholarship players, but thrive. 

FOR THE MOST PART this season Penn State will be 3 scholarship players deep at every one of the 22 positions (66 scholarship players at last count). There will be a heavy rotation at some positions while others will only see action on special teams. 

An NFL roster does not have this luxury. Most positions are not 3 deep and many starting players are forced to play special teams. An NFL roster does not have the ability to dress an additional players that can step in at any time as Penn State does with it’s stable of walk ons. 

Penn State will be allowed to have as many players on the sideline as any other team in the coming years, there will just be a disproportionate amount of walk ons. Football is football no matter what level it is played at. The people on the sidelines who don’t contribute during a game have the same impact in pee wee as they do in college and the pro’s. The players on the field make the plays to win games. Depth is only a concern when you start subtracting players for injury.

An NFL team that has injuries has the ability to go out to the free agent market and sign players. But are those players anywhere near the caliber of the players that are on the field? Would some free agent picked up in the middle of the season be as good a linebacker as Navarro Bowman? No, and those teams still find ways to win. 

Translate this to another college team. If Ryan Shazier goes down for Ohio State, is the player who steps in behind him as good as he is? No. There is a reason those players are buried on the depth chart no matter if they are on scholarship or not. 

No college football team plans on playing all 85 scholarship players every game. No college team plans on injuries. If a team gets hit with a catastrophic injury bug and has to dig deep into their reserves of course the product on the field will suffer. 

Just because Penn State is missing one scholarship player per position buried on the depth chart means they can’t win like everyone else? Is a true freshman on scholarship a better player than a walk on who has been in the system for years? 

Remember walk ons at major college football programs were usually the best players on their HS teams and are accomplished athletes. Penn State won’t be throwing a bunch of intramural flag football players out there to compete.

Professional teams win week in and week out with a 53 man roster. They move some pieces around throughout the year, but count on their starting 22 players to win championships.

You disagree or think you can add support to this opinion get at me on twitter @TheB1GTimePSU

Way-too-early look at Heisman favorites in 2017
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Andy Reid: Chiefs can win with Alex Smith

Romo likely to pick team he wants to be traded to

David Ortiz slams door on rumors of potential comeback

JJ Watt said to be ahead of schedule in back injury recovery

Seahawks expect Earl Thomas to be ready for 2017 season


SD moving companies refusing to help Chargers relocate

Brown could be fined for sharing Tomlin's speech on Facebook

Future denies being on Falcons sideline to mess with Wilson

Green to wear 'Sideline Racism' shoes on MLK Day

Bill O'Brien refuses to commit to Osweiler as Texans' starter

Report: 'Good chance' Chip Kelly gets offer from Jaguars

The week in NFL news as explained by Heart

The 10 best sports docs available for streaming

The Mulligan: Why Chip Kelly deserves a second chance after the Niners

College coaches on the NFL's radar as the coaching carousel starts spinning

Best of Yardbarker: How to hop on NFL playoff bandwagons

Everything sports fans need to know about the Nintendo Switch

TailGreater: Picking the NFL divisional round games by hometown brews

The sports classic horror villains would play

Guilt-free guide to NFL playoff bandwagon fun

Box Score 1/13: Warming up for the playoff weekend

Complicated feelings for Tyreek Hill, others as playoffs progress

NFL Divisional Round watchablity index

College Football News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

The week in NFL news as explained by Heart

The 10 best sports docs available for streaming

QUIZ: Name every Pittsburgh Steelers Defensive Pro-Bowler in the Super Bowl Era

Best of Yardbarker: How to hop on NFL playoff bandwagons

Everything sports fans need to know about the Nintendo Switch

The sports classic horror villains would play

Complicated feelings for Tyreek Hill and others as playoffs progress

NFL Divisional Round watchablity index

QUIZ: Name the 12 members of the San Diego Chargers in the NFL Hall of Fame

NBA referee hotline bling: Green reaches out to touch somebody

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Follow Yardbarker