Yardbarker
Yardbarker
x
Every MLB playoff contender's biggest weakness
Adam Hunger-USA TODAY Sports

Every MLB playoff contender's biggest weakness

All of the MLB playoff contenders have immense talent, but none is perfect. As we head down the stretch in the 2019 MLB season, these weaknesses stick out for each playoff contender.

 
1 of 17

Arizona Diamondbacks: pitching

Arizona Diamondbacks: pitching
Darren Yamashita / USA Today Sports Images

Arizona probably got worse at the trade deadline when it traded ace Zack Greinke, but the team did add two formidable starters in Zac Gallen and Mike Leake. Still, the staff has been an issue since the Diamondbacks lost Luke Weaver, who still doesn't have a clear return date. The bullpen has also become an issue lately with Greg Holland getting demoted from the closer role and the pen sporting a 4.53 ERA overall.

 
2 of 17

Atlanta Braves: starting pitching depth

Atlanta Braves: starting pitching depth
Tommy Gilligan / USA Today Sports Images

Mike Soroka has been a true ace for Atlanta this season, and Dallas Keuchel has fared well despite signing in June. After that pair of groundball pitchers, the rotation has been inconsistent. Max Fried has an ERA above 4.00, and Julio Teheran's ERA metrics show that his 3.46 ERA could be a ticking time bomb. The hope is that last year's ace, Mike Foltynewicz, is able to rebound after returning from the minors recently.

 
3 of 17

Boston Red Sox: starting pitching

Boston Red Sox: starting pitching
Bob DeChiara / USA Today Sports Images

Boston has two former Cy Young winners and Chris Sale on its staff, so starting pitching didn't look like an issue coming into the year. Unfortunately, the Red Sox starters rank 20th with a 5.07 ERA, and Rick Porcello (5.74 ERA) and Sale (4.68 ERA) have been particularly disappointing. A recent eight-game losing streak could have effectively ended Boston's playoff chances, and its starting pitching has been the biggest issue.

 
4 of 17

Chicago Cubs: hitting vs. left-handed pitchers

Chicago Cubs: hitting vs. left-handed pitchers
Quinn Harris / USA Today Sports Images

It's no mystery that the Cubs lineup has struggled against southpaws this season, ranking 20th with a .740 OPS. They remedied the issue at the trade deadline by acquiring Nicholas Castellanos, and the eventual return of Ben Zobrist could also help. Still, a potential playoff matchup vs. the Dodgers left-handed-heavy starting rotation could be a nightmare.

 
5 of 17

Cleveland Indians: hitting depth

Cleveland Indians: hitting depth
Rick Osentoski / USA Today Sports Images

Cleveland fixed a lot of its hitting issues by acquiring Yasiel Puig and Franmil Reyes at the trade deadline, and Jose Ramirez's surge since the All-Star break has also helped. However, the bottom of the lineup still has its share of issues, with Jason Kipnis' .724 OPS and Robert Perez coming back to earth since the break. Those are potential easy outs that AL teams like the Yankees, Astros, and Twins don't have when they're healthy.

 
6 of 17

Houston Astros: pitching reinforcements

Houston Astros: pitching reinforcements
Troy Taormina / USA Today Sports Images

Houston made the surprise move of the deadline when it acquired Zack Greinke, giving the team a fearsome trio of starters that also includes Justin Verlander and Gerrit Cole. Before that point, the Astros had major issues at the back end of their rotation, and that could be an issue again if something happens to the big three or No. 4 starter, Wade Miley.

 
7 of 17

Los Angeles Dodgers: bullpen

Los Angeles Dodgers: bullpen
Gary A. Vasquez / USA Today Sports Images

While the Dodgers bullpen has a respectable 4.04 ERA, ranked eighth in MLB, Kenley Jansen hasn't been his usual dominant self, and free agent signing Joe Kelly has been a major disappointment. L.A. didn't make any major moves at the trade deadline but seems likely to shift Kenta Maeda to the pen for the third straight year. He should be able to help, but Jansen showing consistency will be critical.

 
8 of 17

Milwaukee Brewers: pitching

Milwaukee Brewers: pitching
Michael McLoone / USA Today Sports Images

It's been a rough few weeks for the Brewers, losing Brandon Woodruff, Jhoulys Chacin, Gio Gonzalez and Zach Davies to injuries. The result has been a pitching staff in shambles. While the Brewers expect all of their pitchers to be healthy before the playoffs, it could be too little, too late for their postseason hopes.

