NHL News

Home

Teams

Quizzes

Newsletter

May 18, 2025; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; Toronto Maple Leafs forward Auston Matthews (34) and Florida Panthers goaltender Sergei Bobrovsky (72) shake hands after game seven of the second round of the 2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs at Scotiabank Arena. Mandatory Credit: John E. Sokolowski-Imagn Images

5 Hard Truths About the Maple Leafs After Yet Another Game 7 Exit

Originally posted on The Hockey Writers | By The Old Prof | Last updated Jun 14, 2025 11:20 AM ET

Once again, another spring, another heartbreak for Toronto Maple Leafs fans. The Maple Leafs pushed the Florida Panthers to the edge in Game 7, but it was the same old story. Another early exit, another round of “what went wrong?” ringing through Leafs Nation.

You can tell from reading their responses in the conversation section after posts on The Hockey Writers. Fans are feeling it—some are still hopeful, others just flat-out exhausted. So let’s cut through the noise and talk about five hard truths staring all Maple Leafs fans in the face.

Hard Truth One: The Maple Leafs Still Can’t Close

It’s getting old. This team can hang with anyone during the regular season and even show flashes in the playoffs, but when the pressure ramps up, the team folds. Against the Panthers, Game 5. Game 7. The big moments keep slipping through their fingers.

Fans are convinced that this is not just bad luck anymore. There’s something deeper at play. Whether it’s mental toughness, leadership, or just plain nerves, the Maple Leafs have made a habit of disappearing when it matters. Fans have noticed—some don’t even get angry anymore, just numb. That says a lot.

Hard Truth Two: Playoff Hockey Still Doesn’t Fit Toronto

This team is full of talent—no one questions that. But playoff hockey? That’s a different beast. It’s gritty, heavy, and mean. The Maple Leafs too often look like they’re trying to finesse their way through a bar fight.

Look at how Florida plays. Or Edmonton. They hit, chirp, get under your skin, and win. Meanwhile, the Maple Leafs stick to the outside and hope their power play bails them out. That kind of hockey just doesn’t cut it in the postseason grind.

Hard Truth Three: The Maple Leafs’ Core Has Been Untouchable for Too Long

Auston Matthews, Mitch Marner, John Tavares, William Nylander, and Morgan Rielly have been this team’s heartbeat for years. Sure, they’ve had their moments. But how long do you stick with a core that can’t get over the hump?

The bottom six, the defense pairings, the goalies—they’ve all been shuffled more times than a deck at Casino Rama. But the stars? They’ve been protected. Some fans still believe they are the real deal, while others demand a shake-up. The rumour is that Marner is gone, for sure. For many Maple Leafs fans, something like this is way overdue. Their patience is wearing thin.

Hard Truth Four: NHL Postseason Officials Are Brutal—But No One’s Gonna Save You

Yeah, officiating is all over the place. Yeah, the Panthers got away with a few cheap shots. And yeah, the Maple Leafs always seem to be on the wrong end of it. But here’s the thing: that’s the NHL.

You can’t wait for fairness. You’ve got to hit back, play through it, and send a message. Other teams do it. The Maple Leafs? Not so much. Until that changes (and don’t count on it because fans from every team feel the same way), these kinds of playoff runs will keep ending the same way.

Hard Truth Five: The Maple Leafs’ Fan Base Is Fractured

This might be the toughest one to swallow. Maple Leafs fans are some of the most passionate in the game, but this latest exit has split the room. Some are still holding onto hope, blaming injuries or bad breaks. Others are done—calling for trades, firings, maybe even a complete reset. Some seem cynical enough to believe the team won’t win anyway, so why not lose with a vortex of villains?

That emotional tug-of-war is real. You can feel it reading the online commentary, but it can’t be any better in the bars or the arena for fans on their way home. It’s not just frustration anymore—it’s fatigue. And it’s hard to know what the fan base will look like if this keeps happening.

So, What Now for the Maple Leafs?

The Maple Leafs have some serious decisions to make. Running it back clearly isn’t working. Whether rethinking the core, adding some serious sandpaper, or finding a new voice, the fans believe it’s time for a change.

Because, unlike a decade ago, Maple Leafs fans aren’t just asking for playoff appearances anymore. They want something that wins at any cost. They don’t even care if it doesn’t last. Like their sister, the Toronto Raptors, one championship and years of struggle will do nicely. Just once, they want something that doesn’t end with another gut-punch Game 7.

As the offseason approaches, they wait to see if the organization finally gets the message.