Found November 13, 2011 on

Jonathan Papelbon agreed to terms with the Philadelphia Phillies, pending his physical. How does his signing impact Jimmy Rollins, Roy Oswalt, Brad Lidge and Michael Cuddyer? This is the third top-tier name with the same approach, and that indicates what you can expect and when during this off-season.

Tal's Handy Caps:

I will do a monthly Baseball-Fix Monday for November (2 parts) and one in December. Depending on how quickly things develop, that may change accordingly. It will be December 5 or if a deal is near, I’ll delay posting by a week. I will start January 9 with a weekly version, and will publish after every game that is not washed out during the year.

My format will remain the same for 2012 with Nitecap Insight, The Precap and The Apocalyptic Horsemen. The opening will feature certain players plus participants who warrant mention, good and bad, for what they have done in the contest or clubhouse. Penthouse Occupancy will cover all remarkable plays and solid performances during critical moments by the red pinstripes. The best of those will receive The Crystal Champagne Toast. Cholley’s Doghouse is filled every now and then with a slacking effort. The Outhouse is for something that stinks, like a bad ump call. The Glass House is a stone’s throw away for a man who blows his opportunity to nail a juicier role. The Miniature Mansion is for off-field excellence, like a locker-room influence. However, these houses don’t have visitors after every battle

"Cinco Ocho" Converts His 31st Save On September 27 In Baltimore


The Answers, Part 1

The second half of this article will be next Monday morning, because the 2012 dollars for Papelbon won’t be made public until this week. The money aspect is critical to how Rube Amaro operates ahead of the curve. He moves quickly to fill his most pressing requirement, attacks his second need, and he addresses his other holes with his remaining funds. He simultaneously adds small pieces and negotiates with young stars who are still under control. You can expect swift progress on J-Roll and Cuddyer, because the Phils must have a steady shortstop and a versatile right-handed stick with power. Cuddyer can handle leftfield, while John Mayberry Jr. and Jim Thome hold down first base in April. Cuddyer can also spell Polly Polanco, Chase Utley, Hunter Pence and Ryan Howard.

"Cinco Ocho" Pictured On September 28 In Baltimore

Rube had swaps in place for Doc Halladay and Cliff Lee at the 2009 trading deadline. He went with Lee, which was his second choice. He made an offer to Lee for 2010 plus, but completed the Halladay deal when he felt his original intention would be elongated. Now, he has sprinted away from Ryan Madson, landing Papelbon for his biggest unfilled role. By mid-December, Amaro will again work his magic once or twice.

Over the weekend the debate centered on who is the better closer: Papelbon or Madson. Both are about the same age. Mad Dog took a long time to conquer the lock-down responsibility, and if he has an extended struggling period, it is unclear that he will survive. Lidge went through that and Papelbon rebounded after a down 2010. That said, the big galoot with the bug-eyed look has a 6-summer resume, including All-Star and postseason appearances. “Cinco Ocho“–58 (his number)–is his self-declared nickname and he brings his riverdance to the Bank.

The big question for 2012 is that the new guy is a fly-ball hurler in a homer-friendly field, but Yankee Stadium and Fenway Park are not pitcher’s arenas. Plus, Pap had to work against the toughest divisional offenses in the sport. He will have a huge advantage with opponents who have few or no at-bats against him. Papelbon is now in an ace-heavy environment, where he could develop a secondary pitch by 2014. You cannot go wrong with either Papelbon or Madson at this time.

Jim Thome At Third Base on September 25 In Cleveland

Rube usually offers a fair contract, especially when he has two acceptable candidates. In 2009, he acquired Lee after Toronto demanded too much for Halladay, and he snagged Doc when Cliff’s agent was overly negotiation prone. The return of Lee last season almost didn’t happen, which proves that Amaro’s fast directional change toward Halladay was the right decision. Originally, there was disappointment when the General came to town instead of the Doctor, but that didn’t last too long. By the following spring, Halladay was here and everybody wanted Lee too.

Rube operates on a straight line with the biggest requirement first, which is a closer behind his number ones. He began 2012 with $62M available for 15 of 26 players, but $30.5M would go to 11, like Cole Hamels and Pence. The other 9 are familiar faces: Kyle Kendrick, Vance Worley, Michael Martinez, Wilson Valdez, Antonio Bastardo, Brian Schneider, Ben Francisco, John Mayberry Jr. and a lefty reliever, like Raul Valdes or Joe Savery. The signed 10 are: Halladay, Lee, Joe Blanton, Jose Contreras, Chooch Ruiz, Howard, Utley, Polanco, Shane Victorino and Thome. A 26th man is required until Ryno returns in April or May.

Jim Thome Blasts A 4th-Inning Moon Shot On September 23 In Cleveland

Rube spends until he hits his financial ceiling, which was $31.5M for 5 roster spots: a closer, a shortstop, a 26th slot (Cuddyer or Pete Orr) and 2 arms in that exact order. If Papelbon’s 2012 dollars are $12.5M, that would leave $19M for 4 jobs in next year’s ledger, which could be $1.5M between Orr, Michael Stutes and another young wing. The difference is that he doesn’t exhaust his resources with his first hole unfilled, doesn’t get in a biding war, and he has the certainty of a top-tier performer before turning to his secondary target during November.

