Yardbarker
x
Cleveland Browns face familiar crossroads after 1-5 start
Oct 5, 2025; Tottenham, United Kingdom; Cleveland Browns head coach Kevin Stefanski with owner Jimmy Haslam before an NFL International Series game between the Minnesota Vikings and the Cleveland Browns at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images Kirby Lee-Imagn Images

The Cleveland Browns have once again hit rock bottom. The Browns find themselves in their worst spot since the Hue Jackson era, when they infamously went 1-31 in two seasons, but ultimately acquired the talent that would drive the team to its only two playoff appearances in the past 20 years.

Interestingly, Jackson’s time as Browns head coach ended following a loss to the Steelers in Pittsburgh. That move to say goodbye to Jackson and offensive coordinator Todd Haley would be the moment that things began to turn around for the Browns.

It was at that point in the year, when the team started 2-5-1 and seemed as dysfunctional as ever, they chose to make the switch, naming then–defensive coordinator Gregg Williams, the interim head coach, and taking the handcuffs off rookie quarterback Baker Mayfield. They let him be himself and play free, bringing new juice to the Browns’ offense.

The team finished the season 5-3, playing some weaker competition, but the momentum from that season served as the foundation for their 2020 success.

There’s a chance for an eerily similar scenario to unfold in Cleveland this season if Jimmy Haslam loses his patience with head coach Kevin Stefanski and decides a mid-season move could be deemed necessary. If the Browns lose a game at home to the Miami Dolphins — who they are currently favored to beat — and then suffer another embarrassing loss to the Patriots in Foxborough heading into a bye week, this could become a reality.

The necessary keys for Cleveland to rediscover some of that mid-season magic from 2018 would involve promoting current defensive coordinator Jim Schwartz and making the move to fifth-round rookie quarterback Shedeur Sanders.

Cleveland desperately needs a spark — and fast. Sanders has the same level of confidence and infectiousness that Baker Mayfield displayed during his time in Cleveland, getting fans and teammates alike to believe in him.

No matter the team’s history or stigma, pairing that with making the heart and soul of the defense the head coach — allowing the team to embody the toughness Schwartz brings — could be the 180-degree shift this team needs to save everyone from letting go of the rope before we even hit the trade deadline.

After the bye week, the Browns face a host of winnable games, including the Jets, Raiders, Titans, and Ravens, who all have two wins or fewer on the year. If the change is going to come during the season, we could be closer to it than we think.


This article first appeared on Cleveland Browns on SI and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!