Found August 21, 2012 on Fox Sports Midwest:
Fresh off their second World Series championship in the last six seasons, the St. Louis Cardinals have done just about everything a fan could ask of them this year, and statistically speaking, there's no reason they shouldn't be a contender for the crown once again. Through 121 games in the first season of the post-Tony La Russa era, the Cardinals' pitching has been good despite the absence of Chris Carpenter, their hitting has been awesome despite the Albert Pujols-sized hole in the lineup, their run differential is at an astronomical plus-106 and everything is or at least should be hunky-dory in St. Louis. Except it's not. Because the Cardinals, at 65-56, are currently third in their own division, eight games behind Cincinnati for first in the NL Central and 1-12 games back of Pittsburgh in the wild card standings and that's to say nothing of Atlanta and Los Angeles, which also lead St. Louis in the race for the NL's two wild card spots. But based on nearly every conceivable metric, the Redbirds should already be virtually assured a playoff spot, like the powerhouse Yankees or upstart Nationals, not struggling in the standings, needing another late-season rally in order to clinch a postseason berth. According to the Cardinals' Pythagorean win-loss record, a metric popularized by statistician Bill James to reflect the number of games a team should have won based on their runs scored and allowed, St. Louis should be 71-50, two games back of the Reds for the division lead and in a virtual tie with Atlanta atop the wild card standings. Which begs the question: How can such a statistically superior team have such an average overall record, and where did those six victories the games James' theorem says St. Louis should have won go? Some of St. Louis' shortcomings can be tied to a lack of timely hitting and other losses can be traced back to struggles in the bullpen late in games we'll get to that later but above everything, the most reasonable explanation for the Cardinals' underwhelming record may be simpler than that. "The difference between a team's won-loss record and run differential, when there is a big difference, I would say that almost all of it is going to be luck," said Phil Birnbaum, editor of the Society for American Baseball Research's sabermetrics publication, "By the Numbers." "If you're looking for some sort of indicator of how good a team is, how much talent a team has or what you should expect from that team in the future, I would say that run differential would give you a much better estimate than wins and losses." Birnbaum's assessment makes enough sense; all year long, St. Louis has proven to be one of the most talented teams in baseball. For starters, the Cards can swing the stick, boasting the highest team batting average and on-base percentage in the NL, not to mention the NL's second-highest OPS and third-highest slugging percentage. Additionally, St. Louis has scored the most runs and collected the most hits in the NL. On the mound, St. Louis has seen the top four pitchers in its rotation combine to go 48-26 with a 3.41 ERA, while producing a quality start in 63.9 percent of outings. And Jason Motte has been solid in the closer role, with 28 saves and just five blown opportunities to go with his 2.73 ERA. The rest of the Cards' relievers have combined for a 4.44 ERA in 282 innings, not atrocious by any means, and St. Louis' team ERA of 3.67 is still one of the top 10 in baseball. All of this production has led to lots of blowouts, as St. Louis has won 24 games by five or more runs a fair indicator of how much better they can be than the competition when they're on. Unfortunately, the Cardinals have also lost 21 one-run games this season and have lost nine of 12 extra-inning contests with those two numbers representing a the most sizeable portion of the disparity between St. Louis and the teams they're chasing. "In one-run games they're 13-21; if they were 17-17 in those games, that's four games right there," Birnbaum said. "Their extra innings record is 3-9 not ideal, but if they were 6-6, which you would kind of expect, that's three more games." That powerful Cardinals offense is hitting just .234 in extras, with virtually no power to speak of. And St. Louis' stalwart bullpen boasts an ERA of 5.79 in innings 10 and beyond, with opponents hitting .310 56 points higher than the Cards' overall opposing batting average for the season. Relievers Barret Browning, Eduardo Sanchez, Victor Marte and Trevor Rosenthal have a combined 17.47 ERA in 5-23 innings of extra-inning work this season, alone. But that still doesn't explain the 17 one-run losses that have come in nine-inning games. St. Louis' batting metrics are relatively unchanged whether the team is winning, losing or tied. And while the team ERA does go up from 3.55 in innings one through six to 3.92 in innings seven and later, the starting pitcher has taken the L in nearly half of those one-run losses, anyway. In 12 of St. Louis' one-run losses, the team gave up three runs or fewer, and more often than not just ran into an opposing pitcher having a great day the type of fluky output that one couldn't possibly predict, except to say that it probably won't keep happening. "My expectation would be that it doesn't continue," Birnbaum said of St. Louis' string of disappointing defeats. "If you look at what's going to happen in the rest of August or September, I would say they would be close to normal in one-run or extra-inning games. What you're seeing is almost all bad luck." And they'll need all the good fortune they can get, because the Reds, who haven't won a playoff game since 1995, and the Pirates, who haven't even finished above .500 since their last playoff appearance, in 1992, don't seem likely to fade into the ether down the stretch this fall. Fortunately for Cards fans, their team is always capable of a late-season run, and should they piece one together this year, it certainly wouldn't be the first time in recent memory. Last year, you'll recall, St. Louis went 23-9 over the final 32 games of the season to eliminate a 10-12-game gap between themselves and the Braves and take the NL wild card. In 2009, the Cards took a 10-12-game division lead into September after going 24-7 from July 27 through the end of August. In 2004 and 2005, the Cardinals' only two 100-win seasons since 1985, St. Louis went a combined 40-19 in August. From 2000-2002, a span of three straight playoff berths and two NLCS appearances, St. Louis combined to go 54-35 in August and 61-23 in September and October. Every rule has an exception, of course, and that thinking also applies to the Cardinals, who haven't always found a summer surge to be the winning formula. When St. Louis won the World Series in 2006, it went from 16 games over .500 at 58-42 on July 26 to just five games over .500 at 83-78 when the season ended. That lose-now-and-win-later plan may have worked once for St. Louis, but if the 2012 season so far has been any indication, the Cardinals would probably be wise not to test their luck again. You can follow Sam Gardner on Twitter or e-mail him at samgardnerfox@gmail.com.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Cards extend Westbrook through '13

