NFL Week 1 always creates overcorrections, but Week 2 usually tells us what's true and what's not about most teams. The Kansas City Chiefs, who lost to the Philadelphia Eagles on Sunday to fall to 0-2, better not hope that's the case.
Here are disappointing teams and players from Week 2 with a rating on our panic meter. (A "10" is hair-on-fire level of panic.)
Panic meter rating: 5.5/10
The Chiefs simply aren't good now. Through two games, Kansas City ranks 25th in the NFL in points per game (19), 28th in completion percentage (58.8 percent), 22nd in offensive success rate (42.9 percent) and last in defensive success rate (50 percent). Without WRs Rashee Rice (suspension) and Xavier Worthy (injured), this offense is a mess not even QB Patrick Mahomes can clean up.
Per Dan Treacy of The Sporting News, dating to 2020, 42 teams have started the year 0-2. Only five (11.9 percent) made the playoffs.
Panic meter rating: 6/10
After a heroic fourth quarter in his NFL debut, a 27-24 win over the Chicago Bears, McCarthy came back to Earth in Week 2. The 22-year-old completed just 11 of his 21 pass attempts for 158 yards, no touchdowns and two interceptions in a 22-6 loss to the Atlanta Falcons. Through two weeks, McCarthy ranks last among qualified quarterbacks in EPA per play (-0.354) and 31st in success rate (41.7 percent). He gets a slight pass because he welcomed his first child on Thursday, but McCarthy must show improvement soon.
Panic meter rating: 6.5/10
Lawrence and Thomas haven't been in sync to start the season. Through two games for the 1-1 Jaguars, Thomas has reeled in only five of his 19 targets for 60 yards and no touchdowns. To make matters worse, the Pro Bowl wide receiver has two drops (per Pro Football Focus) and head-scratching plays on tape.
here are all 7 incomplete passes in the direction of Brian Thomas Jr. in Week 2
— Josh Norris (@JoshNorris) September 15, 2025
a day to forget. alligator arms. a drop. and didn't win in traffic.
just 5 catches for 60 yards in two games pic.twitter.com/LYMHWnijMk
This isn't a new issue for Lawrence and Thomas, though. Thomas put up 1,282 receiving yards and 10 touchdowns as a rookie, but 675 yards and five touchdowns came from the last seven games, when Mac Jones was leading the offense with Lawrence out with a shoulder injury and a concussion. The Jaguars won't make a playoff push unless this duo gets on the same page.
Panic meter rating: 8/10
Defense was supposed to be Pittsburgh's strength, but this unit has played terribly through two games. In Week 1. the Steelers gave up 32 points and 394 yards to the New York Jets, who could barely get a first down against the Buffalo Bills, and 31 to the Seattle Seahawks. Pittsburgh ranks 29th in the NFL in yards allowed per play (6.3) and 27th in defensive success rate (47.2 percent).
This probably won't improve in the near future. The Steelers already have six defensive players on injured reserve, and linebacker Alex Highsmith and defensive lineman Isaiahh Loudermilk suffered ankle injuries in Week 2.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!