Found April 24, 2012 on Blue Seat Blogs:

Goaltender interference is a nebulous topic that often generates heated debates and a forgivably vague understanding of the actual rule on the play.  It is forgivable that most fans don’t know exactly how to apply the rule, since the rule itself is written so vaguely.

NHL Rule 69 ,“Interference on the Goalkeeper” is explained mostly in the context of allowing or disallowing goals, with very little substance about the penalty context.  The closest thing to explanatory language is:

“In all cases in which an attacking player initiates intentional or deliberate contact with a goalkeeper, whether or not the goalkeeper is inside or outside the goal crease, and whether or not a goal is scored, the attacking player will receive a penalty (minor or major, as the Referee deems appropriate). In all cases where the infraction being imposed is to the attacking player for hindering the goalkeeper’s ability to move freely in his goal crease, the penalty to be assessed is for goalkeeper interference.”

Under this provision, it would seem to me that Chris Kreider’s penalty last night wasn’t technically a penalty.  He neither intentionally or deliberately initiated contact with Anderson, nor did he hinder Anderson’s ability to move freely in his crease; he accidentally bumped into him.  Now, I suppose you could make an argument that bumping into him is hindering Anderson’s ability to move around his crease freely.  That’s true, but I think we can agree that the drafting of the rule left something to be desired in the clarity department.

So far in this series, we have seen both teams try to get bodies and pucks to the net, which as resulted in some questionable contact with the goaltenders.  Three plays stuck out to me last night alone of examples where contact with the goaltender became an issue: Nick Foligno’s goaltender inference penalty, Chris Kreider’s goalie interference penalty and Chris Neil’s goal at the end of the game.  Let’s break ‘em down and see what we come up with.

Foligno’s penalty was a play in which the 24 year old Buffalo native was crashing the net aggressively.  He has been involved in plays like this consistently since the start of the series.  Girardi seemed to steer Foligno into Lundqvist while trying to tie him up, but ultimately, Foligno had to much momentum and toppled over Hank.  Personally, I think this was the right call.  He clearly intended to get as close to Lundqvist as he could and didn’t seem to have the room to stop even had Girardi not made contact.  Hank’s ability to move in the crease was completely impaired, and it seems like the requisite intent was there.  This was a protect the goalie call.

Chris Kreider’s penalty came in a completely different context.  He was aggressively forechecking a cross-corner play, cut a little too close through the crease and made incidental contact with Anderson.  The refs seemed a little sensitive to certain kinds of contact last night, and this is consistent with the calls that were being made.  As I discussed above, it barely meets the criteria for the penalty under the rules, but it seemed to mesh with normal player-to-player interference, so I can understand the inclusion.  It would be nice if the rules actually spelled it out though.

Neil’s goal is debatable if goalie interference is involved at all. Typically, when a puck is in the crease, the goalie interference rules go out the window.  On a scramble like that, goalie interference is almost never called.  The real issue here was whether Neil kicked the puck in (inconclusive, right…) The puck clearly sped up as Neil’s foot arrived in the area and Hank’s glove was pushing laterally across the crease.  The only object that was moving in the direction of the puck’s ultimate movement was Neil’s skate.  But back on topic.  Here is sample language from the disallow/allow section:

69.3 Contact Inside the Goal Crease - If an attacking player initiates contact with a goalkeeper, incidental or otherwise, while the goalkeeper is in his goal crease, and a goal is scored, the goal will be disallowed.

Neil clearly meets the definition of a goalie interference penalty under Rule 69.3.  He intentionally disrupted Lundqvist’s movement and impaired his ability to move around in his crease, but the rule is not applied.

As the playoffs go on and things get more physical, the goalie interference rule is going to become more prevalent.  It’s important to know that most of the application of the rule is at the complete discretion of the referee.  There are going to be plenty of calls we don’t agree with coming, but as strange as it sounds, there is almost no right answer.


Del Zotto to Be Suspended for Hit on Neil?

Last night late in the third period Michael Del Zotto caught Chris Neil with his head down behind the net......hope Del Zotto told Neil "that was for Boyle" after destroying him with that devastating hit....normally not a fan of a player getting injured, but I had a big ole smile on my face watching Neil lay there on the ice after being dropped like a sack of potatoes.And...

Video: Chris Kreider & Ryan McDonagh Talk After Game 6 Win

… Chris Kreider played a phenomenal game for a rookie in just his 4th game on the NHL surface. The role Kreider played in the 2nd and 3rd periods were huge for the New York Rangers. This kid really is the future of the organization.  Ryan McDonagh also played a lot better tonight and came [...]

