The New York Rangers enter the 2025–26 season with both hope and hesitation after a year that saw them tumble out of playoff contention just one season removed from capturing the Presidents’ Trophy.
Following the late-season collapse and the failure to crack the postseason field, New York fired coach Peter Laviolette and hired two-time Stanley Cup-winning head coach Mike Sullivan.
In a Metropolitan Division roundtable, The Athletic's Vince Mercogliano outlined the reasons to be optimistic about the Rangers' season, starting with the belief that last year represented the bottom of their downturn.
“It can’t get worse, can it?” Mercogliano wrote. “Seemingly everything that could have gone wrong for the Rangers last season did.”
My @TheAthleticNHL teammates and I joined forces to preview the Metro Division and size up reasons for optimism and concern with all 8 teams. (I naturally handled #NYR.) We also took a poll for predicted standings…
— Vince Z. Mercogliano (@vzmercogliano) September 23, 2025
Check out the full preview here https://t.co/cOEDXg0fgS
Added Mercogliano: “They believe a full season with new captain J.T. Miller, the addition of [Vladislav] Gavrikov to stabilize the defense and bounce-back performances from a core that’s only a year removed from winning a Presidents’ Trophy will propel them back into playoff contention.”
The analyst also pointed to the arrival of Sullivan, a hire long coveted by team president and general manager Chris Drury, as another factor working in New York’s favor.
But Mercogliano was equally clear about the warning signs, pointing them out after highlighting Adam Fox's bounce-back season as a key for the Rangers to make a push into the playoffs.
“On second thought, maybe it can get worse,” Mercogliano said, highlighting the reliance on aging veterans Artemi Panarin, Vincent Trocheck, J.T. Miller and Mika Zibanejad. “Team defense is of particular concern. (Goalie Igor) Shesterkin has masked their deficiencies for years, but the walls came crumbling down around him last season.”
Still, Mercogliano offered one bold prediction for the year, and it centered on Fox, the Rangers’ 27-year-old defenseman.
“Fox will establish a new career high in points and make the final Olympic roster for Team USA,” Mercogliano predicted. “The 27-year-old defenseman has been a focus of criticism, particularly in the aftermath of a subpar 4 Nations Face-Off showing. But as Sullivan put it, “It’s provided a lot of motivation for him to train as hard as he did.”
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!