Found April 22, 2012 on Fox Sports Detroit:
DETROIT -- Yes, the umpires blew a call in the 11th inning of Detroit's 3-2 loss to Texas on Sunday. No one disputes that, including the umpires. That said, it probably didn't cost the Tigers the game. With the score tied after 10 innings, Tigers manager Jim Leyland was forced to use Thad Weber in relief. Weber was making his major-league debut and facing baseball's best offense. Texas immediately loaded the bases on a walk and two singles, bringing Alberto Gonzalez to the plate. On the first pitch, Gonzalez bunted the ball toward the mound for a suicide squeeze. With no chance to get the runner at the plate, Weber turned to throw to first, but Miguel Cabrera had charged the bunt and couldn't get back to the bag in time. That put Texas ahead 3-2, and they still had the bases loaded with no one out, but there was a problem. Several Tigers, including Leyland, had seen the bunt hit Gonzalez's knee before bouncing off the dirt and into fair territory. Since Gonzalez was still in the batter's box, the correct call would have been a foul ball, leaving Gonzalez still at the plate with an 0-1 count. Leyland came out to argue the decision, and Welke brought his umpiring crew together to confer on the call. None of the other umpires had seen the ball hit Gonzalez, so the call stood. "I saw just what it did - the ball came down and hit him on the back knee," Leyland said. "Normally, someone sees that - one of the umpires sees it. For whatever reason, they didn't see it." After the game, though, Welke acknowledged that he had seen a replay and that the ball had clearly hit Gonzalez Gonzalez also confirmed that the ball had hit him. "It did," Welke said. "You can decide anything you want and deduce from that, but we didn't see the ball hit anyone on the field. We called what we saw, and we didn't see him get hit." Tigers catcher Alex Avila had a hard time blaming Welke for missing the call. "You can't expect him to see it, because I didn't see it," he said. "But that's why you have four umpires - so they can get it right." The call became more important when Weber got pinch-hitter Mitch Moreland to ground into a 1-2-3 double play, then retired Kinsler to get out of the inning with only the one run having scored. Cabrera singled with two out in the bottom of the 11th, putting the tying run on base, but Joe Nathan got Prince Fielder to fly out to the wall in right, ending the game. The save was Nathan's 34th in 34 career tries against the Tigers. On paper, the umpiring mistake could have cost Detroit the game. If the ball is ruled foul, then Gonzalez hits into the double play and Moreland grounds out, the Tigers would at least have played into the 12th inning. Leyland, though, didn't see it that way. He focused more on the fact that Cabrera's 11th-inning single was the only baserunner the Tigers got in the final five innings. "It's too bad, but that happens," he said. "We didn't swing the bats, and to put this all on the umpires would be totally wrong." The controversial ending overshadowed an outstanding performance from rookie pitcher Drew Smyly. Making just his third career start, Smyly held Texas to one run in six innings, striking out seven. "I thought he did a terrific job holding down a team that been really hot," Leyland said. "He had the advantage that they hadn't seen him before, but he threw the ball well, and he kept them off-balance." Smyly has a 1.13 ERA in his three starts, changing the fifth-starter slot from an expected weakness into a strength. On the other hand, Detroit's offense has been surprisingly weak. In the last 10 games, the Tigers have scored 30 runs and are batting .210. "We didn't really muster any threats - it wasn't like we had the bases loaded or two guys on," Leyland said. "We just didn't do much offensive. Some of that is that they pitched real good, but some of it is that we're not swinging the bat real good right now." NOTES: Cabrera, who was unable to get back to first base in time to make a play on Gonzalez's squeeze bunt, was playing the position for the first time this season. Brandon Inge hit for Don Kelly in the bottom of the 10th, and then stayed in the game at third base, with Cabrera moving to first. Fielder, the usual first baseman, was the designated hitter. ... Smyly is the first Tigers pitcher since 1918 to allow zero or one runs in each of his first three starts.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Snippets on the 30 Detroit Tigers from 2012

The Detroit Tigers were hit with a harsh dose of reality over the weekend during a 4 game series with the Texas Rangers. That reality was quite simple: they’re not as good as Texas. Yes, Verlander was his usual dominant self and got a win on Saturday. Yes, a weird bunt off the knee play in the 11th inning that shouldn’t have counted plated the go-ahead run on Sunday to secure...

