Found January 09, 2013 on
Reading Between The Seams:
Words like “travesty” and “shame” and “unthinkable” are being bantered about with regard to today’s Hall of Fame vote which yielded no players receiving the 75% of the vote needed for election. There are three contributors (Deacon White, Hank O’Day, Jacob Ruppert), only one of whom actually played baseball in the majors and none of which are alive, who were elected via the veterans committee. And probably a broadcaster and a sports writer in their respective wings. But no modern player for the first time since 1996. While this blog felt that six players were worthy immediately, I’m here to tell you. It is okay. Here are five reasons why:
1) There probably wasn’t a consensus candidate worthy on this ballot. A key word there, consensus. What that means is that history shows that it takes a while for the Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA) to come to consensus. History shows that marginal candidates (and by that, I mean non-slam dunk candidates) grow in their vote count from year to year. Bert Blyleven, Andre Dawson, and Jim Rice are three examples (14th, 9th, and 15th year respectively). Great players in their day, but not necessarily consensus during their early years of eligibility. It took a while to appreciate their place in baseball history. Craig Biggio will be a Hall of Famer, but the consensus is just not there yet. Comparable middle infielder Barry Larkin didn’t get in until Year 3.
Biggio will have his day in due time
2) There is no fundamental reason that there should be a minimum of one inductee per year. There is only an economic and publicity one. Cooperstown will suffer very low attendance this year. I wonder how many living Hall of Famers might suddenly have a family commitment that precludes them from showing up? Because we will be inducting ghosts (always fun to congratulate ghosts in person). And baseball needs good press, needs the interviews, the highlights of the inductees, the buzz, the reminiscence, the big smile on the inductees face, the family reaction, the discussion among sports analysts. But it will get none. But in terms of worthiness of the Hall of Fame, you don’t put someone in just because there is no other option.
3) Analysis of future competition and/or the thought that only a few players should get in every year is also not valid. You hear chatter of “X and Y player will be on the ballot next year and take away votes”. There is a limit of 10 players per ballot, but I believe most voters put at most half of that and don’t pit inductees against each other. At least they shouldn’t. It’s not supposed to be an election of one candidate against the rest. It’s the candidate against history. Just as there may be a year with no inductees, there is no reason that there couldn’t be six or seven inductees if several outstanding players retired at the same time.
4) There is definitely no consensus on the steroid issue. MLB has given no clarification on the issue, and therefore, many writers are holding back their votes to see how it plays out, and probably rightfully so. You can’t un-induct someone (at least not to date). So with time on their side (candidates like Bonds will be on the ballot until 2027) no reason to rush into judgment. It may turn out that every single player in baseball did steroids and therefore we should include it as part of the game and move on (just like not penalizing players before the color barrier was broken). It may be that nothing changes much and these people are punished (joining Shoeless Joe Jackson and Pete Rose in terms of their worthiness but lack of induction). But the process is working, for now.
Could have done more
5) Maybe baseball deserved this. By that, I mean the guilt of the steroid era is widespread. The commissioner should have done more, the MLBPA should have agreed to testing (told owners they strike if testing was in 2002 agreement). Fans deserve blame for probably knowing what was up and still buying tickets. Media probably turned the other way to keep player relationships to do their job. Players should have self-policed (and not taken the darn things). So now we have a generation of players with Hall of Fame talent (no doubt, Bonds, Palmeiro, and Clemens in my mind didn’t need juice) that will be postponed at best. But there will be the Biggio’s, the Maddux’s, the Glavine’s, the Jeter’s that were above the fray and will get in. And deservedly so. But there might be some lean years, here.
So we have a momentary disappointment. Some people will call for a change in the voting members (none is perfect). Some people will call for all steroid users to get in because it wasn’t their fault. Some people will call for a change in the voting threshold. But these are knee-jerk reactions. The system works. Deserving players get in (Shoeless Joe and Pete Rose debate for another day). This just won’t be one of those years.
And oh, by the way, you can scratch number 5 from what should be your New Years Resolutions. Wait until next year, you might see 4 or 5 inductees.
Follow us on Twitter at @rbts_sk
The post Five reasons why it is okay nobody was voted in the Hall of Fame appeared first on Reading Between The Seams.