 
9 of 17

Minnesota Twins: bullpen depth

Minnesota Twins: bullpen depth
Steve Mitchell / USA Today Sports Images

Minnesota acquired Sam Dyson at the trade deadline, only for the right-hander to struggle and go on the IL with a shoulder issue. Taylor Rogers has been spectacular as the closer lately, and Sergio Romo has also helped, but much of the heroics at the bottom of the bullpen have been smoke and mirrors. The Twins rank 14th in bullpen ERA (4.43), as some of their relievers have regressed recently.

 
10 of 17

New York Mets: bullpen

New York Mets: bullpen
Charles LeClaire / USA Today Sports Images

The Mets apparently felt they had a viable shot at the NL wild card, acquiring Marcus Stroman at the deadline and keeping Noah Syndergaard and Zack Wheeler. They now have one of baseball's most talented starting rotations, but the bullpen is still a huge issue. The team's 5.17 ERA in the pen ranks third-worst, and closer Edwin Diaz has been shaky, to say the least.

 
11 of 17

New York Yankees: starting pitching

New York Yankees: starting pitching
Brian Fluharty / USA Today Sports Images

The Yankees have done a remarkable job surviving major injuries this season, but their starting rotation remains a major concern for the playoffs. Luis Severino's status is still up in the air, and the rotation ranks 17th in baseball with a 4.73 ERA. While Domingo German has been a savior for the team, New York needs a better final stretch from Masahiro Tanaka, James Paxton and J.A. Happ as the team gets ready for the playoffs.

 
12 of 17

Oakland Athletics: depth

Oakland Athletics: depth
Jesse Johnson / USA Today Sports Images

Oakland continues to withstand some big blows, led by breakout pitcher Frankie Montas' 80-game PEDs suspension. While the club is in a good position in the AL wild card race, as a small market team it doesn't have the depth of some of the other AL playoff teams like Houston and the Yankees. An injury to center fielder Ramon Laureano has already exposed the team's outfield depth, and A's fans should similarly have their fingers crossed that Matt Chapman, Matt Olson and Marcus Semien are able to go down the stretch unscathed.

 
13 of 17

Philadelphia Phillies: pitching

Philadelphia Phillies: pitching
Bill Streicher / USA Today Sports Images

Philadelphia's starting rotation looked thin entering the year, and it's become a much bigger issue as the season has progressed. While Aaron Nola has pitched well, Jake Arrieta is battling through an elbow injury and the rest of the rotation has been under almost constant change. The result is a 4.50 ERA overall, just 15th in MLB. The bullpen has also become a surprise problem due to numerous injuries, including to Seranthony Dominguez, David Robertson and Pat Neshek.

 
14 of 17

San Francisco: hitting

San Francisco: hitting
Ron Chenoy / USA Today Sports Images

The Giants got back into the NL wild-card hunt with a great July, as they continue to search for hitting. The team's .704 OPS ranks fourth-worst in MLB, but there is reason to be optimistic with recent surges from Buster Posey and Mike Yastrzemski. The team also acquired Scooter Gennett at the trade deadline, but the recent injury to breakout outfielder Alex Dickerson was a huge setback.

 
15 of 17

St. Louis Cardinals: thin lineup

St. Louis Cardinals: thin lineup
Billy Hurst / USA Today Sports Images

The Cardinals lineup has finally started to deliver on its promise due in large part to Paul Goldschmidt's hot streak. The return of Marcell Ozuna gives the team two elite hitters, but there are major issues behind them. St. Louis lacks another hitter with an .800 OPS, and the team particularly had issues at third base and center field. While the Cardinals have talent, their hitting performance hasn't stacked up with the elite NL teams.

 
16 of 17

Tampa Bay Rays: pitching depth

Tampa Bay Rays: pitching depth
Noah K. Murray / USA Today Sports Images

The Rays pitching has been outstanding this season, but the depth has been tested. Tyler Glasnow suffered an arm injury earlier in the year, and more recently Blake Snell, Jose Alvarado and Yonny Chirinos went down with injuries. An area that has been a strength this year has started to become an issue more recently.

 
17 of 17

Washington Nationals: bullpen

Washington Nationals: bullpen
Bill Streicher / USA Today Sports Images

Washington has the worst bullpen ERA in baseball. The Nationals added three relievers at the deadline and signed Fernando Rodney earlier this season, but it still might not be enough to fix the severe issues bridging innings between their outstanding starters and closer Sean Doolittle.

