Originally written on The Rhino and Compass  |  Last updated 11/14/14
I had an unusual comment on my Justin Morneau post from the weekend. It was unusual, because it expressed an opinion that didn’t quite align with mine, but refrained from profanity and insults to my person. In fact, all it really did was open up an opportunity for dialogue via an avenue I hadn’t thought to pursue before. So congratulations, commentor Shane, for disagreeing with something on the internet and not devolving into a savage. If one person can do it, there is hope for humanity. That said, I disagree with your assertions, but I respect your opinion. For those that didn’t click the hyperlink, here are the opinions Shane espouses: “3 homers 42 RBI’s in 67 games = another waste of Twins Payroll dollars” “He is one of the reason the Twins stink again in 2013.” “Cut the cord and release or trade Justin. He’s another highly paid mediocre player” I’m going to address these comments individually with my own dissenting opinion. To the first point, looking exclusively at home runs and runs batted in is a poor way to evaluate a complete player. His OPS+ is 100, which is indicative of a league average player at his position. Corner infielders are generally some of the highest paid players in the game, and while Morneau’s salary is certainly higher than it should be, it’s not outrageous, especially considering it was give to him as he was entering the apex of his career. These things happen. And looking at his bat — his league average bat when taking into account things like on base percentage and slugging percentage — gives an incomplete picture of the value Morneau provides to a team. He is also a plus defender at first, and there is certainly something to be said about the chemistry of the team when he is there, for whatever that’s worth. Second, to the point that Morneau is one of the reasons Morneau stinks this year. First, in your reference to his RBI, it’s tough to get them when Aaron Hicks and Brian Dozier are flailing at the plate ahead of your in the lineup. Second, Morneau LEADS THE TEAM IN RUNS BATTED IN. If you DO in fact value RBI as a metric for rating individual value (which I do not) how can you say that Morneau is one of the reasons that the team sucks if he is the team leader in this category? If anything, this is an indication of the ineptitude of the rest of the team, who either fail to get on base ahead of him, or haven’t surpassed his total so they would be the team leader in this category. Lastly, I won’t dispute the “highly paid and mediocre” part. He makes a lot of money and “league average” is the definition of mediocre, but I do disagree with the previous “waste of payroll” assertion. But cutting him? He is under contract, so that saves no money, and the Twins receive nothing in return. And trading him? That assumes there is a viable replacement candidate, in your minds eye, that will immediately make the team better upon Morneau’s departure (given the assertion that Morneau is one of the reasons the Twins suck this year). The Twins might be destined to trade him, but only if they can get a proper return, not to clear payroll and roster space. Thank you, Shane, for checking in with a civilized comment that opened up this discourse. I hope you come back to read this post, because I am looking forward to hearing some counterpoints if I haven’t swayed your opinion (I suspect I haven’t).  
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Robert Kraft: Richard Sherman is a 'marketing whiz'

Rob Gronkowski's party bus headed to Super Bowl

Matt Barnes not happy with NBA for $25,000 fine

Brandon Browner: 'No hard feelings' with Sherman, Thomas

Gronk reads erotica, sings Katy Perry at SB Media Day


Governor donates $10K to UNM hoops star’s cancer charity

U.S. Soccer: Hope Solo needs to do 'number of things' to return

K.J. Wright: Targeting injured players 'unacceptable'

Five reasons the Patriots will win the Super Bowl

Five reasons the Seahawks will win the Super Bowl

Bill Simmons fires a shot at ESPN colleague Ray Lewis

Kurt Warner wonders about Patriots cheating in Super Bowl

4-star QB recruit decommits from Michigan

Top storylines for Super Bowl XLIX

WATCH: Pacquiao, Mayweather meet at halftime of Heat game

One of Tom Brady's ‘treats’ is avocado ice cream

Does MLB need more offense in the modern game?

Re-ranking the Top 25: exposing the biggest flaws

Tiger on wearing mask: ‘Not a lot of brown dudes at ski races’

Putting the Cleveland Cavaliers’ pieces together

Brodeur to retire immediately and join Blues front office

Michael Bennett talks about sex superstition, calls reporter gay

As Patriots prepare, it's easy to forget about Hernandez

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Top storylines for Super Bowl XLIX

Barnes unhappy with NBA over fine

Does MLB need more offense in the modern game?

Re-ranking the Top 25: exposing the biggest flaws

Putting the Cavs’ pieces together

Super Bowl XLIX: Key people to know

Ranking all 48 Super Bowls

Bill Simmons fires a shot at Ray Lewis

NFL pushing CFP to change schedule

Can Yanks not pay A-Rod his bonuses?

Petition started to remove Pats from SB

On John Wall's adidas J Wall 1 NYC All-Star Edition

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.