Originally written on Fangraphs  |  Last updated 6/27/14

Kelly Johnson may or may not be a Toronto Blue Jay next season, but wherever he ends up, he promises to have a better year with the bat — regardless of how many times he strikes out. The free-agent-to-be second baseman hit a respectable .270/.364/.417 after coming over from the Diamondbacks in a late-August trade — but his overall campaign was a huge disappointment. Fresh off a season in which he hit 284/.370/.496, he saw his numbers plummet to .222/.304/.413. He went deep 21 times — his second consecutive year with 20-plus — but he struck out a whopping 163 times.

During a late-season visit to Fenway Park, Johnson talked about his approach to hitting, including his K rate, his extensive use of video and how Toronto compares to Atlanta and Arizona.


David Laurila: What type of season have you had?

Kelly Johnson: One of those learning seasons that you kind of wish you were over. It’s been up and down — mostly down. At my age [29], you feel like you should have ironed out some of the ups and downs and be a bit more consistent. It’s not been the year I wanted.

DL: Why has it been such a down year?

KJ: I don’t know. It’s just been an inconsistent year, feeling for my swing. More times than not, I’ve been 0-2 and feeling like I’m in an uphill battle. It’s been a struggle to find something that’s clicked — that’s worked — and I’ve been coming here thinking more about my swing than just playing the game of baseball.

DL: Is there anything about your hitting style that makes you prone to inconsistency?

KJ: Oh shoot, I don’t know. I think that even when I’m going good, I’m going to have longer at bats. I’ll be in some 3-2s and 2-2s. I feel like I generally have better swings and become a better hitter as the at bats go along. I’m not one of the guys that likes to always look first pitch, this, and that’s my pitch. I’ll do it, but it’s not something I feel is a strength for me. So, strikeouts will come. When I’m going well, walks will come, too. Like I said, this year has been more [about] missing my pitch and being 0-2, 1-2 too many times.

DL: What is your approach on a pitch? Are you looking middle and adjusting, or are you looking in specific areas?

KJ: It depends on the pitcher, but I generally try to look out over [the plate] a little more. I try to stay with my strengths. Pitchers are good — they can exploit you — but at the same time, they’re going to make mistakes. When they do, you can’t miss them. If you start missing mistakes, then you get yourself in non-predictable situations, versus being in a predictable situation. Maybe you’ve seen a pattern, or it’s a guy you’re familiar with, and you’re looking for something once you get into a 2-1 or 2-2 count. You know what he’s thrown you and you can look for it. When you take away that edge, sometimes it’s tough. I’m definitely not one of those people that can shut his brain off and just hack; see ball, hit ball.

DL: To what extent do you use charts and video?

KJ: Video, all the time. Pitchers will generally have a couple of pitches. They might throw a few – three or four or five – but they have a couple of pitches they want to go to for strikes. If you can kind of single out a certain pitch, like a changeup or a get-me-over slider… sometimes I would rather hit something coming in at 80, versus something coming in at 95. Video is big. I don’t use it for my swing, I use it more for pitchers.

DL: When you’re studying video, do you pay particular attention to how a pitcher attacks hitters who are similar to you?

KJ: Oh, yeah, although I look at all lefties. And I always check with guys in scoring position, because a lot of times that will tell you what a pitcher wants to throw, and what he feels comfortable throwing. A lot of times you’ll see a guy nitpicking fastballs and coming in sort of for show. Then, all of sudden, he’ll want to throw something softer, for a strike, to try to get a rollover, or whatever. If that’s a pitch you see well out of this guy’s hand, and you feel comfortable with it, that’s the one. But pitchers are different, so sometimes it’s hard to pick out the one you want to hit.

DL: What did [Blue Jays hitting coach] Dwayne Murphy want to know when you came here?

KJ: First, I guess, just more of my routine and how I get ready. When I’m going well, what do I think and feel about myself? What’s my approach? Do I go up there with a plan? He’s real big on having a game plan — looking at charts and reports — and then watching video. We definitely get along in that sense. He likes looking to hit immediately, and getting ready to hit fastballs. He’s definitely along the same lines as me with his thoughts.

DL: Does an individual hitting coach, and his philosophy, impact a hitter very much?

KJ: I think it can. You’ve got some hitters that come in and don’t watch a ton of video. They just go up there and look for the first straight fastball. They’re ready to hack and have a lot of success that way. I think that’s kind of an old-school way, to be honest. There are also guys talking about what pitchers throw, and thinking more about certain situations and spots. You see that more now — and it’s a little too much for some people — but to each their own. You can definitely have one kind of coach, versus another kind, and I could see where there might be some disconnect.

DL: You were originally with the Atlanta Braves. Coming up through their system, was a specific hitting philosophy espoused, or did they mostly let guys be themselves?

KJ: There was no philosophy, that I [saw]. I felt like it was more, for them, either you can do it or you can’t.

DL: What about when you got to Arizona?

KJ: When I first got there, yeah, it was similar to Murph. There was a certain amount of value to seeing pitches — [former general manager] Josh Byrnes was there — and that’s kind of what they liked. Then it switched to more of the old-school see-it-and-hit-it, where you either get it or you don’t.