Seth Trachtman

Seth Trachtman is a sportswriter, digital marketer, and fantasy sports expert based in St. Louis, Missouri. He’s a two-time winner of the Tout Wars Fantasy Baseball Expert’s League, and his work has appeared in hundreds of fantasy baseball and fantasy football newsstand and online publications

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

TODAY'S BEST

Three offseason trade targets for Blue Jays to add an impact bat
MLB

Three offseason trade targets for Blue Jays to add an impact bat

The Toronto Blue Jays and their fans are fresh off the most heartbreaking loss in franchise history. Putting the defending champion Los Angeles Dodgers on the brink of elimination with two cracks to win the World Series at home, only to lose two nail-biters that each came down to the final out. It’s going to take a long time to get over it, if that’s even possible to do. However, they'll have to turn the page rather quickly because in just three days, the negotiating window for free agents expires, and all are free to sign wherever they so choose. Toronto will be busy in an attempt to retain the likes of star shortstop Bo Bichette and starting pitchers Shane Bieber, Chris Bassitt and Max Scherzer. At the same time, the front office must be active in improving its roster from the outside, whether that’s via free agency or trade. While there are some intriguing names for the Blue Jays to target on the open market, given their needs, heading down the trade route could make the most sense. Here are three ideal trade targets for the Toronto Blue Jays to add an impactful left-handed bat to their lineup for 2025-26 and beyond: Oneil Cruz | Pittsburgh Pirates Cruz’s name popped up in trade rumors ahead of the deadline in August, and it’s fair to wonder if he still could be available if Pittsburgh gets the right offer. The 27-year-old has all of the tools to be one of the best hitters in baseball, standing at 6-foot-7, 240 pounds with extreme power and bat speed. His numbers last season (20 HRs, 61 RBI), while solid, didn't reflect his talent, but it's understandable given the lack of protection around him on the Pirates. In Toronto, Cruz could slot in behind Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bichette, immediately becoming the most dangerous left-handed hitter in a right-heavy lineup. Matt Wallner | Minnesota Twins The 39th overall pick back in 2019 may not publicly be on the trade block, but after its sell-off at the deadline, it doesn’t feel like anyone is untouchable in Minnesota. Like Cruz, Wallner, at 6-foot-4 and 220 pounds, has big-time power, and the Blue Jays saw that firsthand when he crushed three HRs and six RBI during their three-game series in Toronto in late August. He does have some swing and miss in his bat (.231 career average), but with how often the top of the Blue Jays lineup gets on base, all it takes is one swing for Wallner to put up a crooked number on the scoreboard. Jarren Duran | Boston Red Sox The 2024 All-Star Game MVP has been in constant trade discussions for over a year now, and it feels inevitable that he gets dealt out of Boston this winter. Duran had more of an up-and-down 2025 campaign, though he's displayed the ability to drive in runs (84 RBI) and has power with even more untapped potential. Combine that with his speed and athleticism, and you can see why so many teams would love to acquire him. Trading within the division is never easy, but the 29-year-old would be a perfect fit in the middle of Toronto's lineup, so it's something they should absolutely look into.

