Found January 02, 2013 on
Despite all the denials, Andre Ethier‘s name continues to come up in trade rumors, and given what I’ve heard, I don’t think it’s just noise. The latest has him heading to the Mariners, and it’s via ESPN‘s Jason Churchill (1, 2, 3). Hearing Mariners have progressed in trade talks for a hitter. Indications it’s Ethier. Multiple players involved. @nbynwms very possible. Heard 7 or more players could be in it… Two from LAD, 4 from sea. That leaves at least one player from 3rd team @joshuacarpino there will be cash involved If you don’t trust Churchill, then Mike Petriello has said that he heard as much on Ethier’s situation. —– Anyway, given that information, one has to surmise that the deal might look something like this: Seattle Mariners Get: Andre Ethier/Chris Capuano/Cash Los Angeles Dodgers Get: Brendan Ryan/Franklin Gutierrez/Prospects From the Mariners perspective, they’re getting a solid ~2 WAR pitcher in Capuano with some upside and some risk for the price of $6 million with a 2014 mutual option ($1 million buyout). In this market, that’s a bargain and exactly what you want from a pitcher like Capuano, as he’d probably garner a three-year deal as a free agent. In Ethier, they’re getting a flawed but solidly above-average regular worth between 2.5-3.5 WAR, but he’s locked up through his decline years. He has little trade value with his current contract, but there’s still the cash aspect to examine. The cash part of the deal is where it gets interesting, as the quality of prospects will likely depend on the amount of money taken on by the Dodgers. While I have heard people throw around names like James Paxton, Taijuan Walker, and Danny Hultzen, I doubt the Dodgers can coerce the Mariners into parting with any of that trio unless they eat almost all of Ethier’s contract. In a more realistic scenario, they would part with a couple solid prospects, and then what the Mariners would need is enough money to make Ethier an asset again, so perhaps something in the $20 million to $25 million range. Other players the Mariners are parting with would include Brendan Ryan and Franklin Gutierrez. Ryan is an underrated player and an above-average regular, but he’s not the shortstop of the future as he hits free agency in 2014. Gutierrez is player with potential as a regular, but hasn’t been healthy in two years and also hits free agency in 2014. All considered, if the Mariners can get a solid chunk of money in the deal and only have to surrender a couple B-/C+ level prospects, the trade shouldn’t be a problem from their perspective. —– As for the Dodgers, this deal makes no sense for them on the surface. After all, for his faults, Ethier (plus cash) is still a productive player and Capuano is a solid starter. Additionally, the return of Ryan and Gutierrez seems light on present impact, which is what the Dodgers are looking to gain. A closer look, though, reveals how it could make sense. For starters, Ethier has basically zero trade value because of his five-year/$85 million contract. Nick Swisher, a similar player that I compared Ethier with earlier, got a four-year/$56 million deal on the open market, so you can see the overpay there in clear and present terms. The amount of cash will be what actually determines how much of an asset he is to the Mariners. Plus, as far as Capuano goes, he has essentially no utility to the Dodgers in his current situation due to the sheer number of starters they have. As such, the return of decent but unspectacular players with expiring contracts, along with average prospects, makes sense. Moreover, losing Ethier is part of the plan for the Dodgers, as we assume they would then go on to sign Michael Bourn. In an earlier comparison between him and Ethier, I found that he could be an immediate 1-2 win upgrade, so that would be a clear win for the team as it is. Then there’s the other pieces, who are actually worth more to the Dodgers than they seem. Ryan is a shortstop that can’t hit a lick, but is still a ~2.5 WAR player because of his consistently plus-plus defense across all defensive metrics and … well … if you watch the highlight reels like I do. The addition of him would hypothetically allow Hanley Ramirez to slide to third and Luis Cruz to then become a super-sub type, which fixes a lot of problems on the bench. Replacing Hanley with Ryan at short could be a ~30 run upgrade defensively in itself. Gutierrez also excels defensively but has struggled to stay healthy. He can play a plus-plus center field and would be an outstanding fourth outfielder, as I think he could be a solid regular if he could ever stay healthy. As it stands though, he could end up being anywhere between a 0 to 3 WAR player. His acquisition would eliminate yet another need for the Dodgers bench and provide a solid contingency plan for every starter. Now throw in a couple solid prospects as the cherry on top, and the Dodgers have just upgraded their starting lineup, resolved one of their starter dilemmas, filled two holes, extended their bench, and added to a sagging farm system. —– Granted, this is a lot of moving parts, but I struggle to see another way this works out between the two teams, if it ever does. I honestly like the trade for both sides in this proposed scenario, as I think both teams would get what they’ve been wanting. Generally speaking, this is obviously an incredibly inefficient way to do business for the Dodgers, but if the money doesn’t matter, then these sets of moves would clearly improve the roster like they want. I do still have minor lingering concerns about where exactly the money ends, especially looking toward the future, but the details of the potential television contract have allayed my worries for at least a little while, and flags fly forever, so why not chase them while the opportunity exists?

