Yardbarker
x
Ranking the NFL backup quarterbacks for the 2017 season
Aug 10, 2017; Foxborough, MA, USA; New England Patriots quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo (10) prior to a game against the Jacksonville Jaguars at Gillette Stadium. Bob DeChiara-USA TODAY Sports

Ranking the NFL backup quarterbacks for the 2017 season

Depth in the NFL can make all the difference, and the backup quarterback spot is as important as any bench spot in the NFL. For many franchises, even thinking about playing the backup is a frightening proposition, while for others, they couldn't be more confident in the second on the depth chart at QB.

Where does your team fall? Here, we rank the best backup quarterbacks in the NFL from 32-1.

 

32. Bryce Petty, Jets

Bryce Petty, Jets
Noah K. Murray / USA Today Sports Images

Petty found the field as a starter four times in his sophomore season with the Jets last year, going 1-3. An extremely productive player in the Baylor offense, Petty threw seven picks in his first taste of regular-season NFL action. The fact the organization signed the 38-year-old Josh McCown instead of giving Petty an opportunity says a lot.

 

31. Cooper Rush, Cowboys

Cooper Rush, Cowboys
Tim Heitman / USA Today Sports Images

An undrafted free agent out of Central Michigan, Rush surprisingly won the backup job ahead of Kellen Moore. He was very efficient during the preseason, but there was a reason Rush went undrafted.

 

30. Drew Stanton, Cardinals

Drew Stanton, Cardinals
Joe Camporeale / USA Today Sports Images

Battling Blaine Gabbert for the No. 2 job in the preseason, Stanton has only shown that the Cardinals are in trouble if Carson Palmer gets injured. He's completed just 53 percent of his passes for his career with 14/19 TD/INT.

 

29. Scott Tolzien, Colts

Scott Tolzien, Colts
Charles LeClaire / USA Today Sports Images

Andrew Luck is unlikely to be ready in Week 1, and the Colts are in big trouble. Tolzien has started three games during his NFL career and has a horrendous 66.4 passer rating for his career. That explains why the Colts traded wide receiver Phillip Dorsett to the Patriots in exchange for quarterback Jacoby Brissett right before the start of the regular season.

 

28. Austin Davis, Seahawks

Austin Davis, Seahawks
Joe Nicholson / USA Today Sports Images

The Seahawks cut Trevone Boykin in favor of Davis, who has more NFL experience. He made 10 starts between the Rams and Browns in 2014-15 but has significant problems with picks. Seattle would be in trouble if something happened to Russell Wilson.

 

27. Nathan Peterman, Bills

Nathan Peterman, Bills
Mark Konezny / USA Today Sports Images

Considered a sleeper as a fifth-round pick this year, Peterman could get some starts this season if the Bills fall out of contention. In fact, he may get the start Week 1 with Tyrod Taylor in the NFL's concussion protocol heading into the opener. He completed only 54 percent of his passes during the preseason but didn't throw any picks.

 

26. Jake Rudock, Lions

Jake Rudock, Lions
Timothy T. Ludwig / USA Today Sports Images

Rudock got one year in the Jim Harbaugh offense at Michigan before going in the sixth round of last year's draft. He's coming off a very nice preseason, completing 66 percent of his passes with 3/1 TD/INT. While Rudock lacks a big arm, it looks like he might carve out a nice career as a backup.

 

25. Landry Jones, Steelers

Landry Jones, Steelers
Phillip G. Pavely / USA Today Sports Images

Jones is Ben Roethlisberger's primary backup for now, but it probably won't be long before rookie Joshua Dobbs jumps over him on the depth chart. Jones is .500 in four career starts, but the Pittsburgh offense has needed to adjust for him.

 

24. Sean Mannion, Rams

Sean Mannion, Rams
Kirby Lee / USA Today Sports Images

The Rams have too much invested in 2016 first overall draft choice Jared Goff to give Mannion an opportunity, but he has flashed ability during the preseason. The 2015 third-round pick completed more than 64 percent of his passes with two touchdowns this preseason.

 

23. C.J. Beathard, 49ers

C.J. Beathard, 49ers
Kyle Terada / USA Today Sports Images

A third-round pick out of Iowa, Beathard was able to beat out the experienced Matt Barkley for the No. 2 job. He could be the team's quarterback of the future and looked good in the preseason with 4/1 TD/INT.

