My take on why Nathan's 2008 contest overtime was NOT necessary (photos too)!

Although it's been only a few days since the annual Nathan's 4th of July hotdog contest, I thought I would write something about it. Once I got back home to San Jose the night of contest, I began to wonder... should there have been a tiebreaker (with the 5 dog eat off) with Takeru Kobayashi and Joey Chestnut? Within the first 2 hours of my shift at work Sunday morning, I was approached by my coworkers and managers who knew I would closely follow the contest (and competitive eating itself), they asked for my opinon; was it really that close of a tie? So, I started doing research and video recaps from ESPN, youtube, and etc.

Now, in my opinion, there should have been no 5 dog eat off whatsoever, because based on the stills I have captured from various videos available online, it shows that Kobayashi still had about 1/4 to 1/2 a hot dog and bun left in his hand (outside of his mouth) after the buzzer. If you compare the two screen captures I will provide in just a second, Joey morely had his hand flat against his mouth, while Kobayashi looked like he was still bunching it both in and out of his mouth. However, since it was apparently ruled a "tie" after both Kobayashi and Joey had consumed 59 hot dog and buns each, the 5 dog eat off was done. In the end, Joey won and is now a 2x Nathan's champ. He, at least I think, proved naysayers from the 2007 contest that he backed up with another win this year. Of course there will still be diehard Kobayashi fans that still think he won the 2008 contest...

SO, my illustrations below prove my point. I was already disappointed that Kobayashi was allowed to compete at the Nathan's finals without going into a qualifier event (like all other competitors other than Joey, the reigning Nathan's champ), but having him go against Joey to try to win back his 6x title before being beaten did bring excitement to Nathan's and another Koby vs. Joey vs. everyone else matchup. OOO! One more thing, since we don't see Kobayashi competing in that many competitive eating contests since said jaw injury... shouldn't his IFOCE rankings be moved down? Yea, he did bring competitive eating into another spotlight, but should he still be at #3? I think he should move down (not sure to which spot) while some of the other eaters should be shifted up: Juliet Lee and Tim Janus.

Big thumbs up for all the competitors in the finals! It was truely an exciting event to watch, both pre show and the main event!

I haven't figured out how to post multiple photos within one article, so you will see in succession of 2 comments for this article.

The 1st photo:

**The red circles both over Kobayashi's and Joey's mouth. Now if you look at it closely, Joey's hand is more flat on his mouth (and doesn't look like there is any debris leftover after the buzzer), while Kobayashi's hand is more bunched over his mouth (you can kind of see that there is still hot dog debris left)

Vote this post up or down: 

3 Comments On: "My take on why Nathan's 2008 contest overtime was NOT necessary (photos too)!"

 
2nd photo:

**Closer shot of Joey's hand over his mouth (after the buzzer was sound). Like I had mentioned, no debris seen (hot dog or bun) at all.

3rd photo:

**Closer shot of Kobayashi after the buzzer, and right after the clip for Joey's hand over his mouth. The red circle zeroes in on his mouth, and the yellow arrow is pointing to the 1/4 to 1/2 hot dog and bun that was left. Take a look between the thumb and forefinger. How is that not clear for a photofinish? He clearly still had stuff CLUTCHED IN HIS HANDS (and out of his mouth) after the the buzzer.

I noticed the same thing during the broadcast. In fact, it was even more blatant than shown above. I could actually see the final 1/2 or 1/4 HDWB being shoved in, two or more seconds after time had expired. I was amazed that the judge(s) didn't see the same thing. It was good that he failed in overtime. Otherwise, it would have been as rotten a victory for Nippon as Pearl Harbor was.

Your comment:



Featured Stories Today
Chicago Bears (Bear Goggles On)
It's finally time for some football! Despite having two playoff contending baseball teams, Chicago ...
Detroit Lions (SideLion Report)
Team MVP: Quarterback Jon Kitna.Anything the Lions will try to accomplish on offense will revolve...
Green Bay Packers (NFL Mocks)
Team MVP: Ryan Grant. How can it be anyone else? With Aaron Rodgers inexperienced at the helm of...
Minnesota Vikings (The Viking Age)
Team MVP: Adrian Peterson. He had a chance at league MVP last year before Al Harris took his knee...
Exclusive NFL previews in the Yard
If you're a Lions fan, and sincerest condolences if that's the case, why read a preview written by...
Most Comments Today
Most Comments This Week


Top 5 Related Stories
Most Popular Related Topics
Action Sports   All Sports   Backyard   Boxing   College Baseball   College Basketball   College Football   Cricket   Cycling   Eating   Formula One   Golf   High School   Horse Racing   Lacrosse   MLB   MMA   Motor Sports   NASCAR   NBA   NFL   NHL   Olympics   Other Sports   Rugby   Soccer   Tennis   Track and Field   WNBA   WWE  
Recent Eating Fans
Most Popular Eating Articles

MLB
Wednesday Aug 20 (EST)    See all MLB Scores >>
  • 1
    3
    Oakland
    Minnesota
    Final
    Box Score
  • 3
    15
    Seattle
    Chicago
    Final
    Box Score
  • 2
    5
    Houston
    Milwaukee
    Final
    Box Score
  • 6
    11
    Boston
    Baltimore
    Final
    Box Score
  • 5
    8
    Kansas City
    Cleveland
    Final
    Box Score
  • 0
    4
    Washington
    Philadelphia
    Final
    Box Score
  • 5
    1
    New York
    Toronto
    Final
    Box Score
  • 3
    6
    Atlanta
    New York
    Final
    Box Score
  • 5
    4
    Los Angeles
    Tampa Bay
    Final
    Box Score
  • 1
    9
    Detroit
    Texas
    Final
    Box Score
  • 2
    1
    Cincinnati
    Chicago
    Final
    Box Score
  • 2
    11
    Pittsburgh
    St. Louis
    Final
    Box Score
  • 6
    8
    San Diego
    Arizona
    Final
    Box Score
  • 4
    3
    Colorado
    Los Angeles
    Final
    Box Score
  • 5
    6
    Florida
    San Francisco
    Final
    Box Score
  •  
     
    © Copyright 2008 Yardbarker, Inc. All Rights Reserved