Found September 18, 2013 on Fox Sports Arizona:
Los-angeles-kings-rookies
Brendan Shanahan has a difficult job. The National Hockey League's director of player safety reviews hundreds of incidents each season with his staff. No matter how diligent, thorough and reasoned his group is in its assessments, his approval ratings will always hover somewhere just above Congress'. When he doesn't hand down discipline he is largely forgotten; when he does, players, coaches, managers and fans become enraged. That's what happens when you deal in gray areas and passionate arenas. If you think it's simple to mete out punishment or withhold it, remember how fast the game of hockey moves. Remember how tiny changes of body position, circumstance and timing can spell the difference between a legal hit and a punishable offense. It is our opinion that Shanahan got it wrong when he determined LA Kings forward Jordan Nolan's hit on Coyotes defenseman Rusty Klesla was a legal hit that warranted no further punishment. In reviewing the tape, however, there were things Nolan and Shanahan got right. Nolan kept his hands and stick down so that he did not lead with an elbow or something harder. He made sure to get in front of Klesla before the hit -- in Klesla's line of sight. And in contrast to Raffi Torres' infamous hit on Marian Hossa during the 2012 playoffs, Nolan was not late delivering the hit, nor did he leave his skates before the hit as replays show Torres' left skate doing. When Torres delivered that hit during the Coyotes-Blackhawks first-round playoff series, we called it a punishable offense and insisted that Torres deserved a suspension. Nolan doesn't have a suspension history like Torres and, as previously noted, there were fewer issues with his hit on Sunday. But in his explanation, Shanahan sees two things we don't see. He says Nolan didn't pick the head and he says "nor does he launch up or into the check." We disagree on both counts, and we were not swayed by the fact that Klesla left the ice on a stretcher with his head and neck immobilized, as some cynics suggest. Nor were we swayed by the Coyotes' assertion that it was an illegal hit. If you're looking for objectivity, locker rooms are not the places to find it. Teams (and fans) will always rally around their guy. Shanahan declined an interview request, but we've watched the play over and over again, in slow motion, in regular time, frame by frame. Nolan absolutely picked Klesla's head, and that it is the first point of contact. He also launched into the check as he delivers it. Note the increasing amount of air under his skate blades as he follows through the hit. Kings coach Darryl Sutter described it as a good hockey hit after the game ,and clearly Shanahan agreed. While we still believe that is was an illegal hit based on the NHL's current rules, let's go with Shanahan's line of thinking to ask the more important question. Should this be a legal hockey hit? You've probably heard the alarmists saying that such an attitude amounts to the "wussification" of the game -- that calls for the elimination of such plays are a slippery slope that will ruin the game and indicative of those who don't understand the sport. Let's just call that opinion what it is: Ignorance. Some are so hung up on tradition or outdated definitions of masculinity that they believe maintaining injurious acts of violence is a way to reaffirm those definitions. That is unenlightened thinking and doesn't warrant further discussion. Hockey is a physical game. Heavy hits are an exciting and integral part of the game. And there is no question that head injuries and concussions will continue to occur because of the speed of the game and the increasing size of its players. You can't protect everyone. But with all we know about head injuries -- and all we still don't know -- shouldn't we think twice about what constitutes a legal hit? Shouldn't we say that, any time the head is the first point of contact as well as the principle point (as Rule 48 now reads), the offense is punishable? Shouldn't we be so scared of the damage done by head injuries, both now and down the road, that we do everything humanly possible to remove them from the game? "Maybe we're getting to that stage," said NBC's NHL analyst, Ed Olczyk, who played 16 NHL seasons for six teams. "You're never going to take head contact out of the NHL completely, but maybe we're getting to the point where this is a hit you say can easily be avoided -- and were saying you could have avoided it because we know the game." Head injuries have received an enormous amount of attention in the NHL and NFL recently. Part of that comes from our increasing medical knowledge of their impact, part of it comes from increasingly pervasive media coverage, part of it stems from a few high-profile incidents like Sidney Crosby's lengthy battle with post concussion syndrome and the tragic cases of chronic traumatic encephalopathy endured by several former NFL players. Dr. Javier Cardenas is a neurologist and concussion expert at Barrow Neurological Institute. He also serves as an on-site consultant at Cardinals and Arizona State football games to give football teams an expert on the sidelines in the event of head injuries. Cardenas believes both the NFL and NHL are doing a commendable job with their concussion protocols, education and prevention. But Cardenas also believes there is room for growth because there is still so much we don't know about head injuries and concussions. "Point A is a concussion. Point B is CTE. What we dont know is everything in between," Cardenas said. "Is there a number of concussions at which CTE sets in? How many concussions are caused by genetic susceptibility or other factors? What about those injuries that don't have classic symptoms of concussions like headaches or dizziness? Do those still cause brain injury? We still need more information and more research to know." Like Olczyk, Cardenas does not believe head injuries can be removed from the NFL and NHL so long as contact is part of the games. However, he said, "We know that removing the head from the game is the safest thing to do." The implementation would create several problems. "I've been around long enough to know that you can do things accidentally on purpose really quickly down there," Olczyk said. "If you say no head hits, then you'll have situations where the size difference in guys comes into play, or you will have situations where guys are skating around with their heads down." Olczyk is right, and his points underscore just how difficult a job Shanahan's department has. Clearly it's good advice to teach players to keep their heads up, on a swivel, to avoid injuries. But a couple staples of the NHL's enforcement still mystify. First, Shanahan noted that Nolan hit "squarely through the body." So if that makes it legal, isn't that a memo to big hitters? You want to nail some guy in the head? Just make sure you get plenty of body and youre good. Also, isn't blaming the guy who got hit with his head down simply blaming the victim. Sure, he wasnt exhibiting proper stick-handling or skating technique, but that doesn't mean he deserves to be laid up in bed for weeks with a concussion. Implementation would be difficult, but that's a problem to be solved; not one that should paralyze action. "When considering changes for all sports, we need to think about the purpose of that athletic activity," Cardenas said. "In boxing, the goal is to cause a concussion. In hockey, its to put the puck in the net; in football, its to score touchdowns. "Hockey is going to have contact, and it's worth noting that some people think it's heresy to talk about eliminating fighting despite the evidence of its impact. "But professional leagues can learn a lot from each other, and in this case, maybe the NHL can look at how the NFL regulates hits to the head and follow suit. If a hit is legal now, there's no reason not to look at it and revise it if it's in the interest of player safety." "Again, let's really take a hard look at what is elemental to the game and what is not, and let that guide us." Follow Craig Morgan on Twitter
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES

