Found August 12, 2012 on 60 Max Power O:

The spotlight was on Peyton Maning on Thursday night. Having said that, there were three other Broncos quarterbacks that played vs. the Bears, and two of them were Caleb Hanie and Brock Osweiler.

Hanie, Osweiler and Adam Weber are competing for the backup quarterback gig behind Manning. As of right now, Hanie has the inside track, although Osweiler isn't far behind as the third-string quarterback. Weber is currently listed as the fourth quarterback. The Broncos went in the depth-chart order in Chicago, allowing Manning to start off the game with one drive, before giving Hanie the rest of the first and the entire second quarters to work with the second-team offense. Osweiler played the entire third quarter with the third-string offense.

Here are how both quarterbacks looked on Thursday night in auditioning for the backup gig in a quick analysis.

Caleb Hanie

While watching Hanie vs. the Bears a couple of days ago, all I could think about was how Hanie looked exactly like the quarterback that he was in Chicago in the four games that he started last year, and in his NFC Championship game relief appearance, when he spelled Jay Cutler two seasons ago. Wildy inconsistent, great at making plays with his legs when the pocket collapses, overthrown passes to open targets, and some nice completions mixed in there.

Hanie went 7/14 for 79 yards, with no touchdowns and interceptions. He led one touchdown drive which went for 52 yards in seven plays in the second quarter, which ended with a three yard touchdown run by Xavier Omon.

Hanie had five drives to work with. His first drive began at the CHI 6, with Denver in prime position to score a touchdown. What this drive resulted in was the Broncos kicking a field goal after three plays which resulted in -4 yards gained. Here was the problem with this drive – Hanie threw two passes on second and third downs. One was a pass to TE Clint Ingram out in the flats, in which there was no defender with several yards of Ingram. What this resulted in was an overthrew by Hanie.

The second pass was on a fade route to Matthew Willis towards the right side of the end zone. What this resulted in was an overthrow by Hanie yet again, not giving Willis a chance to haul the ball in the end zone for a touchdown. The one positive of this drive was that he didn't turn the ball over.

Outside of Denver's one touchdown drive led by Hanie, in which he did have a nice 20 yard completion to Ingram to atone for his earlier mistake in the first quarter, Hanie's four drives during the first and second quarters went for 27 plays and 65 yards. For those that know how to do math, that's a little over two yards per play. That's against a second-string defense.

What do you deduct from one preseason performance by Hanie? Although there are three more preseason games to go, this is Hanie as a quarterback in a nutshell – if this guy steps in to be your starting quarterback after an injury to your starting quarterback a la Jay Cutler or Peyton Manning, your team is simply screwed.

Why is this? Hanie is too inconsistent and hesitant with his decision making. His strengths lie in his mobility and his ability to improvise. I would go so far as to say that he is one of the better quarterbacks in the league at making something out of nothing. There were several runs that he had in the first quarter that were as a result of bad pass protection by the second-team offensive line. He made plays that guys not named Vince Young, Tim Tebow and Michael Vick cannot make.

Having said that, when it comes to his play in the pocket, he overthrows open receivers, although he will make the nice completion from time to time. If his first or second read is covered, he is too indecisive and either stands in the pocket too long to take a sack, runs around too long to improvise, which eventually results in a sack (Shea McClellin's 10 yard sack on Hanie was an example of this), or simply throws an incompletion.

Caleb is the perfect quarterback to have as a third-stringer with little film of him. He can improvise and lead a team back when an opposing team does not expect him to play. This was evidenced by his solid performance in the NFC Championship game as a sub for the even worse Todd Collins. He was within 20 or so yards of tying the game for the Bears.

Hanie had an OK performance on Thursday night, but he is better suited to be a third-string quarterback in this league, rather than as a backup. His 0-4 performance for the Bears in 2011 displayed that.

Brock Osweiler

Osweiler on the other hand had three drives, two of them which resulted in touchdowns. One of them was a beautiful 19 yard touchdown pass to Jason Hill over the seam which was timed perfectly. Overall, Osweiler had a better night than Hanie. Osweiler led touchdown drives that went for 52 and 60 yards.

He finished the night 4/7 for 37 yards and a touchdown. He looked poised, remained in the pocket comfortably and had good timing with his receivers.

Having said that, Hanie did face a second-string defense. Osweiler faced the third-team defense. Keep that in mind when analyzing these performances. I don't know what to exactly expect in Denver's preseason home opener vs. Seattle next week. What I mean by that is, does Osweiler get a chance with the second-team offense against the second-team defense to show if he's better against backups than Hanie? Or does the same order remain the same, with Manning, Hannie, Osweiler and Weber vs. Seattle?

I would hope John Fox does something similar to what he did last preseason, with the rotation of Tim Tebow and Brady Quinn as backup quarterbacks in each of the four preseason games.