 

22. Cardale Jones, Chargers

Cardale Jones, Chargers
Kyle Terada / USA Today Sports Images

Jones made a name for himself at Ohio State and was acquired before the season from Buffalo. The fourth-round pick in 2016 has a huge arm, but his accuracy has always been lacking. Given Philip Rivers's durability, the Chargers probably aren't concerned.

 

21. E.J. Manuel, Raiders

E.J. Manuel, Raiders
Kirby Lee / USA Today Sports Images

Manuel was an optimistic 16th overall pick in the 2013 draft by the Bills, but it didn't take the organization long to conclude he wasn't starter material. He has only 6.4 yards per attempt for his career and is 6-11 as a starter. If nothing else, Manuel does have wheels.

 

20. Paxton Lynch, Broncos

Paxton Lynch, Broncos
Kyle Terada / USA Today Sports Images

It's much too soon to call the 26th overall pick in the 2016 draft a bust, but the early returns for Denver haven't been good. Lynch struggled in his rookie season and looked overmatched during the preseason this year before getting injured. He could miss significant time, necessitating the Broncos to sign Brock Osweiler.

 

19. Ryan Mallett, Ravens

Ryan Mallett, Ravens
Chuck Cook / USA Today Sports Images

The strong-armed Mallett was infamously cut from the Texans in 2015 despite beginning the year as the starter. His leadership has often been questioned, and he's also extremely inaccurate, completing only 55 percent of his passes for his career.

 

18. Cody Kessler, Browns

Cody Kessler, Browns
Scott Galvin / USA Today Sports Images

A third-round pick by Cleveland last year, Kessler is the equivalent of a finesse pitcher. He went 0-8 as a starter as a rookie, albeit on a horrendous roster. Kessler did complete more than 65 percent of his passes, but he also threw only six touchdowns and didn't even figure into the starting conversation during training camp this year.

 

17. Brett Hundley, Packers

Brett Hundley, Packers
Jeff Hanisch / USA Today Sports Images

Stuck behind Aaron Rodgers, Hundley has thrown 10 regular-season passes over his first two seasons. He performed during the preseason this year, completing 63 percent of his passes with 3/1 TD/INT.

 

16. Geno Smith, Giants

Geno Smith, Giants
Brad Penner / USA Today Sports Images

A draft bust after going 39th overall in the 2013 draft, Smith infamously lost the quarterback battle for the Jets in 2015 when he he broke his jaw in a locker room fight. Completing less than 58 percent of his passes in four years, Smith now backs up Eli Manning with the Giants.

 

15. Chad Henne, Jaguars

Chad Henne, Jaguars
Reinhold Matay / USA Today Sports Images

The fact Henne couldn't beat out the struggling Blake Bortles despite getting the opportunity says a lot. A former starter in Miami and Jacksonville, Henne is 18-35 over his NFL career, completing less than 60 percent of his passes.

 

14. Matt Cassel, Titans

Matt Cassel, Titans
Dennis Schneidler / USA Today Sports Images

Cassel went 10-5 as the replacement for an injured Tom Brady back in 2008 with New England and became a starter under Todd Haley with the Chiefs, going 10-5 two years later. Since then he's been quite inconsistent, struggling with significant work in Dallas in 2015. Now 35, it's debatable if Cassel is even a reliable backup, though he has experienced and has won in the past.

 

13. Matt Schaub, Falcons

Matt Schaub, Falcons
Matt J. Rebilas / USA Today Sports Images

Still the best quarterback in Texans history, Schaub made two Pro Bowls during his tenure but was benched in 2013. He's seen only two starts since then but continued to struggle with interceptions when he did play. There are still few backups with his résumé, but Schaub is well past his prime at 36.

 

12. Case Keenum, Vikings

Case Keenum, Vikings
Kirby Lee / USA Today Sports Images

The starter in L.A. at the beginning of last season, Keenum failed to move a bland offense but did go 4-5 as a starter. However, he's completed only 58 percent of his passes for his career and struggled with his accuracy in the pocket.

 

11. Deshaun Watson, Texans

Deshaun Watson, Texans
Troy Taormina / USA Today Sports Images

Clemson's hero should emerge as Houston's starter sooner than later. He was taken 12th overall to finally fix the organization's years of quarterback issues, but he struggled during the preseason, completing only 51.8 percent of his passes with one pick and no touchdowns. Still, he can make plays and create offense with his feet.