LA Kings Willie Mitchell Ready to Play

After playing an important role in the LA Kings’ 2012 Stanley Cup run, defenseman Willie Mitchell hopes to bounce back from a season devastated by injury.  Mitchell, the 36 year old defenseman, is back with the team after missing last season because of knee problems.  His last game with the Kings was when they won the Stanley Cup in 2012. Kings defenseman Willie Mitchell took...

Darryl Sutter perfect guy to coach talented Kings

EL SEGUNDO, Calif. With a Stanley Cup title and two conference championship appearances since Darryl Sutter took over as coach in December of 2011, the Kings have earned their place among the NHL's elite. Once an afterthought, they're now 12-1 favorites to win their second Stanley Cup in three seasons and picked fourth by oddsmakers behind defending champion Chicago, Pittsburgh...

Adam Kirshenblatt: Thoughts on Nolan Hit, Mason Raymond, Hockey History, WC Predictions

Here are some thoughts over some of the major subjects that have gone through the wire over the last week. Nolan Hit The hit itself doesn’t concern me at all. Not only is hard hitting “part of the game”, it’s part of what makes hockey great. The only other sport with contact similar to hockey is in football. In that, when a big hit like Jordan Nolan’s...

Carter, Frattin lead LA Kings' 6-0 rout of Anaheim

Jeff Carter had two goals and an assist, Matt Frattin scored his first goal for Los Angeles, and the Kings beat the Anaheim Ducks 6-0 in a preseason game Tuesday night. Frattin and Drew Doughty each had a goal and two assists. Anze Kopitar and Scott Sabourin also scored as the Kings dominated a preseason Freeway Faceoff. Jonathan Quick got his first preseason action for the Kings...

Carter helps Kings rout Ducks

Jeff Carter had two goals and an assist, Matt Frattin scored his first goal for Los Angeles, and the Kings beat the Anaheim Ducks 6-0 in a preseason game Tuesday night. Frattin and Drew Doughty each had a goal and two assists. Anze Kopitar and Scott Sabourin also scored as the Kings dominated a preseason Freeway Faceoff. Jonathan Quick got his first preseason action for the Kings...

Bissonnette gets 10-game ban; Kings' Nolan gets none

In a ruling that is sure to make Coyotes fans' blood boil and stoke this already budding rivalry, Los Angeles Kings forward Jordan Nolan will face no supplemental discipline for his hit on Phoenix Coyotes defenseman Rusty Klesla, while Coyotes forward Paul Bissonnette has been suspended 10 games without pay for leaving the bench during an altercation on "an illegal line...

Paul Bissonnette Suspended 10 Regular-Season Games After Leaving Bench to Fight Jordan Nolan (Video)

The Phoenix Coyotes will be without their enforcer for the beginning of the regular season. The NHL suspended Paul Bissonnette for 10 regular-season games after the Coyotes left winger left the bench during an altercation during Sunday night’s preseason tilt against the Los Angeles Kings. Bissonnette was given a game misconduct during the first period when he came off the bench...

Matt Frattin working to catch on with LA Kings

(Eds: Updates with details, quotes. Will stand. With AP Photos.) By GREG BEACHAM AP Sports Writer Matt Frattin moved to Southern California this summer with a plan. Three weeks before the Los Angeles Kings opened training camp, he found a place close to the ocean in Hermosa Beach, but he wasn't looking for surf or sand. After an up-and-down hockey career filled with arrests...

Why There Was No Action Taken Against Jordan Nolan For His Hit On Klesla

No supplemental discipline for Jordan Nolan for bodycheck on Rostislav Klesla. Video: http://t.co/QESZ8YMqYK — NHL Player Safety (@NHLPlayerSafety) September 16, 2013

BizNasty to appeal suspension?

According to Sarah McLellan of AzCentral sports, the Coyotes' Paul Bisonette's agent has said he will be appealing the 10 game automatic suspension he received after leaving the bench to fight the Kings' Jordan Nolan:   #Coyotes Paul Bissonnette will be appealing his 10-game suspension, according to his agent, Mark Guy. — Sarah McLellan (@azc_mclellan...

Klesla recovering after taking hit

Phoenix Coyotes defenseman Rostislav Klesla is resting at home a day after being wheeled off the ice following a hit by Los Angeles Kings defenseman Jordan Nolan. Klesla was injured in the first period of Phoenix's opening preseason game Sunday night when Nolan knocked him off his skates. The hit triggered a series of fights among players on both teams and led to four 10-minute...

Biznasty To Stick To Twitter For Ten Games by   Steven Ellis

Phoenix Coyotes forward Paul Bissonnette has been suspended for 10 regular-season games for leaving the bench to start a fight. Bissonnette left the Coyotes bench following a hit by LA Kings forward Jordan Nolan that resulted in teammate Rostislav Klesla getting taken off the ice on a stretcher. He suffered a concussion on the play, however Nolan was not suspended on the play...
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.