Andre Ethier trade would improve farm system, but ulitmately limits flexibility

Well, well, well, apparently Andre Ethier isn't as unavailable as previously expected. The Dodgers, despite reports from some in the national media, have been talking to other teams about the outfielder -- specifically, the Seattle Mariners. Jason Churchill of Prospect Insider and ESPN tweeted the news on New Year's Eve. "Hearing Mariners have progressed in trade...

Dodgers invite top prospects to Winter Development Program in Arizona

The Dodgers have invited 13 prospects to their annual Winter Development Program, which begins next week at Camelback Ranch. The camp is usually held at Dodger Stadium, but as Ken Gurnick wrote, the stadium is undergoing major renovations, making it unavailable for use. Position players (5) Tim Federowicz Jeremy Moore Joc Pederson Yasiel Puig Matt Wallach ...

Five prospects with a shot at the Mariner’s opening day roster

Influx of youth to affect 2013 Despite their flurry of veteran pickups this winter, the Seattle Mariners are still entrenched in a youth movement. A movement that could mean the future of the organization. With plenty of roster spots up for grabs—and some of the game’s top prospects chomping at the bit—the Mariners will have their hands full this Spring Training. Any top prospect...

Player Profile #191: Josh Beckett | SP | LAD

Josh Beckett has endured a lot of bad press over the last two years, and he’s to blame for pretty much all of it. The good news for bargain-hunting fantasy managers is that all the talk about his bad attitude, poor conditioning, and general selfishness might do wonders for his average draft position. According to Mock Draft Central that hasn’t been the case so far, but I find...

Former Angels' IF Adam Kennedy Looks to be Retiring From Baseball

Adam Kennedy, who spent much of his career playing for the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim/Anaheim Angels, is all but retired from Major League Baseball.  Kennedy has not announced his retirement, but he is moving on with his life and focusing on teaching baseball. According to Mike DiGiovanna of the Los Angeles Times, Kennedy is set to open a baseball academy in the Anaheim...

Mariners' Franklin Gutierrez Had a Huge Winter After Injury-Plagued Season

Franklin Gutierrez used the Winter as a time to get more baseball in.  Considering he missed much of the 2012 season with injuries, that was probably a good idea.  Considering how well he played, it was probably a great idea.  The Seattle Mariners could use a rejuvenated Gutierrez heading into next season. According to Greg Johns of, Gutierrez hit .349 in the Venezuelan...

Hall Of Fame Ballot Deadline Is Tonight

Tonight, December 31, is the deadline for all eligible BBWAA voters to submit their Hall of Fame ballots. My own ballot has already been cast and I voted for Mike Piazza, Craig Biggio, Edgar Martinez, Jeff Bagwell, Fred McGriff, Jack Morris, Don Mattingly and Tim Raines. I know many Met fans will anxiously await the outcome of the vote with the earnest hope that Mike Piazza gets...

Report: Mariners, Marlins Have Discussed Deal for Giancarlo Stanton

The Marlins have said they aren’t shopping Giancarlo Stanton, but that hasn’t stopped teams from asking about the star outfielder. The Seattle Mariners have discussed a possible deal with Miami for Stanton, according to Jon Morosi of FOX Sports. Morosi mentioned that Seattle’s pitching prospects could interest the Marlins. The Mariners have RHP Taijuan Walker, LHP Danny Hultzen...

Mariners Rumors: Seattle Targeting Marlins’ Giancarlo Stanton

The Miami Marlins have said they’re willing to listen to offers on outfielder Giancarlo Stanton, and the Seattle Mariners have reached out regarding the slugger, according to Jon Paul Morosi of FOX Sports. Mariners have contacted Marlins about Giancarlo Stanton, but one source I talked with doubts a trade will occur. — Jon Morosi (@jonmorosi) January 1, 2013 ...

Source: Mariners, Marlins have discussed Stanton

The Seattle Mariners and Miami Marlins have had discussions about a trade that would send outfielder Giancarlo Stanton to Seattle, but one source told that a deal appears doubtful at this point. After failing to sign free agent Josh Hamilton, the Mariners still are looking for a big bat to help what was the American League’s worst offense in 2012. The Mariners traded...

Rumor Roundup: Wednesday, January 2 by Daniel Rathman

The Mariners continue to search for offense, and Javier Vazquez ponders a return to the majors.
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.