
Major League Soccer is home to global superstars like Lionel Messi, Thomas Muller and Son Heung-min, but its greatest current team isn't home to any of them.
The San Jose Earthquakes — a small-market franchise that finished dead last in 2024 and missed out on the playoffs in 2025 — are the first-placed team in MLS, and deservedly so. The team captured the top spot in the league after beating Austin FC, 5-1, at home on the ninth matchday of the season.
San Jose's rise against the odds, put together by an American coaching legend and a squad of hardworking domestic players, has been swift and gratifying. Here's the story of its charmed 2026, told through some of its most curious statistics:
With nine games of the 34-game MLS regular season under its belt, San Jose has scored 22 goals and conceded just four for a league-leading goal difference of +18. Those four goals conceded, incidentally, set a club record for the least number of goals conceded over nine games of play.
It's a marked improvement from the team's record in 2025, where goals were plentiful but concessions were plentiful, too. Nine games into last season, San Jose had scored 19 goals but conceded a whopping 17 for a goal difference of +2.
Take things back one year more, though, and the progress becomes even more astounding. Nine games into the 2024 season, San Jose had scored 13 goals and conceded 24 for a goal difference of -11.
San Jose's dizzying 5-1 victory over Austin FC on Matchday 9 was a blowout, but not quite the blowout it appears to be on paper. San Jose actually struggled quite a bit to find its way into the game and closed out the first half with a 1-0 deficit. The team got plenty of shots off in the opening 45 minutes, but none of them were particularly deadly: San Jose's 11 first half shots combined for an expected goal tally of just .83.
Coach Bruce Arena flipped that script at halftime.
"I told them we needed to get a few more crosses in front of the goal, and to be more aggressive running in the penalty area," Arena said in the post-match news conference. "And we accomplished that on a couple plays."
Indeed San Jose did. Its 11 shots, 0 goals and .83 xG at halftime morphed into 37 shots, five goals and 5.6 xG at the final whistle. Arena's men cracked Austin FC open after a frustrating first half and got the win they deserved.
There are a lot of things that are intriguing about this San Jose team, but that ability to read a game, make adjustments in real time and change its outcome so dramatically is perhaps the most intriguing of all.
Seven American players — Jack Jasinski, Daniel Munie, Reid Roberts, Jamar Ricketts, Beau Leroux, Niko Tsakiris and Preston Judd — started San Jose's 5-1 demolition of Austin FC on Matchday 9. (An eighth, Ousseni Bouda, came up through the NCAA system despite playing his international soccer for Burkina Faso.) That's nothing new for this San Jose team: It's played an average of 7.8 American players per game in 2026, more than any other team in MLS, and it's given 70% of its total game minutes to domestic athletes.
Defending MLS champion Inter Miami, meanwhile, started zero American athletes on Matchday 9. Just one — Greek international Noah Allen — spent any time in the American youth soccer system at all.
"We're not a club that has the resources of Inter Miami or LAFC or some of the bigger spending clubs in the league," Arena said. "We have to rely on some kids making it as homegrowns, some making it as college draft choices, and trying to hopefully be shrewd about the way we build the roster."
San Jose's Austin win on Matchday 9 put it in sole possession of the first-placed spot in MLS, a place it hasn't found itself since 2012. That season's San Jose side, led by club legend Chris Wondolowski, missed out on the MLS Cup after getting eliminated by an LA Galaxy side coached by...yes, you guessed it, Bruce Arena.
If San Jose can make a run toward the Cup in 2026 — and do it with Arena at the helm — it'll heal plenty of wounds from that 2012 season and prove that small franchises can still compete in MLS' big-money future.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!