x

Could History Repeat Itself at Linebacker?

It seems like yesterday to me, but it was about this time 30 years ago that the Miami Dolphins had just finished their first preseason game against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.

The play shown as a highlight was linebacker Jack Del Rio making a huge tackle at the 1-yard line on 4th down to keep the Bucs out of the end zone. A couple of days later, I got a call from a friend after I had just gotten out of the pool to say VanHoover, the Dolphins just cut Jack Del Rio. I said no, they didn’t. He said yes, they did. I said Stop jerking me around.

He said, “VanHoover, turn on ESPN2 and look at the bottom line”; the internet was in its infancy, and that’s how you learned sports news back then.

So, I did, and sure enough the Dolphins cut Jack Del Rio, and I was stunned, and I didn’t see it coming, and I didn’t know why. 

It turns out that coach Jimmy Johnson saw a lot of potential in a rookie linebacker named Zach Thomas. The Dolphins were in rebuilding mode, and he didn’t want Del Rio taking snaps away from a rookie and his growth as a player. Well, Johnson was 100% correct, as Del Rio was at the end of his career, and Thomas went on to become a Hall of Fame linebacker. He went sideline to sideline making tackles, sacks, interceptions, and forced fumbles. 

Fast forward to the April 2026 NFL Draft. The Dolphins, heading into the offseason, have linebackers Jordyn Brooks and Tyrel Dotson under contract for one more year, and in the 2nd round of the draft, they select linebacker Jacob Rodriguez.

When the Dolphins made the pick, I thought, well, the team doesn’t need a linebacker, but with two guys in Brooks and Dotson under contract 1 more year, why not look down the road? Then I listened more to the draft coverage, and many people were surprised that Rodriguez was even available in the middle of the 2nd round, with some even saying that he was the best linebacker in college football.  

I also read more about him after they drafted him, and he is good sideline to sideline, makes tackles, forces fumbles, etc. He is also a good student of the game and watches film as well as calls out defensive signals. On top of that, he comes from a school at Texas Tech with a strong history of linebackers, including Thomas and Brooks. He can also be the green-dot player who calls out the defense. 

The Dolphins signed Brooks to a new contract just a few weeks ago, so that brings us to Dotson, who is a good player but has been around the NFL, first with the Buffalo Bills and then cut by the Seattle Seahawks during the 2024 season. That’s when the Dolphins picked him up, and he played well that season, so the Dolphins gave him a new 2-year contract. 

Dotson has played well as the defender that calls out the signals, but has he reached his ceiling? The Dolphins have already identified Brooks as a cornerstone player by giving him the extension, but not Dotson. Rodriguez has played as advertised in camp, and Dotson has done the same. New HC Jeff Hafley has said that he has a package to get Brooks, Dotson, and Rodriguez on the field at the same time, but will he do that? 

Hafley has said he likes competition and will play the best player. The linebacker position is full of competition and is clearly a strength for the Dolphins. My question for Hafley is: will he play the rookie with terrific upside over the veteran, who could stunt the rookie’s growth? 

Jimmy Johnson wasn’t afraid to play Thomas as a rookie because he believed in what he saw in him, which made Del Rio expendable. I’m not saying the Dolphins are going to cut Dotson before the season, but as we get into the preseason, it is something to watch.

Plus, GM John Eric Sullivan could possibly use Dotson as a trade asset to a team that may need linebacker help to get something in return because, in all likelihood, Dotson isn’t getting a contract past this year. 

I’m not trying to look ahead on this, but have what happened 30 years ago as a reminder that the Dolphins could go this route to help Rodriguez get his work in and go through the rigors of a long NFL season to help his growth, just like Johnson did with Thomas. 

This article first appeared on Dolphins Talk and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!