This past offseason, the Kansas City Royals needed to address their leadoff woes.
Even though the Royals went 86-76 in 2024 and made the postseason, they got little production at the leadoff spot, which Maikel Garcia primarily manned. According to Fangraphs, Garcia and other Royals leadoff hitters ranked last in OBP (.270), wOBA (.265), and wRC+ (67) last season.
Thus, it’s not a surprise that Royals GM JJ Picollo addressed the issue by trading Brady Singer to Cincinnati for Jonathan India, who was the Reds’ primary leadoff hitter since 2021.
Unfortunately, the results haven’t been great for India at the top of the Royals’ batting order this season.
India is hitting just .237 with a .676 OPS with Kansas City this year. That included eight home runs, 53 runs scored, and zero stolen bases in 495 plate appearances. As a leadoff hitter, he is hitting .236 with a .658 OPS in 452 plate appearances.
Royals manager Matt Quatraro decided to move India out of the leadoff spot on August 6, opting to make newcomer Mike Yastrzemski the regular leadoff hitter against right-handed starters with Garcia going against lefties. India has moved down the batting order, primarily to the sixth or seventh spot.
The move has produced excellent results, with the Royals 8-3 since moving India out of the leadoff spot. Thus, let’s examine why the move has been effective for the Royals’ lineup and its positive impact on India.
Stats were taken prior to play on August 20.
The Royals acquired the 34-year-old outfielder at the trade deadline for Low-A pitching prospect Yunior Marte. Even though Yastrzemski is a pure rental (he will be a free agent after this year), he has made an immediate impact in Kansas City, especially at the leadoff spot.
Even though he’s only hitting .229 this month, he’s been thriving in nearly every other category. His wRC+ is at 151, and he also sports a .964 OPS and .396 ISO since joining the Royals. He’s also shown excellent plate discipline this month, walking as much as he’s striking out (15.3%).
Yastrzemski was known for his plate discipline while in the Giants organization, with a 0.55 BB/K ratio and 12.6% walk rate before being traded to Kansas City. However, his power with the Royals has been a pleasant surprise, especially considering Kauffman Stadium’s spacious dimensions.
Heading into play on Tuesday, as Kansas City’s leadoff hitter, he had three leadoff home runs, which tied the single-season record for leadoff home runs in a month by a Royals hitter, as pointed out by Royals Assistant Director of PR Ian Kraft. He wasn’t tied for long though, as Yastrzemski then hit his fourth on Tuesday evening.
Third leadoff home run by @mikeyaz18 THIS MONTH, already matching that @Royals record preciously held by Johnny Damon (Sept. 1998) and Alex Gordon (Aug. 2012).
— Ian Kraft (@Krafty_3) August 19, 2025
Damon (1998) and Gordon (2011) currently share the club record for leadoff HR in a single YEAR (5).#FountainsUp https://t.co/2hMIyeAF50
What’s impressive about Yastrzemski’s line with the Royals is that he’s producing excellent offensive value in 16 games despite a subpar BABIP, which is .167. Conversely, his average exit velocity with the Royals is 92.7 mph, his barrel rate is 17.1%, and his hard-hit rate is 51.2%.
Thus, it’s not surprising that the expected wOBA rolling chart is spiking in a positive direction, as illustrated in his chart via Baseball Savant.
Therefore, Yastrzemski’s performance at leadoff not only feels sustainable for the remainder of the season due to his plate discipline, but his batted-ball and hard-hit ability as well. He could see some positive regression in his batting average if those hard-hit balls start to find some holes and gaps in the coming weeks.
While India hasn’t quite lived up to expectations at leadoff in Kansas City, he’s found new life batting lower in the order since August 6.
In 41 plate appearances since moving out of the leadoff spot, India is hitting .250 with a .374 wOBA and 138 wRC+, according to Fangraphs. Additionally, he has three home runs, nine RBI, and an ISO of .278.
India has also hit his recent home runs in clutch situations, as evidenced by this 451-foot two-run shot against the White Sox on Sunday that tied the game:
The Royals' Jonathan India crushed a two-run homer and tied the game in the seventh inning. This was a 451-foot bomb. pic.twitter.com/zoGkEMrQEr
— Pete Grathoff (@pgrathoff) August 17, 2025
Since moving down in the order, he is striking out more, as his 24.4% strikeout rate is higher than his 17.4% K rate for the season. However, the Royals will be okay with the strikeouts if it means more power, especially at the sixth/seventh spot in the batting order.
A significant improvement for India is that his Ideal Attack Angle (IAA) percentage has improved dramatically since he changed spots in the batting order.
IAA is when the ball is hit with an attack angle between five and 20 degrees. IAA can lead to more barrels, and thus, more productive contact. India was going through a patch, especially after the All-Star Break, where he wasn’t getting to those optimum angles. That likely led to poor performance, despite his contact ability (19.5% whiff rate, which ranks in the 78th percentile).
However, he’s seen a positive spike in IAA percentage that has correlated with his move down in the batting order, which is a promising sign for his outlook this season.
In August, he is slugging .423, and his OPS is .762. Both are the best marks of any month he has had so far this year (excluding March, in which he only had 19 plate appearances).
The only downside with India this month is that his average is only .212. However, his wRC+ is 113, and his low average could be due to a .235 BABIP this month, the lowest mark of any month for him this season. His BB/K ratio of 0.40 is trending in the right direction as well when compared to previous months.
Thus, the move down in the order has not just helped India with his power, but arguably his plate approach as well.
Yaz strikes again! pic.twitter.com/k1SBXZue75
— Kansas City Royals (@Royals) August 20, 2025
With Yastrzemski getting another home run on Tuesday against the Rangers, there seems to be no reason for Quatraro to move India back to the leadoff spot anytime soon. Even against lefties, when Yastrzemski will likely sit, Garcia has handled leadoff duties much better this year, as evidenced by his .395 average and 166 wRC+ in 51 plate appearances at leadoff this year.
The Royals need to let India continue to get comfortable at this new spot in the batting order. If he does, he could give some nice pop and length to the batting order, which will not only improve the lineup down the stretch but also boost their playoff chances as well.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!