The Answer, Conclusion will be published next Monday morning. There are 72 story lines from the 2011 season that can be found in my author archives ( Tal Venada ).

The Phillies finished 42 games over .500, which equaled a season of many positives. I have many summer-long highlights of puzzle pieces, especially after drubbings and defeats. I alternated the 2011 ERA For The NL East ( Philadelphia Phillies: 2011 ERA For The NL East At Game 162 And Final ) and 2011 ERA For The MLB 5 ( Philadelphia Phillies: Final 2011 ERA For The MLB 5 At Game 162 ) with the last 2 in the link. Check out The Phillies page by placing the pointer over MLB at the top, and click on the name. Thank you, to all who bookmark my page, because feeds are erratic at times. Many visitors come from these outlets, and it is always obvious when one of those didn’t work. Tal’s Handy Stats is daily coverage.


Debate: Chase Utley or David Wright?

Utley or Wright? (Photo: interrupt the Jonathan Papelbon talk to focus our attention elsewhere for a few minutes. This post was written by one of our finest commenters, “Publius.” A few weeks ago, when Jayson Stark uttered the Rumor That Launched a Thousand Comments by possibly linking the Phils to David Wright, I engaged with other Phillies Nation commenters who said...

Reaction to Phillies Signing of Jonathan Paplebon

I have had a few days to let the Jonathan Paplebon signing sink in now and I am still not sure what to think.  Paplebon is a proven closer and a 4-time All-Star.  In 2011, he saved 31 out of 34 games for the Red Sox and posted a 2.94 ERA. Both Paplebon and Ryan Madson are the same age and have similar stats with the big difference being experience as a closer.  Paplebon has...

Don't Feel Sorry for Ryan Madson

Do you feel bad for Ryan Madson?  Do you believe that he is devastated he will not be returning to the Phillies?  Do you feel he genuinely wanted to come back and was cheated out of the opportunity?  Is he sitting around shell shocked, trying to comprehend how it all went wrong, realizing there's no way to fix it?  Well, don't feel bad for him! Certain players make...

Phillies Have Payroll Flexibility

David Murphy of the Daily News High Cheese has a post today that talks about the Phillies payroll and what kind of flexibility they still have. By his math the Phillies have approximately $26 to $31 million to spend for the 2012 season. That math sounds about right but I’m not quite sure about his conclusion about the Phils being able to resign Jimmy Rollins and also bring in...

Name That Phillie: Closer Edition

In the spirit of the new Phillies closer Jonathan Papelbon, WSBGMs wants to see if our readers recognize this past Phillies 9th inning specialist. Name that Phillie...

Did the Phillies Make the Right Choice with Papelbon?

After all the chaos that unfolded this week for the Philadelphia Phillies, first agreeing but not agreeing with Ryan Madson, and then signing Jonathan Papelbon, there was a general consensus opinion online among Phillies fans and non-Phillies fans alike: that the team would have overpaid for either player. There are just as many critics of the Papelbon deal as there were for the...

Nats GM Met With Agent For Wilson, Oswalt

Nationals GM Mike Rizzo met for about 45 minutes tonight with Bob Garber, the agent for free agents C.J. Wilson and Roy Oswalt, writes Adam Kilgore of The Washington Post.

Discussion: Potential minor league free agents of note

I’m going to focus on the external options here, as we’ve already reviewed the Phillies minor league free agents. You can check all minor league free agents using BA’s tracker here. I just picked out a few guys I find interesting. None of these guys are likely to be big time MLB contributors in 2012 or any time, for that matter, but they might be good depth guys who can fill...

Marlins Made Offer To Ryan Madson

In addition to Albert Pujols, Jose Reyes, and Mark Buehrle, the Marlins made an offer to free agent closer Ryan Madson, reports SI's Jon Heyman.  Unlike the other three, the Madson offer has yet to inspire a visit to Miami.  Heyman notes that the proposals are preliminary, and the team is not concerned about all four accepting.  Marlins president David Samson explained...

Roy Oswalt?

Sports Illustrated is doing a team-by-team preview of each club’s off-season plans. You can read the entire thing yourself, but relevant to our conversation here is the list of “targets” they identify for the Reds: SP James Shields, SP Roy Oswalt, SP C.J. Wilson, SP Jon Danks, SP Scott Baker. Shields: yes, please. Wilson: too expensive and probably not worth the money he...

Papelbon, Phillies complete deal

PHILADELPHIA (AP) -- Jonathan Papelbon and the Philadelphia Phillies have completed a $50 million, four-year contract .

What’s So Funny?

I came across this post on Amazin Avenue by Chris McShane, which actually reflects perfectly the overriding sentiment on Twitter immediately after it was announced the the Phillies agreed to a contract with closer Jonathan Papelbon to a four-year deal. He writes: The good news out of Philadelphia is that the Phillies have signed Jonathan Papelbon to a four-year contract worth...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.