Found September 04, 2013 on Fox Sports:
The debate is over. It ended on Nov. 18, 2010, the day Felix Hernandez won the American League Cy Young Award with a 13-12 record, beating David Price, who was 19-6, and CC Sabathia, who was 21-7. Most voters get it. They know, thanks to the rise of sabermetrics, that win-loss record alone is a poor measure of pitching excellence. There is no chance we will ever see a repeat of 1990, when Bob Welch's 27 wins prevailed over Roger Clemens' 21, even though Clemens' 1.93 ERA was more than a full run per game lower. So, while my friend Brian Kenny rants daily on Twitter and MLB Network about "killing" the win and educating all of us half-wits in the Baseball Writers Association of America, he's like a single-issue candidate fighting for a law that already has passed. The better questions, as they pertain to this year's American League Cy Young race, are these: - Who is more deserving, Detroit's Max Scherzer or Texas' Yu Darvish? - Should wins matter at all? Let's tackle the second question first, though it is somewhat less pressing than it was a week ago: Scherzer twice has failed to get his 20th victory, and on Tuesday night suffered his second loss, falling to Boston, 2-1. Of course, Scherzer still could finish 24-2 if he wins all of his remaining starts, a record that -- in the view of most casual fans -- seemingly would assure him of the Cy Young. Darvish was 12-6 entering his start Wednesday afternoon in Oakland, but as we shall see, in most other statistical categories, the two were quite close. So, what about the difference in their respective win totals? Well, it can be attributed partly to Scherzer's run support, which is the best in the majors by a considerable margin. In both of Scherzer's losses -- surprise! -- the Tigers scored just one run. Run support and bullpen support contribute mightily to a pitcher's win total -- and a pitcher, of course, has zero control over both. But when I posed the win-loss question to a friend of mine, a sabermetrician who works in a major league front office, his response was considerably less strident than Kenny's. I'm granting my friend anonymity to protect him from the barbarians at the gate on both sides of the discussion and also to shield the identity of his club. The old-school/new-school debate over win-loss records, my friend said, is ongoing even within his own front office. And the old-school types, he conceded, "have a point." "They're sophisticated enough to understand run support, defense, BABIP (batting average on balls in play) left-on-base percentage, luck, etc.," my friend said. "All those things affect win-loss, but there is some variation in win-loss record that might be explained by experience, know-how, in-game strategy. Maybe the explanatory power is vanishingly small, but it probably is not zero." My friend went on to say that if a pitcher "knows how to win," his savvy will show up in other advanced stats but "maybe not completely." The larger question, he said, is whether certain pitchers "pitch to the score," as Jack Morris says he did throughout his career. Morris says that he wasn't worried about his ERA when he had a big lead; he pitched more to contact, and if his ERA and other statistics suffered, so be it. I don't vote for Morris for the Hall of Fame; his career 3.90 ERA would be the highest of any pitcher in the Hall, and I'm wary of lowering that standard. But my friend says that we should perhaps be less skeptical of "pitching to the score," reasoning that if managers manage to the score, it shouldn't be outrageous to think that pitchers would do the same. OK, but back to win-loss record. Few knowledgeable observers assign it great meaning, but my friend says, "I don't see it disappearing; it contains information." What kind of information? A pitcher's ability to work deep into games, for starters (something that is more clearly reflected by his innings total). Also, a pitcher's ability to hold leads. Darvish, according to STATS LLC, has lost leads of two or more runs in six of his 26 starts -- we're talking about his final lead, not any two-run lead during the course of a game. Scherzer, on the other hand, has squandered such leads in only two of his 28 starts. Means something , doesn't it? Yes. Especially when otherwise, the two are nearly inseparable. Darvish, entering Wednesday, had the slightly better ERA, 2.73 to 2.88. He also had the better ERA-plus, a statistic that adjusts ERA to a pitcher's league and ballpark -- no small thing in this discussion, since Darvish pitches in the hitter-friendly Ballpark in Arlington while Scherzer works in more pitcher-friendly Comerica Park (though Comerica, according to park factor, actually rates as more hitter-friendly than the Ballpark this season). Scherzer ranked first in opponents' OPS (Darvish was second) and ahead of Darvish in Fielding Independent Pitching (FIP) and both accepted measures of Wins Above Replacement (WAR), Baseball-Reference and Fangraphs. Darvish ranked first in strikeouts per nine innings -- his current rate of 12.16 would be one of the 10 highest in major-league history -- and fewest hits per nine. Scherzer was second in both categories. Others also deserve mention. Scherzer's teammate, Anibal Sanchez, leads the league in ERA and also would be among the Cy Young favorites if he had not missed three weeks with a strained right shoulder. The Chicago White Sox's Chris Sale currently would be third on my ballot despite his 10-12 record. Seattle's Hernandez and Hisashi Iwakuma also would merit top-five consideration. Right now, though, I've got Scherzer first, and not because he is 19-2. No, I've got Scherzer ahead of Darvish and the others because he ranks at or near the top in more statistical categories that we now consider important. The award is for best pitcher, and to this point Scherzer has been just that, the best of the best. I won't actually cast a ballot for AL Cy this season -- I'm voting for AL MVP and NL Cy Young -- but if I did, I would withhold judgment, waiting to see if anything changed in the final few weeks. Most voters generally stay similarly open-minded. And most are quite mindful of their responsibilities despite what some critics will have you believe. Heaven knows we're not perfect, but if there is one thing we have proved, it's that we understand the diminished value of pitchers' wins and losses. The debate is over. It ended in 2010. A pitcher needs much more than a gaudy win-loss record to capture a Cy Young.