BEST OF MAXIM
Craig Biggio believes it's possible that he wasn't elected to the Hall of Fame because he was on the ballot for the first time with several big stars linked to performance-enhancing drugs.
Biggio, who has never been linked to PEDs, received the highest vote total in a year that produced no inductions to Cooperstown on Wednesday. Biggio, who is 20th on the career list with...
CRAIG BIGGIO First Year on Ballot PLAYING CAREER: Houston Astros (1988-2007) ACHIEVEMENTS: Career batting average of .281 with 3060 hits, 668 doubles, 291 home runs, 1844 runs and 414 stolen bases. Ranks fifth all-time in doubles and 21st all-time in hits. Became just the ninth player in the 3000 hit club to get all his hits with the same team. Holds the modern record for most times...
Craig’s the man Juan…
As JJ Watt prepares for the matchup at Foxboro this weekend, he showed support this week for Hall Of Fame snub Craig Biggio. “Hall of Famer in my book”, Watt said
JJ Watt Struggles With 3lb Weights
JJ Watt With Justin Beiber
Houston’s Craig Biggio came the closest in a year with no Baseball Hall of Fame inductees.
J.J. Watt has only been in the Houston area for two years now, but apparently he’s a big Craig Biggio fan.
The star defensive end wore a Biggio Houston Astros jersey to his news conference on Wednesday and said he believes the second baseman should be in the Baseball Hall of Fame, according to the Texans’ Twitter account. Biggio led the 2013 hall of fame class in voting, but...
As you probably heard, yesterday was not a good day for retired baseball players. Nobody was elected to the baseball Hall of Fame. Craig Biggio, who had 3,060 hits in his career and was a seven-time All-Star
while playing three positions, topped
the ballot with 388 votes, but needed 427 votes to get in. The New York Times ran with it and printed a blank front page of...
For only the eighth time in history and the first time since 1996, the Baseball Writers Association of America decided no single player was eligible for the Baseball Hall of Fame. In his first year on the ballot, longtime Houston Astro Craig Biggio was the closest to Cooperstown earning 68.2 of the required 75 percent [...]
The Baseball Hall of Fame will not welcome any new members in 2013. Craig Biggio received the highest percentage of votes but his 68% was well short of the 75% required to earn enshrinement in Cooperstown.
This year’s ballot featured many players who have been linked to steroids.
It was the first time since 1996 that no one was inducted into the hall of fame. Also falling short...
The 2013 HOF Class will never be forgotten.
Yesterday, the Baseball Writers Association of America announced that there would be no inductees in the 2013 Baseball Hall of Fame class. Craig Biggio led all 37 nominees with 68.2 percent of the vote. Out of the 569 ballots sent in, only 39 of them did not have Biggio’s name on it and those 39 votes kept him out of Cooperstown. The...
All the Hall of Fame ballots have been cast, all the votes have been tallied, and now there’s some guy in a Steve Henderson jersey is walking to the podium with a large white envelope in his hand…
You guessed it, it’s time for MMO to reveal their Hall of Fame results and the winners are… A drum roll please…
The 2013 Hall of Fame voting results will be announced later today and I wanted to cast my ballot as well. *I'm not into that "first ballot" bull crap, this is all about whether I think they should be in or not. Not whether they should go in first shot, 2nd year, or their last hurrah.On My Ballot:1. Craig Biggio - a tremendous up the middle player over the course...
The Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA) got it right in 2013.
The Baseball Hall of Fame (HOF) is not the Hall of Good Guys. (Dale Murphy)
The Baseball Hall of Fame is not the Hall of Milestone Numbers and you are automatically included regardless if you cheated, regardless if you are a bully, regardless if you forget English. (You know the list)
Nor is the Baseball...
Moments ago, the Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA) announced the results of this year’s Hall of Fame voting.
The only problem is that there were no results.
For the 8th time in history, and first since 1996, no player was selected for entry into the Hall. This is an outcome most predicted since the “Steroid Era” players are now just beginning to appear on the...
So has the news of yesterday’s Hall of Fame vote sunk in yet? I guess it should come as no surprise really that no one got in as the voters need more time to decide who should get in. This is the first class that was directly affected by the presence of PEDs in professional sports. Half the ballot was filled with players who have been known or suspected of using the juice. The...