Penguins aiming to reduce Kris Letang’s minutes

The Penguins’ retool is in full swing. While the up-and-coming forward group benefits from having a still-effective Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Bryan Rust, and Rickard Rakell to build and develop around, the same can’t be said for the defense corps.

Pittsburgh’s depth issues on the blue line are compounded by the fact that neither of their top two rearguards is expected to return in their current roles next season. In addition to trade talks involving Erik Karlsson likely serving as the dominant storyline of the Penguins’ offseason, the organization is looking to have right-side mainstay Kris Letang slot lower on the depth chart next year as he enters his age-38 campaign, Josh Yohe of The Athletic reports.

As Yohe writes, the Penguins’ front office believes a role reduction is the best way to get value out of the aging defender, who still has three seasons remaining on his contract at a $6.1MM price tag. This season marked Letang’s least effective performance in well over a decade. The lifelong Penguin, known primarily for his elite offensive ceiling, only managed a 9-21–30 scoring line in 74 games. That works out to 0.41 points per game, his worst offensive showing since the 2009-10 season. He only had 14 points in 39 games in the back half of the season, a 0.35 per-game rate.

His point production had already taken somewhat of a hit after the Karlsson pickup, since the latter superseded him on the top power play. That means most of his nosediving point totals had to do with a lack of even-strength output, a more concerning and less variable long-term factor. Letang recorded just 13 even-strength assists in 2024-25 after notching 35 of them, the second-highest mark of his career, the year before.

A reduction in minutes also makes sense for physical reasons. Letang is already fully recovered from the minor heart procedure he underwent in April to address the underlying cause of his two documented strokes, but it’s unrealistic to continue expecting him to shoulder such a high workload.

As Letang’s ice time decreased slightly for the third year in a row, there could be a more dramatic dropoff from the 23-minute range to the 20s next season as a result. He’s already entered the negative value stage that most knew was coming when he signed his six-year, $36.6MM extension in 2022. What wasn’t clear at the time was how the rest of the Penguins’ roster would look when that happened and how they would opt to move forward.

Nearly every scenario still involves Letang finishing his contract in Pittsburgh, Yohe writes. A buyout would be feasible if Penguins general manager Kyle Dubas decided he really needed the roster spot and additional cap space, but that’s rarely an avenue he takes. The negative reputational impact of paying the best defenseman in franchise history to not play for them likely outweighs any positives.

A trade is also out of the question. Letang’s no-movement clause notwithstanding, “it’s believed that no NHL teams are interested in Letang’s services” even if he decides to green-light a deal, according to Yohe.

Assuming Karlsson is moved, their plan for Letang only increases their desperate need for bodies on defense. That could increase their urgency to re-sign pending unrestricted free agent Matt Grzelcyk or put their names in the ring for one of the better free-agent blue-liners on a shorter-term deal while giving prospects like 2022 first-rounder Owen Pickering and 2024 second-rounder Harrison Brunicke a long leash to begin what could be an extremely difficult 2025-26 campaign defensively in Pittsburgh.