Rookie’s Splits Could Force a Tough Decision for the Yankees

Originally posted on Athlon Sports | By Kristie Ackert | Last updated May 2, 2025 11:46 AM ET

Jasson Dominguez has proven he can play at the big-league level. The New York Yankees’ one-time top prospect, however, has not yet proven he can play every day in the majors.

His ability to switch-hit has long been a cornerstone of his appeal, but early in the 2025 season, his right-handed struggles are becoming an issue.

Entering Friday night’s series opener against the Tampa Bay Rays, Dominguez was batting just .086 (3-for-35) against left-handed pitchers, with a .220 on-base percentage and a .171 slugging percentage over 41 plate appearances.

Yes, it’s a limited sample size, but those numbers highlight a concerning trend, especially for a Yankees lineup that has consistently struggled against left-handed pitching. If the issues persist, Dominguez could find himself platooning in left field, USA Today Network's Pete Caldera suggested.

Trent Grisham, meanwhile, has emerged as a formidable presence in the outfield. Batting .292 with eight home runs and a 1.009 OPS, Grisham’s consistent performance against both righties and lefties has solidified his role. His ability to deliver in clutch situations, paired with his defensive versatility, adds real value to the Yankees.

With Giancarlo Stanton’s return eventually on the horizon and Ben Rice growing into a reliable power bat, the Yankees are nearing a lineup logjam.

Manager Aaron Boone has acknowledged the challenge of finding enough playing time for everyone. For Dominguez, improving his performance from the right side is now essential.

No one’s suggesting he abandon switch-hitting, but the Yankees must reevaluate his approach against lefties. As the season moves on, Dominguez’s ability to adapt will be key to keeping his place in the Yankees’ outfield rotation.

This article first appeared on Athlon Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: