Originally written on StraitPinkie.com  |  Last updated 11/20/14

The year was 1998. Tiger Woods had won one of his fourteen major championships. Bill Clinton was president. Matthew Stafford was ten years old. And Aerosmith’s “I Don’t Want to Miss a Thing” was number one on the Billboard Hot 100.

The Indianapolis Colts would never be the same.

That year, Peyton Manning took his first snaps as a Colt. In the next 13 years, Indianapolis would see three mayors, a population increase of over 5%, and a new stadium – but only one quarterback. That is until the calamity that was this past season, when Curtis Painter, Kerry Collins, and Dan Orlovsky all proved what many football fans had assumed for years: Peyton Manning is the Indianapolis Colts.

The Colts moved to Indianapolis from Baltimore in 1984. Before Peyton Manning took the helm, they were a laughable franchise. In their first 14 years in Indianapolis, they had only five winning seasons (all 9-7) and an overall record of 88-137. Since Manning became the face of the franchise, the Colts have had 11 winning seasons, and not counting this year, a record of 141-67.

Peyton Manning and his superb quarterback play saved the franchise. It brought a Super Bowl trophy and a Super Bowl weekend to Indianapolis. It built a new stadium. It made the number “18” synonymous with superstar. And now, it seems almost a foregone conclusion that the era will end. Andrew Luck is coming. And Indianapolis isn’t big enough for two franchise quarterbacks.

The argument seems simple enough. Manning’s health and the strength of his regenerating arm is a huge question mark – almost as huge as the paycheck the Colts’ management would owe him if they keep him. Andrew Luck (aka the Colts’ Second Coming) is the surest thing since John Elway. Clearly, the future and the long-term win column seem to be pointing to a single conclusion: Draft Luck and let Manning ride off into the sunset.

But I think it’s time to dispel one of the newest myths of sports: “It’s all about winning.” I mean no offense to Vince Lombardi or his newest contemporaries who spend their afternoons throwing knives at Lebron James and Dan Marino, but this mantra is simply not true. Sports are not all about winning. Winning is not the only thing. If winning were all that mattered in the world of sports, steroids would not have left fans sick to their stomachs and tainted an era of baseball. If winning were all that mattered, Ted Williams would be a chump –another good hitter that never won the October classic. If winning were all that mattered, we wouldn’t celebrate the stories. But we do. The stories are what matter in sports because there is a human connection. When we lose that, we lose everything –even when we “win”.

The emotions that this image of Joe Namath produces are why this Manning situation goes beyond “winning”. It just doesn’t feel right. Teams will always win championships. Fans will always faithfully fill the seats. What is truly rare is finding a player that is not just a star and not just a champion, but a hero – the entire town, the entire franchise – the embodiment of the horseshoe. What is the price tag on that? How many wins is that worth?

It’s easy to be practical. Sometimes, it’s harder to do what is right. Without Peyton Manning, the Colts may have been a football franchise located in Los Angeles. With Peyton Manning, the Colts breathed new life into the city of Indianapolis, and more importantly, gave fans young and old a town hero.

Is it worth a good Luck charm to throw all of that away?

  • Digg this!
  • Share this on Reddit
  • Share this on Facebook
  • Tweet This!
  • Buzz up!
  • Stumble upon something good? Share it on StumbleUpon
  • Share this on Mixx
  • Share this on Linkedin
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Eagles players don't share McCoy's views on Chip Kelly

Bryant attends Cowboys OTAs despite not signing contract

Are Dwyane Wade and the Heat headed for a split?

Good news for the effort to bring an NHL team to Vegas

Adrian Peterson goes on social media rant regarding contract


Report: John Wall, friends kicked off plane in Las Vegas

Broncos OT Ryan Clady suffers torn ACL in practice

Report: Buffalo Sabres to hire Dan Bylsma as head coach

Marc Trestman will make Joe Flacco a Pro Bowler

Could Tyrod Taylor be the Buffalo Bills’ savior?

Chicago Bulls fire Tom Thibodeau after five seasons

Is Sam Bradford not close to full health?

Five NFL players who paid dearly to obtain jersey numbers

Dee Gordon thought Marlins’ manager hire was a joke

Which MLB teams are most changed since Opening Day?

Seattle Mariners: Back to .500

JJ Watt doesn't care for chance to be on 'Hard Knocks'

McElwain compliments Muschamp culture at UF, previous staff 'snakebit'

Montreal mayor to meet Manfred in hopes of getting a franchise back

Five things we'd like to see on 'Hard Knocks' with the Texans

Chipper Jones challenged military veteran to fight

President Obama answers NBA questions on Twitter

'Entourage' creator rips Eli Manning for ditching movie

NFL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Is Sam Bradford not close to full health?

Are Dwyane Wade and the Heat headed for a split?

Good news for the effort to bring an NHL team to Vegas

JJ Watt doesn't care for chance to be on 'Hard Knocks'

Ryan Clady suffers torn ACL

'Entourage' creator rips Eli Manning

Brandon Marshall, Geno Smith are roommates

The Cavaliers are top (under)dogs

Bryce Harper on his breakout

WATCH: Jon Lester sets MLB hitless record

Six moves that made the Warriors NBA title contenders

USA Soccer, CONCACAF losers in FIFA’s ‘World Cup of fraud’

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.