DL: How cognizant are players of front-office thought process?

KJ: I think a lot depends on struggles — on ups and downs — when the lineup decisions are made. If you’re not doing well, or whatever, you see real quickly what they value. People want to stick with you and back you and just wait you out — or they get sick of it and want to try something else.

DL: Have your strikeouts been brought up by anyone in your current, or former, organizations?

KJ: Probably once. Really, these last two years have been the most I’ve struck out in my whole career, by a long shot. Last year, I had the best year of my life, and this year is one of the worst. They come when they come. In the minor leagues, I’d strike out 90-100 times, and I remember one of my coaches saying that he didn’t think I was that type of hitter. So, just one time ever.  To be honest, if I start thinking about not striking out, I’m going to strike out as much and lose a lot of my ability to drive the ball. I try not to think about it.

DL: Do you buy the sabermetric premise that strikeouts don’t matter?

KJ: To an extent. This year, as an example for myself — just how fed up I get with having bad at bats — I was playing with Mark Reynolds. Mark does so many more things than people understand. They come to a game and see him strike out and strike out and strike out. But there are little things that he does that, to me, mean you forgive [the strikeouts]. At the same time, when he’s going through certain stretches where he’s striking out more than others, and there are guys on third, or times where you’ve got to put the ball in play to get a guy over… being able to put the ball in play when you need to is definitely a big part of the game.

DL: Do you pay any attention to your walk rate?

KJ: I pay attention if I know it’s not where I need it to be. I don’t try to go out and draw extra walks because I feel like I haven’t walked in a while. But I do know that if I haven’t walked in a while, it probably means I’m swinging too early and not getting myself into a comfortable position at the plate. So, it kind of reminds me that I need to go up there and relax a bit more, see the ball a bit better and try to focus a little better.

DL: When you moved from the outfield to second base [in 2007], how aware were you that putting up the same offensive numbers at your new position would increase your value?

KJ: Oh, very aware. That’s a no brainer. I mean, last year, choosing between going to Arizona and staying at second base, or going to… actually, Toronto wanted me to play some outfield, and so did some other teams. I knew immediately that it wasn’t the right time, or a good decision on my part. I wanted to stay, and I feel like I made a lot of strides in the last two years, and I’m happy I did.

DL: Are you happy with your defensive game?

KJ: Yeah. I mean, I’m not a guy that was drafted or signed for defense, but there are certain plays that are completely necessary to be a major-league second baseman. You need be able to handle them. Most of those are making sure you get those double-play balls, because pitchers work for them. They’re not out there just throwing to get a swing and miss. A lot of times they want the ground ball — they’re pitching to a spot to get an easy ground ball — and you need to be there for them.

DL: What has the league adjustment been like, National to American?

KJ: Not too much. Pitching all around baseball is ridiculous. There are guys that can throw the crud out of the ball — they’ve got good stuff and can put it all over the place. Bullpen guys, rookies and even the young guys that are up-and-coming. There are plenty on both sides, so it hasn’t been too different — except maybe a little bit in the advance scouting. I’ve had more at bats in the National League, so ...


Jeremy Maclin not happy with Riley Cooper’s contract remark

Broncos reportedly waive kicker McManus, sign Connor Barth

Report: Browns not committed to Brian Hoyer long-term

Pablo Sandoval, Red Sox officially agree to contract

Ex-NFLer passed out in Wendy's drive-thru, arrested for DUI

Ex-NFL DB Fred Smoot arrested on domestic assault charges


Jets’ Sheldon Richardson: ‘I didn’t get drafted to lose games’

Jose Canseco's fiancée Leila Knight breaks it off with slugger

Rex Ryan reportedly wants to start Michael Vick in Week 13

Tom Thibodeau: Derrick Rose must ‘get out there and play’

Reports: Jon Lester, Red Sox still engaged in contract talks

Peter King, Red Sox picked the wrong time to send these tweets

Why Packers' offense continues to evolve despite success

'Fire Idzik' billboard updated with suggestion for Jets owner

Watt buys pizza, shows gratitude to Houston firefighters, cops

College football's post-Week 13 Playoff projection

Which teams have the best shot at an undefeated season?

Infographic: Terrell Suggs' sack victims after notching 100th

Dude Perfect video features Russell Wilson, Pete Carroll

Rick Pitino 'played four white guys and an Egyptian' in blowout

NFL Power Rankings after Week 12

WATCH: James Harden had another lapse on defense

One thing every NFL team should be thankful for

Could Kentucky beat the 76ers?

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.

Maclin unhappy with Cooper comments

Post-Week 13 CFB Playoff projection

What has Masai Ujiri built in Toronto?

How L.A. should replace Hanley

Lester, Red Sox still talking contract

Why each NFL team should be thankful

Could Kentucky beat the 76ers?

Greatest college football rivalries

LeBron on losing streak: 'I stink'

Report: Manziel, friends get in brawl

Tate: Loss to Pats was 'embarrassing'

Bill Belichick burns Dominic Raiola

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.