Found May 09, 2013 on
Athletics manager Bob Melvin still believes he witnessed a home run, and nothing will change his mind.
Unfortunately, there's nothing he can do about it.
Melvin said Thursday that he has been in contact with Major League Baseball regarding the disputed ninth-inning call in Wednesday night's game. Umpires ruled that a ball hit by Oakland's Adam Rosales with two outs was a double, not a game-tying homer.
The umpires did not reverse their call despite watching video. TV replays clearly showed Rosales' ball went over the wall, and their decision shocked the A's, the Indians, 14,000 fans in attendance at Progressive Field and anyone watching the game on TV.
Melvin does not know if the call will be overturned, but expects baseball officials to comment.
''I've heard from MLB and I'm not going to say what they said,'' Melvin said before the A's and Indians wrapped up a four-game series. ''It's probably what the majority saw, but what they're going to do from here I haven't had any discussions about that.''
Helped by the disputed call, the Indians held on and won 4-3 as closer Chris Perez escaped a bases-loaded jam.
Melvin, who had requested that the umpires review Rosales' hit, was automatically ejected by second-base umpire Angel Hernandez for charging onto the field and arguing following the video review. MLB rules state that once the review is made, the call stands.
Hernandez, who asked a pool reporter not to record his interview following the game, said there was not enough clear proof to overturn the original call.
''It wasn't evident on the TV we had it was a home run,'' Hernandez said. ''I don't know what kind of replay you had, but you can't reverse a call unless there is 100 percent evidence and there wasn't 100 percent evidence.''
Melvin wasn't entirely familiar with the review procedure, which takes place off the field and near the umpires' dressing room. But he was confident the three umpires who left the field would see the same replays that were available to anyone watching the TV broadcasts.
Melvin said he became concerned the double would not be ruled a homer when the umpires took extra time to review the play.
''It actually worried me when it took so long because I knew all it took was one replay to see,'' he said. ''Even the group in the suite next to us, you could see them look at the replay one time and they all turned away and said it was a home run. When I went and looked at it in the video room, their TV announcers were saying, `This is a home run, let's go.'''
Melvin's understanding is that the umpires get several camera angles when reviewing a contested homer.
''They get all the feeds from both outlets and maybe even another one, I don't know,'' he said. ''But I don't think that MLB withholds feeds from them. Now what they're watching it on, I don't know. I'm not in there. It came down to somebody's decision and that was probably against the grain from what the majority thought.''
Melvin plans to take out the lineup card before Thursday's game, and joked that he ''hoped'' he wouldn't get ejected.
''I don't have much to say about it,'' he said. ''I'm not going to talk to them about it. If they want talk about it's one thing, but I'm just going to take the lineup card out.''
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
Athletics utility guy Adam Rosales is known for his home run trot — rather than the slow jog of most players, he sprints all 360 feet around the bases. Rosales didn’t get that chance during the ninth inning of Oakland’s Wednesday game against the Indians, hitting a ball that appeared to be off the wall and parking himself happily on second base.
Except that on second look,...
Oakland Athletics outfielder was placed on the 15-day DL on Wednesday for a sprained right wrist, so it’s understandable he may be a bit on the cranky side. But with a trip to the disabled list aside, for Josh Reddick and every other like-minded individual, it doesn’t require much to become profoundly irritated with [...]The post Josh Reddick is mad as hell about shopping carts...
The Athletics are running out of healthy outfielders.
Oakland placed outfielder Josh Reddick on the 15-day disabled list with a sprained right wrist on Wednesday, where he joined center fielders Coco Crisp (hamstring) and Chris Young (quadriceps). The A's have seven players on the disabled list and have used the DL nine times in just over a month.
''We never expected...
At the top of the 9th inning, Oakland A’s INF Adam Rosales appeared to hit a game-tying home run on Wednesday. The ball hit off the top of the fence in centerfield and then it came back down. The homerun was under review and after the review, the umpires decided that it was only a double. Everybody was shocked, even the Cleveland Indians broadcasters and players knew that it was...
The Oakland Athletics have placed outfielder Josh Reddick on the 15-day disabled list with a sprained right wrist.
The A's made the move Wednesday before playing the Cleveland Indians. Reddick joins Oakland center fielders Coco Crisp (hamstring) and Chris Young (quadriceps) on the DL.
Reddick hurt his wrist colliding with the wall in foul territory while chasing a pop on April...
And another one bites the dust…
So goes the story of the A’s early season troubles in the outfield. First Yoenis Céspedes did a 15 day stint on the DL, next up Coco Crisp and Chris Young. Before the A’s could even get either of those two outfielders back, Josh Reddick will now head to the DL for the next 15 days.
A once very crowded outfield is now scrambling to fill the...
Not overlooking tonight’s series opener between the Seattle Mariners and Oakland A’s, which will send Dan Straily to the hill to face off against Hisashi Iwakuma, but the more interesting game of the series could turn into the match-up on Saturday.
The probable pitchers are currently listed as Brandon Maurer for Seattle and Jarrod Parker for the A’s.
Parker was pulled early...
An apparent game-tying homer by Oakland's Adam Rosales was ruled a double by umpires in the ninth inning, and the Cleveland Indians held on to beat the Athletics 4-3 on Wednesday night.
Rosales sent a drive off Indians closer Chris Perez that looked as if it cleared the left-field wall. However, second-base umpire Angel Hernandez called it a double, and the crew concurred after...
Cleveland Indians Nick Swisher is one of those guys you either love, or hate. Love his genuine enjoyment of the game. Hate the way he celebrates in your face when he does well. The latter is the way Oakland Athletics pitcher A.J. Griffin feels, according to Susan Slusser, San Francisco Chronicle’s Oakland A’s beat writer for 15 seasons and president of the Baseball Writers’...
The injuries continue to mount for the Oakland A's, as Josh Reddick becomes the latest player to land on the A's suddenly crowded disabled list.
What did umpire Angel Hernandez see and how did he see it?
The question became a hot topic Thursday amid the uproar surrounding Hernandez's failure to make the correct call on an apparent ninth-inning, game-tying home run by the Athletics' Adam Rosales.
Hernandez indicated to a pool reporter that the umpires might not have seen the same replays in the same broadcast quality...
((HT: CSN California/MLB))
Let's face it...
The Oakland A's lost a game today because the umps fouled it up...
Evidence below involving Adam Rosales, replay, and a huge #umpfail
Justin Masterson got the win, Chris Perez collected his fifth save on the season...
Oakland is now 6-13 in their last 19 games...
And the fact it was Angel Hernandez makes it that much...
Major League Baseball acknowledges an ''improper call'' was made
by umpires in the ninth inning of a game between the Cleveland
Indians and Oakland Athletics.
Instant replay for baseball is supposed to help get it right, and many people are of the opinion that baseball needs more instant replay.
After the fiasco in Cleveland last night with Angel Hernandez missing a call not once, but twice, you have to wonder about the wisdom of such a move.
Last night in Cleveland, Adam Rosales hit a 1-1 pitch delivered by Indians closer Chris...