Dolphins' Mike McDaniel Reveals Tua Tagovailoa Decision Before Bills Game
NFL

Dolphins' Mike McDaniel Reveals Tua Tagovailoa Decision Before Bills Game

Through nine weeks of the NFL season, the Miami Dolphins have been one of the worst teams in the league. Following the team's 28-6 Week 9 loss to the Baltimore Ravens on Thursday night, the Dolphins have fallen to 2-7 on the year, and have seemingly already laid the groundwork for a total rebuild. One day after the loss, the Dolphins announced that they had fired general manager Chris Grier. A change in power at the GM role indicates that no one on the roster is safe moving forward, as whoever is brought in will have ties or allegiances with the current regime. One person who many believed could be at risk of losing his job is quarterback Tua Tagovailoa. The Pro Bowl quarterback has been a shell of his former self this season, throwing for 1,779 yards with 15 touchdowns and 11 picks through nine games. For reference, Tagovailoa's previous career high in interceptions came in 2023, when he threw 14 in 17 games. Head coach Mike McDaniel benched Tagovailoa in the team's Oct. 19 loss to the Cleveland Browns after he threw three interceptions and lost a fumble, turning to rookie quarterback Quinn Ewers. While calls have been growing again for Tagovailoa to be sent to the bench once and for all, McDaniel confirmed that he's not entertaining that idea at this time. When speaking to the media on Monday ahead of the team's Week 10 game against the Buffalo Bills (6-2), McDaniels confirmed he is not anywhere close to making that decision at this time. "I am far from even going down that direction of would've, could've possible things," McDaniel said. "We have a football game against the Buffalo Bills that we are certain that Tua gives us the best chance to win and we have to approach our jobs with diligence. We have to execute and Tua knows that heavy is crown that of being a franchise quarterback." According to ESPN BET, the Bills have opened as 8.5-point favorites. While Miami looks to stay afloat on the season, the Bills are coming off of a monster win over Patrick Mahomes and the Kansas City Chiefs, as they look to make a Super Bowl run this season. As for the Dolphins, they haven't beaten the Bills since 2022, and are 1-9 against them in their last 10. Tagovailoa has been far from spectacular this season, but is clearly being given some grace by McDaniel. With that being said, the Dolphins have a bye in a couple of weeks, and it does cause one to wonder if that is when the Dolphins would end up benching the former Alabama star if things don't turn around.

Buffalo Bills receive devastating news on injured rookie CB
NFL

Buffalo Bills receive devastating news on injured rookie CB

Not the news Buffalo Bills fans wanted to hear. Head Coach Sean McDermott delivered a troubling update on Dorian Strong during a Tuesday afternoon press conference, pointing toward a long-term absence for the Bills’ rookie cornerback. The sixth-round pick has been dealing with a neck injury which led to his placement on Injured Reserve on Oct. 4, and entering Week 10, McDermott says that Strong has not received an encouraging update regarding his ailment. “I do have some more clarity, it’s not good in terms of the reports and everything,” said McDermott. “I don’t want to get into where it may go. It’s not moving in the direction we would like it to at this point. I’ll stop there just out of respect for Dorian.” Strong was selected by the Bills with the 177th overall pick in the sixth round of the 2025 NFL Draft and went on to earn the start in the first game of his NFL career in Week 1 against the Baltimore Ravens in place of injured veteran Tre’Davious White. Strong played in each of the Bills’ first four games of the season, but was injured before Buffalo’s Week 5 matchup against the New England Patriots and it now appears he has been lost for the year. The next question is, will this injury impact his career? Neck injuries are tricky and often dealt with conservatively. “He and I have had some conversations over the last few days and I wish the reports were better at this point,” added McDermott. Strong recorded 10 tackles during four games in his first professional season. — Sign up for OnSI’s Free Buffalo Bills Newsletter —

Canadiens Player Sends Clear Message After Senators Targeted Ivan Demidov
NHL

Canadiens Player Sends Clear Message After Senators Targeted Ivan Demidov

Montreal Canadiens defenseman Jayden Struble didn’t hesitate when Ottawa Senators forward Nick Cousins came back through Bell Centre on Saturday night. Weeks after Cousins’ preseason slash on Canadiens rookie Ivan Demidov, Struble delivered his own message during Montreal’s 4–3 overtime win. The Habs defenseman dropped the gloves with 18 minutes, 45 seconds left to play in the third period and the game tied at 2, settling a feud that lingered since training camp. “When you have a guy like that taking a shot at your star young player, that was a bad play,” Struble said. “None of us liked it. We were thinking about it. This is the first time we played him since. That’s on our minds. You can’t go around trying to hurt our best players.” Cousins spent most of the night trying to avoid both Struble and Montreal’s usual enforcer, Arber Xhekaj, before finally being caught after two full periods. The fight was brief but decisive, ending with Cousins bloodied and leaving the game. Struble, 24, said there was no personal vendetta, just a need to hold opponents accountable for their actions, even more in preseason exhibitions. Back in October, the NHL fined Cousins $2,148.44, the maximum allowable under the collective bargaining agreement. Cousins was only assessed a minor penalty for slashing during that preseason matchup. Struble made it clear on Saturday that Montreal won’t forget when a player crosses the line, saying, “We’ll protect our guys. That’s how it should be.” For the Canadiens, the moment carried meaning beyond retaliation. Demidov, the target of Cousins' slash in September, tied the game late in regulation before Alex Newhook sealed the win in overtime. The Canadiens and the Senators will meet three more times this season, the next matchup scheduled for Dec. 2 once again in Montreal.