Found April 07, 2012 on Blue Seat Blogs:
Philadelphia_flyers_v_e771

The race for the Vezina trophy may come down to three finalists, but this year it’s a two horse race between Henrik Lundqvist and Jonathan Quick. To be fair, both are very deserving of the award. They have had tremendous years, and are clearly the two best goalies this year. While we have been spoiled by having the best goalie in the world in net, the Kings would not be anywhere even close to the playoffs without Quick. Even looking at the stats, there’s no clear cut winner between the two of them:

Lundqvist: 39-17-5, 1.93 GAA, .931 SV%, 8 SO
Quick: 35-21-12, 1.93 GAA, .929 SV%, 10 SO

Before Quick gave up five goals to the Sharks, Quick’s numbers may have made him the front runner for the award. However, that five goal game gave Lundqvist the superior numbers heading into the season’s final game. The award is not just based on numbers though. Both goalies have a case for and case against that will be thought about by the GMs before a decision is made.

The case for Lundqvist

Lundqvist is the single most important player on the best team in the Eastern Conference, and possibly the NHL. The Rangers have had significant injuries to two of their top four defensemen, and have used a whopping 11 players on the blue line throughout the season. All that in a division that has four teams with 100 points, and four of the top six seeds in the Eastern Conference. If the division winners weren’t given the top three seeds, than the division would have four of the top five seeds. Against those opponents in the Atlantic, Lundqvist is 14-5-0 with a 1.84 GAA and a .936 SV%. Lundqvist is the best goalie in the league playing in the toughest division in the NHL.

The case against Lundqvist

Despite the injuries to the top four defense, the Rangers still boast one of the top defensive teams in the league. They are 2nd in blocked shots with 1,321 and 3rd in goals against (183, of course LA is ahead of them in goals against with 176). The Rangers are also the more balanced team who is in the upper half of the league in scoring (11th – 225). To put this in perspective, the Kings are 29th in blocked shots and goals for. Also, Lundqvist’s roughest month happens to be the most recent month, while Quick’s was much earlier in the season.

The case for Quick

Quick leads the league in shutouts, but that isn’t a determining factor since Lundqvist didn’t win last year despite leading the league in shutouts. Quick also doesn’t have the benefit of any offensive support. As mentioned above, Quick received just 192 goals, which is good for 29th in the league. Until he gave up five goals to the Sharks, he also had the better stats. Quick has played an equal role in getting his team to the playoffs, and had to deal with his coach getting fired halfway through the season.

The case against Quick

The Pacific Division is not as strong as the Atlantic. None of the five teams will crack 100 points, and none of them have a goal differential better than +17. Quick may have more shutouts, but he is only 9-8-1 against the same quality of opponents the Rangers have faced (the top five offensive teams in the conference).

There’s no “bad” choice for the Vezina this season. Ranger fans will be outraged if Quick wins, and Kings fans will be outraged if Lundqvist wins. At the risk of sounding like a homer, that five goal game put Lundqvist back on top for the voting. Quick is a fine goalie, but Lundqvist has been the better goalie in a much tougher division.

THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES

Lundqvist Wants To Be The Best

In a New York Times profile on the Rangers All Star goaltender, Henrik Lundqvist says this about his desire to succeed..."The first three years, it was a lot about proving to everybody else that I should be here, that I should play in this league. But now it's about proving to myself. I want to be good. I want to play better.Lundqvist then added this..."I'm going...

Morning Skate Notes: Biron, Rupp In; Lundqvist Handling Stick Fine

Steve Zipay at Newsday reports that Marty Biron will make the start in Pittsburgh tonight, while Mike Rupp, despite having a sore neck, will be back in the line-up which will remain the same....got to be honest, I'm shocked that Scott isn't subbing for someone tonight. Zipay also says that Henrik Lundqvist (right hand) was able to handle his stick fine during practice this...

Could Quick Steal Vezina from Lundqvist?

Greg Wyshynski at Puck Daddy tries to make a compelling argument for Jonathan Quick to win the Vezina Trophy over Henrik Lundqvist..."But if you see the Vezina as an award not only for the goalie "adjudged to be the best at this position" but also the goalie who was vital to his team's success, then Jonathan Quick beats Henrik Lundqvist for the award. He has better...

Postgame: Rangers Lose to Caps, Set to Face Senators in Quarterfinals

Tonight's 4-1 loss to the Washington Capitals wasn't necessarily the way in which the New York Rangers wanted to conclude their 2011-12 regular season campaign, but it's nothing the team should be discouraged over. Henrik Lundqvist made that clear by skating to center ice after handing his jersey to a fan and beginning to clap for the supportive fans that have been with...

