
Replay review in sports is supposed to fix things. It is not supposed to make things more difficult or even embarrass the league. But the NHL's attempt to legislate goaltender interference is proving to be a major problem for the league, and everybody is getting tired of it.
The biggest problem teams are having when they challenge plays for goalie interference is that there seems to be no consistency or standard for what the league is looking at when it makes the replay decision.
Pittsburgh Penguins general manager Kyle Dubas spoke about the issues extensively on Friday.
On Thursday, the Penguins were unsuccessful when they challenged a Buffalo Sabres goal for goalie interference after Josh Doan made contact with goalie Arturs Silovs in the crease. The play was upheld, the Penguins lost the challenge, and were then given the two-minute penalty that comes for a failed challenge.
Dubas cited that play, and a nearly identical play involving the Columbus Blue Jackets on the same night that was overturned.
He also went into detail about similar plays involving Penguins forward Anthony Mantha that took away a goal, and one involving the Nashville Predators that was allowed to stand.
Here is Dubas' full answer and explanation of the plays in question.
Kyle Dubas spoke for 4+ minutes about his frustration with goaltender interference rulings ️
— SportsNet Pittsburgh (@SNPittsburgh) March 6, 2026
On last night: "I thought for sure that was going to be no goal... I think it's the accumulation, and the not knowing makes it really difficult." pic.twitter.com/RGmedDpGWx
While that might seem like sour grapes from a general manager whose team has been on the wrong side of those calls in recent games, he is far from the only coach, executive or player who has sounded off on the subject.
The other factor here is that NHL teams are far less successful with goalie interference challenges than they have been in recent years.
During the 2024-25 season, teams were successful on more than 56% of their interference challenges. This season, they are only successful on 34% of their challenges. That is a stunning difference, and it is really hard to make the argument that coaches suddenly forgot what they were doing or started making random, bad decisions. Something is different, and it is annoying everybody. It is also a really bad look for the league to have so many important goals decided with no clear process.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!