Felix Hernandez leaves Monday night's game with cramp

Seattle Mariners' ace Felix Hernandez left Monday night's game against the Kansas City Royals in the seventh inning due to a lower back cramp.  He left for precautionary reasons  with the Mariners behind 3-1. As reported by Robert Falkoff of, After a 1-1 pitch to Alex Gordon with two outs in the seventh inning, Hernandez put his hand near the left side of his...

Felix Hernandez’s start pushed back; Innings taking toll?

Seattle Mariners cornerstone Felix Hernandez has had his next scheduled start pushed back to Wednesday – when they host the Houston Astros. His start has been pushed back in result of the club being precautionary in hoping that the back cramps that the King is currently dealing with subsides. Hernandez was suffering back cramps previously during his Labor Day start at the Kansas...

Red Sox Take Important Step in Proving Playoff Readiness With Big Win Over Max Scherzer, Tigers

Though most players avoided admitting it, Tuesday night’s game felt like postseason baseball at Fenway Park. The matchup featured not only the best two teams in the American League in the Red Sox and Tigers, but also the star of each team’s respective pitching staff. It has been said that this year’s edition of the Boston Red Sox is built for the regular season, but ill-suited...

Miguel Cabrera, Max Scherzer Lead Teammates in Singing of ‘Sweet Caroline’ During Eighth Inning (Video)

Typically, the Fenway Faithful are responsible for belting out the words to “Sweet Caroline”  during the middle of the eighth inning, but a few members of the Detroit Tigers couldn’t help themselves from joining in on Monday afternoon. Holding a three-run lead against the Red Sox, the Tigers were feeling upbeat about their day, and they chose to commemorate the occasion with...

Felix loses again, Royals top Mariners 3-1

Felix Hernandez lost his fourth straight start and Will Smith struck out a career high eight to help the Kansas City Royals beat the Seattle Mariners 3-1 on Monday. The Mariners left-hander hasn't lost four straight starts since 2008. He also left in the seventh inning with a cramp in his lower back. Smith (2-1) pitched 4 1-3 innings of scoreless relief to pick up the victory...

Scherzer takes second loss of season

Jon Lester outdueled Max Scherzer and the Boston Red Sox beat Detroit 2-1 on Tuesday night, ending the Tigers right-hander's chance to become just the second pitcher to open a season with a 20-1 record.

Jon Lester Says He Couldn’t Worry About Max Scherzer, Focused on Giving Team Best Chance to Win (Video)

It was a battle of two aces on Tuesday night, but Jon Lester saved one of his best performances of the season for the occasion, and he was rewarded with a hard-earned win. The left-hander allowed only one run, and struck out a season-high nine batters over his seven innings of work. Lester outdueled Max Scherzer who was seeking his 20th win of the season, and looking to become...

Red Sox-Tigers Live: Jon Lester, Max Scherzer Face Off at Fenway in Battle of Aces

8 a.m. ET: Monday’s series opener between the Red Sox and Tigers was not what you would expect from the two highest-scoring teams in baseball. Both starters took shutouts into the seventh inning, with Detroit’s Doug Fister emerging victorious in a 3-0 Tigers win. Don’t be shocked if you see more of the same on Tuesday. The second matchup in a three-game series between the...

Game 140: Tigers at Red Sox - Lester looks to prevent win No. 20 for Scherzer

Ben Whitehead Contributing Writer Even without Miguel Cabrera, the Detroit Tigers showed why they are still considered the team to beat in the American League, shutting out the Boston Red Sox 3-0 in the series opener on Labor Day. Detroit (81-57) now trails Boston (82-57) by a half-game for the best record in the AL with a chance to overtake the top spot tonight. Jon Lester has...

Lester outduels Scherzer in Tigers' loss to Red Sox

If you wanted to know why Max Scherzer was not able to win his 20th game of the season Tuesday night, just look at the box score. When Torii Hunter, Miguel Cabrera (back in the lineup after missing three straight games), Prince Fielder and Victor Martinez go a combined 3-for-16 (.188) with zero RBIs, it's probably not going to be your night. Scherzer pitched extremely well...

Royals steal one from King Felix

by John Viril— The Kansas City Royals stole a win on Sunday from Seattle uber-starter King Felix (Felix Hernandez). With young gun Danny Duffy wobbling in the 4th inning after giving up a single run and runners on 1st and 3rd with two outs, Kansas City’s prospects looked grim against Hernandez. Manager Ned Yost made the unconventional decision to pull his starter at 91 pitches...

Oddsmakers Expect Tigers-Red Sox Series to Be ALCS Preview

The Detroit Tigers have played the Chicago Cubs four times in their postseason history yet somehow have yet to face the Red Sox in the playoffs. Think about that. If Bovada oddsmakers are correct, there will be a Tigers-Red Sox matchup in the American League Championship Series next month. Detroit is the +150 AL pennant favorite with Boston second at +300. It’s now all but a lock...

Top 5 AL Cy Young Contenders

While Los Angeles’ Clayton Kershaw has essentially pitched his way to becoming the clear front-runner for the Cy Young Award in the National League, it appears that Detroit’s Max Scherzer is slowly, but surely becoming an almost virtual lock for the American League honors. The following is a list of the Top 5 pitchers who should be considered for the distinction of being named...

Jacoby Ellsbury Not in Red Sox Lineup, Shane Victorino to Hit Leadoff and Play Center Against Tigers

Jacoby Ellsbury has some good numbers against Detroit Tigers ace and Cy Young favorite Max Scherzer. However, when Scherzer takes the Fenway Park mound Tuesday night, the first batter he see will not be Ellsbury. Instead, Shane Victorino will lead off for the Red Sox in the second game of a three-game set with the Central-leading Tigers. As of Tuesday afternoon, it’s unclear why...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.