Report: Chris Neil Won't Be Disciplined for Big Hit on Brian Boyle Despite John Tortorella's Displeasure (Video)

Brendan Shanahan has ruled with an iron fist this postseason, but it doesn't look like he'll be calling Chris Neil into his office any time soon. Neil delivered a crushing blow on Brian Boyle of the Rangers during Game 5 of the New York-Ottawa series on Saturday, which led to Boyle suffering a concussion. Multiple reports indicate that Neil will not have a hearing with Shanahan...

Kreider Not Easily Fazed

During his conference call yesterday, John Tortorella gave this comment on his impressions of Chris Kreider's performance up until this point (via Bergen Record)..."The thing that impressed me the most about him right now in just a couple of days being with him is forget what's on the ice, it's how he's handled the situation. I'm sure there's a letdown...

Chris Neil Not Suspended and Alfie Set to Return?

Much to the chagrin of the insufferable John Tortorella, Chris Neil will not face any supplementary discipline for his hit to New York Rangers forward Brian Boyle. In his post-game press conference last night, Torts drew parallels between Neil's hit and the Raffi Torres hit on Marian Hossa; even going so far as to say that Boyle had sustained a concussion and that the NHL has...

Video: Michael Del Zotto Drills Chris Neil

… LOVE IT! LOVE IT! LOVE IT!  Hate Chris Neil with a passion, guy is a punk. 

Derek Stepan hits Chris Neil

This was from yesterday's Rangers and Senators game. Very nice check by the former Wisconsin Badger and Rangers forward Derek Stepan on the Senators forward and tough guy Chris Neil. It's a text book body check. Related articles Chris Neil will not meet the Shanahammer Anderson Blanks Rangers, Ottawa Takes Series Lead Kyle Turris helps Sens tie series...

Prust Alters Series With Bout Against Neil

Games 2 through 5 we watched as Chris Neil dominated the Rangers physically without a care in the world as John Tortorella inexplicably stapled Michael Rupp and Stu Bickel to the bench.Well Brandon Prust finally had enough and could have changed the course of the series by doing this with the Rangers down 1-0 in the first period... ...i don't care that Prust lost...

Rangers Play Their Game to Extend Series to 7

When the New York Rangers play within themselves and play their style of hockey, they are an extremely tough team to beat. The Blueshirts proved that tonight by beating the Ottawa Senators by a score of 3-2 in Game 6 to tie the series up at three apiece. The two teams will have two days off before meeting on Thursday night at Madison Square Garden for a Game 7. The Rangers played...

Replacing Boyle in the lineup

When Chris Neil took out Brian Boyle with a questionable hit on Saturday night, he took out the Rangers most effective forward. He took out their leading scorer, top defensive forward, and top penalty killer in this series. He took out the only player that has managed to get under the skin of the Senators. It’s a big blow to the Rangers, and not a player easily replaced. The best...

Morning Skate Notes: Cally In; Boyle Out; Kreider Not Intimidated; Konopka Out?

Pat Leonard at the Daily News reports that Ryan Callahan (finger) participated in this morning's skate, however, Brian Boyle (concussion) did not.Arthur Staple at Newsday says Boyle was seen riding a stationary bike this morning, but is not close to returning....figured Callahan would be ready to go. Don't like hearing that Boyle isn't even close to returning. Hopefully...

Goaltender Interference Should Have Negated Spezza Goal

In his weekly article at TSN, former referee Kerry Fraser weighs in on the controversial Jason Spezza goal from Monday night in which the NHL review booth confirmed that Chris Neil did not kick the puck in..."Henrik Lundqvist and Chris Neil both knew that the Rangers goalie was pushed off the puck by Neil's stick. The entire hockey world watching on television saw that Lundqvist...

Henrik Lundqvist on controversial goal: “Someone wanted the Senators back in it”

Photo Credit: With under a minute left in Game 6 of the New York Rangers- Ottawa Senators playoff series, Senators’ forward Chris Neil scored a goal, making it 3-2 Rangers while bringing the Senators within one goal. However, after a few replays, it apparently seemed as though Neil had illegally kicked the puck into a net, an illegal play which would have nullified...

Shortening the bench

The Rangers play their biggest game of the season and perhaps biggest game since the lockout on Thursday night. A win over the Senators and progress to the next round could be the springboard to a successful post season. Or Friday morning could be the start of golf season. With that said, should John Tortorella shorten his bench in the series finale? Given his tendencies to do so...
NHL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.