Originally written on The Sports Post  |  Last updated 11/19/14
40
David Ortiz undoubtedly celebrating a spectacular hit. (Photo credit) The year 1973 was a very important one for comedic television. It was the year Dave Chappelle, Seth MacFarlane, Neil Patrick Harris, and Jim Parsons were born. Without them, television as we know it would be a duller place. But another improvement was also born that year that would impact the future of television; It was the year that the designated hitter was introduced to the American League.   This meant that instead of watching a pitcher try not to strike out, baseball fans, in one league at least, could watch an invasion of home runs with the addition of another power bat to the lineup. Edgar Martinez is usually celebrated as the best DH of all time. His eighteen-year career with the Mariners was spectacular, no doubt, but I say that David Ortiz is better. Ortiz has become a Boston legend during his tenure with the Red Sox. The argument about who is the best DH of all time, in most cases, comes down to these two sluggers. The argument for Edgar Martinez is greatly bolstered by the credibility of Sports Illustrated, which recently ranked him as the best designated hitter. He defined consistency, batting over .300 eleven times in 18 years. He hit more than 25 home runs five times and was always someone Mariners fans could rely on. And, in an age when performance-enhancing drugs were rampant, Martinez was not much of a traditional power hitter, hitting over 30 home runs once (37 in 2000). He was more of an average guy, winning the batting title in both 1992 and 1995. But is that what you want out of your DH? You can find high average hitters who play the field. The DH is supposed to be a guy who can drive in runs, which Martinez could, but other DHs do it at a higher rate. The DH is supposed to be the scary guy who can clear bases with a single stroke and instantly change the game. Enter Ortiz. Ortiz has had an awkward career. He suffered a great deal of injuries and was inconsistent at the plate during his early career with the Twins. But, when the Red Sox signed him in 2003, he made a giant impact on the Boston offensive attack. He has hit over 30 home runs six times and has hit over .300 five times, as well. For comparison’s sake, I have looked at each player’s eight prime seasons. Martinez’s prime was between 1995 and 2003, omitting his 2002 campaign based on a lack of at-bats. His average numbers: 27 home runs, 108 RBIs, and a .324 average. These numbers are definitely impressive. Ortiz’s prime was between 2003 and 2011 subtracting his 2008 season due to a lack of at-bats, as well. His statistics: 37 home runs, 117 RBI’s, and a .293 average. I assumed Martinez would dominate the statistics, but that is not the case. During both players’ primes, Ortiz averages 10 more home runs a season -- the difference between an average power hitter and an elite one. One of the most important stats for a hitter batting in the heart of a lineup is RBI because that is how you win the game. An offense’s job is to score runs and Ortiz accounted for more runs than Martinez did, hands down. Martinez does have a significant advantage in batting average over Ortiz, but again, how monumental is that stat compared to home runs and RBI when considering where both hitters batted in the order? And we haven’t even gotten to the most important factor: David Ortiz is a team leader. No hitter has come closer to single-handedly winning a series more than David Ortiz in the ’04 ALCS. He hit five home runs with 23 RBI, while batting a scorching .409. That is all not including his two walk-off hits. Ortiz is a two-time World Champion and was a major factor for both titles. Martinez never made it out of the ALCS and although he hit a clutch double in the 1995 ALDS, he will never be able to compare to the playoff success of Ortiz. Ortiz is on a top-ten list of all-time hitters you would want up with the game on the line. Martinez would not make that list. The best way to look at any debate like this is to ask which player would you want to build a team around. Both qualify as quality character guys and solid leaders, but how can you deny the performances of Ortiz in the playoffs? You want that guy on your team, not a hitter who hit over 30 home runs once in his eighteen-year career. Look at the Hall of Fame voting for Edgar Martinez. First eligible in 2010, he received 36.2 percent of the vote and that number has not increased much in the following years. It was 36.5 percent in 2012. In contrast, it’s hard to see a scenario where David Ortiz is not a first ballot Hall of Famer. To be fair, one hitter has been overlooked in this debate. Frank Thomas may have better number than both guys. His peak seasons from 1993 to 2000 make an impressive case. He averaged 35 home runs, 118 RBIs, and a .321 average. His home run and RBI total compare to Ortiz’s and his average compares to Martinez’s. I would take Ortiz over Thomas, though, with the game or season on the line. Thomas only played in one ALCS. When talking about the best player ever in a position, I think he needs to have made such an impact that his team won a World Series. But with Thomas’ numbers, how could you possibly justify calling Martinez a better hitter? I know that the best DH every season is awarded the Edgar Martinez Outstanding Designated Hitter Award, but that does not make him the best DH of all time. Honestly, it doesn’t even make him the second best DH of all time. By: Matt Levine Twitter: @Matt_TFJ
GET THE YARDBARKER APP:
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Pacquiao to have surgery to repair 'significant' shoulder tear

Chris Paul ruled out for Game 1 against Rockets

Stephen Curry thanks father in touching MVP speech

Lawrence Taylor's son pleads guilty to statutory rape

49ers FB Bruce Miller charged with vandalism

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Report: Winston snubbed ESPN out of draft interview

Report: Some Colts players unhappy with first-round pick

Falcons GM Thomas Dimitroff: Focus is on Julio Jones contract

Irvin on Seahawks not picking up option: ‘F— that option’

Brandon Prust rips referee, accuses him of on-ice trash talk

LeBron James ditched headband to look more like teammates

Five overhyped NFL Draft storylines that didn't play out

WATCH: Chris Johnson wants to play for the Cowboys

WATCH: Chewbacca throws out 1st pitch at Red Sox game

WATCH: Kyrie Irving carves up Bulls' defense for layup

WATCH: Metallica goes Jimi Hendrix for national anthem

Brandon McCarthy shares disturbing info about himself

Ole Miss fan got pregnant because of upset over Alabama

Willie Cauley-Stein legally changes middle name to 'Trill'

Marcus Mariota welcomed to Tennessee with billboard

Five takeaways from the first round of the NBA playoffs

NFL has a Los Angeles Rams webpage

10 undrafted free agents who could become NFL stars

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
the YARDBARKER app
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Cauley-Stein changes middle name to 'Trill'

NFL has Los Angeles Rams webpage

10 undrafted free agents to watch

Report: Winston snubbed ESPN

Life without Love: The new-look Cavs

Drafted player changes Twitter name to ‘Pick 245′

Floyd Mayweather Punch Out mock video game is great

Report: Steph Curry to be NBA MVP

Kelly: Tebow here to compete for job

Tony Allen booed for being rude?

Lindsey Vonn, Tiger Woods break up

Pacquiao fought with injured shoulder?

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.