Found December 13, 2011 on Midway Illustrated:

 

Usually I like to stick to my own thoughts and insight without having to directly address crap put out by the media talking heads here in Chicago, but in the case of Mike Mulligan's article I have to respond.

In Mulligan's article he simply asserts that the Bears' 53-man roster is flawed from top to bottom full of has been players or never will be players or just flat out bad players.   Mulligan couldn't be any more wrong in his assertion, and he needs to take his Jerry Angelo Chicago Bears hating blinders off and CTFD.

The flaw in the Bears as it is with most teams is at the backup quarterback position and a bit in the coaching staff.   Much like the Colts are a annual playoff team when Peyton Manning is behind center, much like the Lions last year and this year and even the almighty Packers last year and this year, the margin for error is slim.

The Packers would not be competing for the perfect season without Aaron Rodgers, not with the worst pass defense in the NFL.   The Packers without Rodgers lost two straight games that nearly kept them from the playoffs last year.  If Rodgers goes down at any point during the playoffs for one game, the Packers are DONE.

Same with the Lions who lost Stafford last season, and have had to count on Stafford's early season heroics in the second half in order to maintain their slight edge for the playoffs.   The Lions had two major early comeback wins over the Cowboys and Vikings, games they should have lost which would easily put them out of the playoff hunt with seven losses.  Instead they received some luck and are still in the playoff hunt.

Caleb HanieThe Bears are in the same boat, with Caleb Hanie that the Packers and Lions would be in with their backup QBs.  Hanie is a flawed QB, and it's not surprising because QBs who can play in the NFL are such a hot commodity that backup QBs are traded in the off-season nearly immediately and with a high value in return.

Yes I was wrong to assert that the Bears would be just fine with Caleb Hanie.  That was my call, Hanie would be fine and the Bears would still be in the playoffs.  Instead the razor's edge sliced open the Bears the last three games with some help along the way fluke hail mary touchdown, fluke play from Marion Barber and just downright bad play from Caleb Hanie against the Raiders.

The Bears would be sitting at 10-3 with Jay Cutler, with injuries to Forte and two starters on the offensive line meaning the roster would be just fine thank you.   As it is overcoming the injuries the Bears have has been remarkable enough, especially considering how bad the starting offensive line was supposed to be.

So yes the Bears have been snake bitten in three straight weeks, but their anti-venom has been on the bench with a thumb injury.   The Bears experienced good fortune last year, and this year they didn't get the same fortune in return.  That's not a flawed roster, that's a sure sign of the competitive balance that is the NFL.

THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Aaron Rodgers should Thank Tebow: Now Hurd

The Green Bay Packers should be feeling the pressure of a perfect season. Aaron Rodgers should have the media following him like a Kardashian. So far ESPN and the media have followed Tim Tebow. Now with the legend of Tebow fading slightly (we only have attentions spans so long), and with 13-0 and every week [...]

It’s right for Packers players to start talking perfection

Aaron Rodgers has been the catalyst in a so-far undefeated season.<img class="size-medium wp-image-7855" ... [visit site to read more] It’s right for Packers players to start talking perfection - Lombardi Ave - Lombardi Ave - A Green Bay Packers Fan Site - News, Blogs, Opinion and more.

Top 10 MVP Candidates Not Named Aaron Rodgers

Saying that Aaron Rodgers is the front-runner for the NFL‘s MVP award is like saying the Detroit Lions are the NFL’s most undisciplined team. Everyone knows it. Everyone accepts it. So there is really no reason to discuss it. Rodgers is just on another level. He is the sun and we are all just basking in his omnipotent glory.  The more interesting discussion comes when Rodgers...

Smith says Hanie made progress

Although he lost his third consecutive start Sunday, Bears quarterback Caleb Hanie is headed in the right direction, coach Lovie Smith said. ‘‘I think it was a step forward,’’ Smith said, pointing to Hanie’s numbers. Hanie was 12-for-19 for 115 yards with no touchdowns and, more important...

Hanie, Bears' offense need to find groove

Martz suggests he'll open up playbook to help HanieAs little as Caleb Hanie has done since taking over for Jay Cutler three games ago, the Bears quarterback is three Marion Barber brain cramps and a Roy Williams drop away from sporting a two-game winning streak.

Will The Green Bay Packers Complete An Undefeated Season?

With a 13-0 record, a road game this week at Kansas City, and their remaining two games in Lambeau Field, the Green Bay Packers and their fans can taste an undefeated regular season. But will they be able to go all the way and finish the season undefeated and back-to-back Super Bowl champions? MSF's own Chris Callaway outside of Lambeau Field. Green Bay’s Path To An...

Packers QB Rodgers defends NL MVP Braun

Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers went on the offensive - in defense of National League MVP Ryan Braun of the Milwaukee Brewers. While the two are admittedly close friends, Rodgers was stunned by the news that Braun was handed a 50-game suspension for a failed drug test. Braun reportedly tested positive for an elevated level of testosterone caused by a synthetic substance...
NFL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.