Nostalgia vs. Practicality—Are Wood-Burning Stoves Really Worth It?

What's the difference between a wood-burning stove vs. a wood-burning fireplace?

Wood-burning stoves are freestanding units located in the center of a room or against a wall. They have a closed combustion chamber with a door and a fireplace damper, allowing for controlled airflow and efficient heat distribution. Wood-burning fireplaces are built into a wall or structure, featuring an open hearth where wood is burned directly.

As beautiful as a masonry fireplace can be, they tend to lose heat through the chimney and since they take time to get going, they are great for creating a cozy space but aren't the most efficient for heating your whole living space. Wood-burning stoves, have an enclosed design, better control of combustion, and reduced heat loss, making them a popular choice for homeowners seeking energy-efficient and reliable heating solutions.

Can you convert a gas fireplace back to wood burning?

Some gas fireplaces were never meant to burn wood. But assuming that yours had been modified to have a gas insert, converting it back to wood-burning is possible. First, a professional needs to do a thorough inspection to ensure the fireplace structure can accommodate burning wood safely. Alterations or renovations to the chimney or flue liner may be necessary to handle the different exhaust gases and higher temperatures produced by wood fires. Additionally, building codes and fire safety regulations will need to be met. This may require modifications to the firebox, hearth, and ventilation design to suit updated EPA-certified wood Stove regulations. Overall, while feasible, this conversion process demands careful planning and expertise.

How to decide between wood-burning, gas, or electric?

There is so much variation in heating efficiency and heating costs between types of fireplaces that it's tough to compare between these broad categories. Beyond your wants and dreams, it comes down to practicality.

• Wood fireplaces or pellet stoves require the ability to stack, carry, and store seasoned wood. They also create smoke and ash. Then again, they do offer a unique ambiance and sense of self-sufficiency, especially on cold winter nights.
• Gas fireplaces require access to a gas line and a source for fuel delivery. But they are as easy to operate as flipping a switch and new models have high-efficiency ratings.
• Electric fireplaces are best for a small space and they require a stable power source. Though, they are great for apartments, only need a power outlet, and can come with fun lights and artificial crackling sounds.