 

10. Derek Anderson, Panthers

Derek Anderson, Panthers
Reinhold Matay / USA Today Sports Images

The last quarterback to lead Cleveland to a winning record over a season, Anderson has settled in nicely as Cam Newton's backup. He started two games last season, losing both, but completed more than 66 percent of his passes for the third straight year. Anderson's biggest weakness is his decision making, with as many touchdowns as interceptions for his career.

 

9. Colt McCoy, Redskins

Colt McCoy, Redskins
Brad Mills / USA Today Sports Images

A starter early in his career with Cleveland, McCoy has made a nice living recently as a backup. McCoy doesn't have great arm strength but can execute short throws. He completed more than 71 percent of his passes in his last year of extended playing time with Washington in 2014.

 

8. Nick Foles, Eagles

Nick Foles, Eagles
Bill Streicher / USA Today Sports Images

It's easy to forget that Foles was a Pro Bowler in the Chip Kelly offense in 2013, going 8-2 s a starter with 27/2 TD/INT for the year. He soon fell out of favor in Philadelphia, St. Louis and Kansas City. Foles's experience still makes him valuable behind Carson Wentz.

 

7. Chase Daniel, Saints

Chase Daniel, Saints
Derick E. Hingle / USA Today Sports Images

Daniel is on his third team in three years, but it's not for lack of ability. The Mizzou alumnus doesn't have much of an arm, but he's shown accuracy and scrambling ability when he's found the field during his career, completing more than 65 percent of his passes.

 

6. Ryan Fitzpatrick, Buccaneers

Ryan Fitzpatrick, Buccaneers
Kim Klement / USA Today Sports Images

Fitzpatrick had a huge season with the Jets in 2015, but his regression last season made the team look smart for not signing him long-term. The fact is that Fitzpatrick has turned over the ball far too often in his career with 133 picks in 3,876 career attempts. He's also just 46-69-1 as a starter for his career, though the experience and smarts he has are invaluable as a backup.

 

5. Mitchell Trubisky, Bears

Mitchell Trubisky, Bears
Mike Dinovo / USA Today Sports Images

Bears fans weren't crazy about the Trubisky pick when he was selected second overall, but now they're calling for him to be the starter ahead of Mike Glennon after a great preseason. Trubisky was 36-of-53 for 364 yards and three scores. It's only a matter of time before he's starting ahead of Glennon.

 

4. Patrick Mahomes, Chiefs

Patrick Mahomes, Chiefs
Kirby Lee / USA Today Sports Images

The 10th overall pick in the 2017 draft out of Texas Tech, Mahomes showed his raw talent and absolutely lit up defenses during the preseason. He finished 34-of-54 for 390 yards and 4/0 TD/INT with some highlight-reel throws. Of course, Mahomes also got away with some risky throws, which is why scouts said he needed a year on the bench. He's in the right situation under the tutelage of Andy Reid and could emerge as a star next season.

 

3. Matt Moore, Dolphins

Matt Moore, Dolphins
Brad Rempel / USA Today Sports Images

Moore performed well in Ryan Tannehill's stead late last season, though it wasn't enough to prevent the Dolphins from signing Jay Cutler when Tannehill went down again during training camp. For his career, Moore is a very respectable 15-13 as a starter with more than 6,000 yards passing. He's the type of passer a team can trust as the No. 2.

 

2. A.J. McCarron, Bengals

A.J. McCarron, Bengals
Brad Mills / USA Today Sports Images

Cincinnati discovered that McCarron could play late in 2015 when Andy Dalton got injured. He made three regular-season starts and threw for 854 yards and 6/2 TD/INT over seven total games. He also would have led the team to a playoff victory if not for some boneheaded defensive fouls by the Bengals.

 

1. Jimmy Garoppolo, Patriots

Jimmy Garoppolo, Patriots
Troy Taormina / USA Today Sports Images

A former second-round pick, Garoppolo played well in two starts for the Patriots last season when Tom Brady was suspended. For the season, he was for 43-of-63 for 502 yards, four touchdowns and no picks. He's completed an impressive 67 percent of his passes for his career and is the heir apparent to Brady.

Seth Trachtman is a fantasy sports expert and diehard Kansas City Chiefs fan. He doesn't often Tweet, but when he does, you can find him on Twitter @sethroto.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

+

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.