Courtesy: St. Louis Cardinals ST. LOUIS, Mo. The St. Louis Cardinals announced today that they have agreed to a contract extension with pitcher Jake Westbrook that carries through the 2013 season and includes a mutual option for 2014. Westbrook, acquired by the Cardinals on July 31, 2010 in a trade from Cleveland, has built a 28-22 mark with a 4.01 ERA in 69 starts as a member...

Beltran sidelined by hand injury

Carlos Beltran, the National League's RBIs leader, missed his second start in three games because of a right hand injury. St. Louis Cardinals manager Mike Matheny said the hand has been bothering Beltran for a while. Beltran was 0 for 8 in a 19-inning loss to the Pirates on Sunday, and Matheny said the injury has flared up, but that he didn't think he'd be out long...

Jaime Garcia’s Return Key for Cardinals

Eleven innings after his departure Jaime Garcia‘s return to the Cardinals’ rotation was buried by the absurdity of one of the season’s longest games. After battling back from one run down in the 16th inning, the Cardinals scraped one across to keep the game going, but a Pedro Alvarez home run in the 19th sealed a victory for the Pirates. But as we look long-term for the Cardinals...

Astros mulling future of Tal’s Hill

It is a shame that the long histories of St. Louis and Houston baseball will diverge even further when the Astros are moved to the American League West starting next season. Though the current Houston club is one of their worst ever, the city has a proud history, including a long stint hosting Cardinals farm teams. That doesn’t mean I like everything about Houston baseball. Their...

Cardinals give Jake Westbrook a contract extension

Jake Westbrook Extended

The St. Louis Cardinals and Jake Westbrook have agreed to an extension. The new contract is reportedly a one-year, $8.75 million contract for 2013 with a superfluous mutual option worth $9.5 million for 2014 with a $1 million buyout. While the mutual option seems increasingly prevalent, given that it is usually irrelevant in practice, it might be more straightforward to think of...

Lohse, Cardinals top Astros

ST. LOUIS (AP) -- Kyle Lohse pitched seven innings of three-hit ball to earn his seventh consecutive win and the St. Louis Cardinals beat the Houston Astros 4-2 on Wednesday night. Lohse (13-2) gave up two runs and retired his last 14 batters while improving to 7-0 with a 2.21 ERA in 12 starts since he dropped a 3-2 decision against Kansas City on June 15. The Cardinals have won...

Cardinals recap: St. Louis Cardinals 7 Houston Astros 0

St. Louis Cardinals starting pitcher Adam Wainwright struck out 12 hitters to pick up win number 12 on the season. -  (Photo credit: Wikipedia) After Sunday's devastating nineteen inning loss to the Pittsburgh Pirates, the St. Louis Cardinals needed two things to happen on Tuesday night against the Houston Astros to get things back on track. First, the Cardinals needed the...

Cards, Westbrook agree to one-year extension

Right-handed pitcher Jake Westbrook will be back in the St. Louis Cardinals rotation in 2013 and perhaps 2014 as well.

St. Louis native Tom Layne picks up first big league save

St. Louis native Tom Layne may not be wearing a St. Louis Cardinals jersey, but he is doing everything he can to help the Cardinals out this month while wearing a San Diego Padres uniform. On Wednesday, Layne picked up his first Major League save in a 4-2 Padres victory over the Pittsburgh Pirates, who the Cardinals now lead by a half game in the National League Central Division...

Astros-Cardinals Preview

The St. Louis Cardinals' longest game in more than two years didn't go their way, but the team remains in the playoff hunt. The major league-worst Houston Astros aren't even close to contention, but interim manager Tony DeFrancesco still plans to treat the final stretch like a pennant chase. Cardinals right-hander Adam Wainwright will try to win his sixth straight start...

Kendrick’s Continued Improvement

Kyle Kendrick has been at times both brilliant and frustrating this season. He shut out the St. Louis Cardinals towards the end of May, and hasn’t allowed a run in 15 straight innings, blanking the Marlins over seven innings and the Brewers over eight in his most recent start. Between the end of June and beginning of August, he threw 22 straight scoreless innings. However, he...

Tony LaRussa's Block Party Coming To Left Bank Books

Believe it or not, we like reading.So when our friends down at Left Bank Books have a book block party and bring some old fodder logs out, we feel the need to share details.Former Cardinal manager (who, in his photo, appears to have something on his lip) Tony LaRussa will be at LBB on SEPT 24 @ 12p to sign books and take pics. The entire flier is here:More Information: LINK HERELeft...
Cardinals News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.