Jacob Turner pitches for Lakeland

Jacob Turner is back on the mound. Turner, who dealt with shoulder problems in spring training, made his 2012 debut for Single-A Lakeland Monday night. Turner pitched four innings without allowing a hit or a run. He did walk two batters, but picked off one of them. Turner, the Tigers' first-round pick in 2009, is considered their top pitching prospect. He spent most of last...

Tigers weekly: Power outage on offense

The one given for the Detroit Tigers this season was supposed to be offense. The defense was going to be questionable and there was some uncertainty over the back end of the rotation, but no one doubted that the Tigers would hit. Right now, they aren't hitting. In Detroit's last 10 games, the offense has produced only 30 runs at a .210 batting average - a rate that has...

Transaction Blog: Weber Up, Schlereth Down

Stay current with all the roster movement and personnel decisions with the TigsTown Transaction Blog. The Tigers purchased the contract of right-hander Thad Weber and optioned Daniel Schlereth to Toledo due to his struggles and the need for a long reliever in the bullpen.

Game 2012.15: Rangers at Tigers

Well, that was quick.  The Rangers put the game away with 8 runs in the first inning before a stunned Rick Porcello could even record a second out.  The Rangers rolled to their 8th straight, beating Detroit 10-4, and have now outscored them 20-7 so far this series. If there was a bright spot for the Tigers, it was another great outing by Duane Below, who threw 6 scoreless innings...

Tigers salvage doubleheader split

DETROIT -- Justin Verlander didn't throw a perfect game or even a no-hitter Saturday, but against the hottest team in baseball, it might as well have been. The White Sox's Philip Humber might have thrown a perfect game against the Seattle Mariners, but the Mariners lineup doesn't quite equal that of the Texas Rangers, which Verlander said is the best in the American...

Game 2012.16: Rangers at Tigers

Good pitching beats good hitting. Or maybe the adage should be superior pitching meets incredible hitting. On a day when JV did not have his best stuff, he demonstrated why he’s the best pitcher in baseball by shutting down baseball’s best offense and ending the Rangers’ 8 game winning streak. Ron Washington said after the game “We didn’t lose, we got beat.” + 1. JV’s...

There’s a New Ranger in Town

3 HR's for Hamilton in the series It’s safe to say that this past series between the Texas Rangers and the Detroit Tigers is one that will try and be quickly forgotten. Coming into this series the Rangers were coming into Comerica Park winners of their past six games in a row. The Tigers had just come a sweep of the Kansas City Royals and winners of their last four. This series...

Tongue-wagging Rangers fan crashes Tigers live broadcast (Video)

FOX Sports reporter Shannon Hogan was videobombed during a live segment at Sunday's Detroit Tigers game by a Texas Rangers fan who stood right behind her wagging his tongue. The Rangers fan started out innocently enough, showing off his jersey and walking away. However, a few seconds later, the Rangers fan came back and started wagging his tongue like a crazed maniac...

Bunt carries Rangers past Tigers

Alberto Gonzalez's squeeze bunt turned into an RBI infield single in the 11th inning, and the Texas Rangers went on to beat the Detroit Tigers 3-2 on Sunday. With the bases loaded and nobody out, Gonzalez bunted back to pitcher Thad Weber (0-1), who had no play at the plate on runner Nelson Cruz. Weber froze with the ball, and first baseman Miguel Cabrera struggled to get back...

Tigers, Rangers rained out

Jim Leyland is as impressed with the Texas Rangers as he was during last year's playoffs. ''They're such a tremendously solid team in all areas - starting pitching, defense, bullpen, offense,'' the Detroit manager said Friday. ''They're a very good team, top to bottom. They have a lot of nice weapons, they have a lot of versatility. They're...

Beltre going for a MRI tomorrow

The Rangers blog on ESPN Dallas has reported Beltre will seek an MRI on Monday. He strained his hamstring in the first game of the Rangers double header Saturday vs. the Tigers. Beltre still does not believe he’ll be out of the lineup for an extended period of time. Alberto Gonzalez is in the lineup at third
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.