LA Kings 2012 award winners

The Los Angeles Kings announced their award winners. AS VOTED BY THE MEDIA Most Valuable Player "Bill Libby Memorial Award" - Jonathan Quick Best Newcomer "Mark Bavis Memorial Award" - Jeff Carter Outstanding Defenseman - Willie Mitchell Defensive Player - Jonathan Quick AS VOTED BY THE KINGS PLAYERS Most Inspirational Player "Ace Bailey Memorial Award...

Sutter On Quick

from Rich Hammond of LA Kings Insider, Darryl Sutter might say simple things, but be assured that he’s not a simple man. Every coach has his own motivational tools, and every coach knows that what he says publicly has a good chance of making its way to his players’ eyes and ears. To that end, Sutter gave some interesting comments today, after initially being asked about Jonathan...

Rangers face great playoff expectations

Henrik Lundqvist's style -- both on and off the ice -- doesn't mesh with Mike Richter. Ryan Callahan lacks a Stanley Cup title, let alone the five Mark Messier had on his resume. John Tortorella is certainly as fiery as Mike Keenan, although the two don't look much alike. Comparisons have certainly been drawn between this year's New York Rangers and the 1994 team...

Stanley Cup Playoffs Round 1 Predictions: Vancouver Canucks vs. Los Angeles Kings

Welcome to Center Ice Chat’s Stanley Cup Playoffs Predictions feature. The pickings are up for debate, and the projects are meant to be taken lightly, and engage further discussions. Please feel free to join in on the conversation. The Vancouver Canucks will come into the first round of the 2012 Stanley Cup Playoffs with more stability than the Los Angeles Kings have...

Blues face San Jose Sharks in first round of Stanley Cup Playoffs

Candygram! The Blues've picked the safer bet between the Sharks and Los Angeles Kings, not that there was much picking involved. The Sharks're a tough team -- not like there're any creampuffs in the playoffs -- but their goaltending can be exploited. The Blues went 4-0 over them this year, as opposed to the 1-2-1 that they did over the Kings. No one in their right mind...

2012 Stanley Cup Playoffs First Round Eastern Conference Predictions

14 teams are out. 16 are still in chase for the ultimate prize, the silver mug, the most famous trophy in all of sports, the Stanley Cup. Who will it be this year that gets to raise it? Here are my first round Eastern Conference Predictions.[1] New York Rangers vs. [8] Ottawa SenatorsOutlook: After a great season during which they accumulated 109 points - just 3 less of their franchise...

Postgame: Rangers Fall to Pens, Tortorella Lashes Out Against Pittsburgh Organization

Before everyone loses their cool and begins to call the Rangers out for not being able to defeat the Pittsburgh Penguins, let’s realize two things; with a healthy Henrik Lundqvist, this game is much closer than 5-2. The Rangers’ effort was not half bad tonight, and they even outshot the Pens by a large margin in the third period. Secondly, the Rangers have already clinched the...

Most Improved Goalie This Season

Yesterday I wrote that I think Erik Karlsson of the Ottawa Senators is the most improved player this season.  Commenters quickly pointed out Brian Elliott of the St Louis Blues.  While Elliott has had a huge statistical improvement in his play this season, I do not see it as a huge sustained improvement.  I wouldn’t list him among the elite goalies in the NHL.  There are several...

Treehouse Of Season Enders Part 1: The Studs!

Thanks to Ian Gooding, we get the season enders off to a firecracker start.  Here we go..... =============================================== Fantasy All-Star TeamWere any of these players on your fantasy team? You were probably more successful this season if so.Henrik Lundqvist, G, NYRBased on all four traditional categories (GAA, SV%, W, SO), Lundqvist is the top fantasy goalie...

Capitals 4, Rangers 1

The New York Rangers (51-24-7) lost to the Washington Capitals (42-32-8) by the score of 4-1, tonight. For a box score and recap go to Yahoo! Sports....guess the Rangers didn't want to play the Capitals in the first round. And I don't blame them. Washington seems to be peaking at the right time....to be honest, I'm not worried. When...

Game Preview: Rangers/Capitals

Standings: Capitals (41-32-8), Rangers (51-23-7) NYR Leading Scorer: Marian Gaborik (41-35-76) WSH Leading Scorer: Alexander Ovechkin (37-27-64) NYR Goaltender: Henrik lundqvist (61 GS, 1.93 GAA, .931 SV%) WSH Goaltender:  Braden Holtby (6 GS, 2.79 GAA, .910 SV%) Rangers Lines (probable): Carl Hagelin-Brad Richards-Marian Gaborik Brandon Dubinsky-Brian Boyle-Ryan Callahan Artem...
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.