Osweiler improved his stock for the backup job, while Hanie didn't look great, but he didn't look bad either.

The next three preseason games will display which one of these quarterbacks deserve the backup gig.

Be sure to check out other great articles at Sports Media 101.

THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES

Denver Broncos Vs. Chicago Bears: Analyzing Peyton Manning

Here was Peyton Manning's final stat line by the end of the Broncos' first preseason game in Chicago: 4/7 for 44 yards, 1 interception and a 36.3 passer rating. If you read that stat line without watching the game last night, you'd think that Manning had an off game. In fact, you'd probably think he had a terrible game. From watching the tape, Manning did look...
BROTHERLY LOVE

Eli: Peyton is better quarterback

Eli Manning says that brother Peyton is the better quarterback. There wasn't a debate in the past, but there may be one now.

Preseason Game 1 Breakdowns for San Diego and Denver

Last night, two AFC teams took to the field in their first preseason contests of 2012. Both games were fairly high profile, as the Chargers took on the Packers in a game that featured two on the NFL’s best quarterbacks, while the Broncos took on the Bears, highlighted by the return of Peyton Manning. Here [...]

Peyton Manning shows only a tinge of rust as the Broncos defeat the Bears 31-3

Although the staff of Players View was covering the Atlanta Falcons pre-season affair against the Baltimore Ravens, our attention like many of those in the Georgia Dome was focused on the return Peyton Manning hundreds of miles away in Chicago. Various whispers in the concession lines and neighboring seats could be overheard pondering not only how well he would do but whether or...

Here’s Manning, the Bronco

For the record on August 9, 2012, Peyton Manning stepped onto Soldier Field in the uniform of a Denver Bronco. While the uniform may have been different, the number and acumen were the same. As odd as this may appear to football enthusiasts, Peyton looked like he hasn’t lost a beat. On the field for only [...]

Eric Decker, Peyton Manning clicking in Training Camp for Broncos

Eric Decker and Peyton Manning reportedly have great chemistry in Training Camp, much better than him and Demaryius Thomas. This makes a lot of sense because Peyton Manning loves crisp route runners with reliable hands, rather than pure athletic freaks like Thomas like Tim Tebow did. With Peyton Manning likely to show diminished arm strength this season at age 36 after 4 neck surgeries...

Peyton Manning, RG3 Looking Sharp

Video: 1 throws a pick, 1 throws a TD.

The Good, The Bad and The Ugly: Denver @ Chicago 8/9/12

The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly By Eric Judd   Broncos 31 – Bears 3   The Good   Yeah, I got this. Broncos Oline. It was hard not to like what the Broncos did in this game. Peyton looked good. His arm strength might not be 100%, but his control of the offense was obvious and it is clear the broncos have the inside track in the AFC West. The best part of this early pre-season...

NFL Quick Hits: RGIII, Peyton Manning, Matt Ryan & Steelers’ O-Line Problems

RGIII impresses in preseason debut. What teams essentially look for out of a rookie quarterback making his NFL debut (preseason or otherwise), isn’t that he completes most of his passes or leads his team on a touchdown-scoring drive. Those things are nice, of course, but what is most important is that the young signal caller has command of the huddle, displays composure, and is...

Everybody Knows: Looking for Preseason Storylines

The NFL pre-season is at least two weeks too long and only made longer by the constant rehashing of the agreed upon storylines of the preseason.  Here’s what we know so far: Peyton Manning is a Denver Bronco and NFL experts everywhere will be required by law to state a percentage value for his current level of quarterbacking.  He’s at 85% Chuck! Tim Tebow is a New York...

Broncos beat out Olympic ratings once again

During the Olympics, NBC routinely airs promos for the 2012 NFL season and Sunday Night Football on NBC. On Thursday night, the Denver Broncos opened the preseason with a 31-3 win over the Chicago Bears.  The game, televised locally on KTVD-Channel 20, drew better ratings than the Olympic games on Channel 9. Per the Denver Post‘s Joanne Ostrow — From 6:30-9:45 p.m. Thursday...
NFL Forum Discussions
Can't wait SPLASH MESSAGE! 2 days!
4 replies, 2 days ago
1st win 2013!
2 replies, 2 days ago
Thank you kinmosa and watamote!
4 replies, 2 days ago
Rodgers out 3-6 weeks?
4 replies, 2 days ago
Thank you Vikes!
4 replies, 2 days ago
Thank you 5 years!!!!!
2 replies, 2 days ago
Home Sweet Home!
2 replies, 2 days ago
NFL on NHK next week
2 replies, 2 days ago
Pro Bowl draft
2 replies, 2 days ago
We are NFC EAST Champion!!!!!!!!!!
2 replies, 2 days ago
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.