Back Draft: How QB Geno Smith is the Eagles best option

Posted February 20, 2013

This is the weekend where NFL fans get their first "peek" of some of the players trying to make a big splash during April's Draft. The combine has become a spectacle of sorts, and now a favorite time of year for the off season junkie who loves the NFL.

While there will be a few prospects I will undoubtedly be following throughout the process, it makes me wonder which of them will make the biggest jump after this weekend. The most common names the Eagles have been associated with going into this weekends combine (in regards to mock drafts etc) have been OT Luke Joeckel, DT/NT Star Lotulelei and CB Dee Milliner (in that order). While CB Milliner would suit a "need" I don't think he's one of the top 4 prospects in the entire draft. If the Eagles priority is either 1A. Joeckel or 1B. Lotulelei does it really make sense to settle for any other player at pick #4? Which brings me to the player I highlighted in QB Geno Smith. How is it that he is the Eagles best option during this Aprils Draft? The answer: Trade Bait.

With the most recent signing of QB Dennis Dixon, I don't think the Eagles are going to take a QB early in the draft. While Geno Smith may be the only QB with a 1st round grade, I think that selecting him anywhere outside of the top 20 would be a mistake. Fortunately, the NFL is a "Quarterback League" so assuming Big Red doesn't make the mistake of taking Smith with the #1 overall pick (or the Raiders making the same blunder at pick #3) let's look at some teams who may be just desperate enough to make the move.

Arizona Cardinals (pick #7):

Sure, we already burned them with the Kolb deal, but with a new HC in town (Bruce Arians) this might be prime pickings once again. Last season Kolb was downright atrocious. And since Arians is the new man in town, he will want someone who could be the QB of the future. Kolb is clearly not Andrew Luck (nobody is in this years draft) so why mortgage off the #4 if there is very little difference in terms of "draft grade" between picks 5-15?

Buffalo Bills (pick #8):

Huh? Don't they already have QB Ryan Fitzpatrick? Didn't they just give him a massive contract? This is the exact reason they will be desperate for QB Geno Smith. While Fitzpatrick was good at times, there were plenty of times he was terrible last season. New HC Doug Marrone will be looking to add hope to the Buffalo faithful and Fitzpatricks days are numbered (literally). Fitzpatrick is due a $3 million roster bonus in March on top of a $4.25 base salary. Which makes more sense to cut Fitzpatrick, because it's cheaper to go with a rookie than it would be to keep him at $7.25 million dollars.

New York Jets (pick #9):

J-E-T-S JETS JETS JETS! S-A-N-CHEZ SUCKS SUCK SUCKS! Honestly, if you are a Jets fan, how fast would you be running up to the podium in April's draft to select QB Geno Smith over the fledgling arm/talent of Mark Sanchez? GM Mike Tannenbaum was recently fired over Sanchez's lackluster performance (coupled with a terrible contract extension), and Rex Ryan knows he's tied to the hip of the QB's success. This is more than motivation to do what is necessary to draft Geno. And it gives the Eagles yet another option to move back in this Aprils draft.

Getting Lucky.

While I might be disappointed that the Eagles won't get their "man" (assuming we don't get either OT Joeckel or DT/NT Lotulelei at pick #4). My inner GM starts to drool over the "bidding war" we could start in regards to 3 QB desperate teams who are located in near identical areas of the draft (pick 7, 8, and 9).

The draft is loaded to the gills with good OT/DL (OT Eric Fisher, OT Lane Johnson, DT Shariff Floyd, DT Sheldon Richardson) and there are a few linebackers who would be a nice fit in a 3-4 scheme (Demontre Moore, Dion Jordan, Jarvis Jones etc) and could still possibly draft CB Dee Milliner at pick #7-#9 based on his performance at the combine. There are still plenty of options in the top 10. And even if we did move back as late as pick #9 we would get an impact player while also adding depth in terms of draft choices (perhaps an extra 3rd round pick which would be at the top end of round 3). The Eagles could also be lucky enough to trade back a bit, while also snagging quite possibly the best player in the entire draft: OG Chance Womack (who many believe is better than Steve Hutchinson and could possibly be the next "Larry Allen").

This years draft is also considered a good year to draft a safety, so we are in good shape here as well. Especially if the Chiefs are desperate enough to trade their 2nd round selection for QB Nick Foles and we can land another impact player on the OL/DL (while also selecting a player like Florida S Matt Elam in the second round).

So many options, and this is even before all the "cap casualties" hit the open market along with Free Agency. Exciting times indeed. Stay tuned!

Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45
  • [not displayed: comment from locked account]
  • Yeah I don't think the Cardinals need a QB. Kolb is no world beater, but he can manage a game. It would make more sense if they got him a RB or fixed that hot mess of an O-line.
  • Sure, Kolb isn't a "World Beater" and this is exactly my point. 1st year coach Arians will want a "Franchise QB" and this will give him more leeway as a new coach with a rookie QB (while also trying to emulate what he did with Luck in Indy). OL would be a better choice from a team perspective, but you can still get a decent OL in the 2nd while drafting the QB of the future in the 1st.
  • Latin, you killed it! I was thinking a trade of our 4th and Nick Foles, for the Jets 9th and 39th. That would give us the 9th, 35th, and 39th. Three top picks for a coach looking to rebuild a roster, would be a neat start.

  • You're giving up too much if you are the Eagles here. It just seems like you want to just get rid of Foles here. The Eagles could get those two picks with their pick alone.
  • I saw the reason why? kelly went with Dixon ? he played at Oregon.
  • I wouldn't mind this scenario at all. Mike Mayock was stating that he didn't like the Eagles #4 pick in an article just the other day and it seems that he may be right. Many mocks now have the Chiefs selecting Joeckel with the top pick and if Lotulelei doesn't make it to 4 then it seems like the Eagles could get a similar type talent at 7-9 and an extra pick. I honestly wouldn't be surprised to see the Eagles get a 2nd round pick out a deal like that instead of a 3rd but it all depends on how much value a team puts in Smith obviously. I'm extremely curious to see Kelly's first draft and even see what type of free agents he goes after. We all know how little Reid valued linebackers...could Kelly use his first pick on one or could he spend top dollar on Kruger? Does he fool many of us and draft Smith if he's there at 4, does he draft Manuel or Nassib in the 2nd if they are there (or someone else for that matter) and what kind of message does that send to Mike Vick if he does? It should be interesting spring.
  • I just mentioned the idea of Joeckel being gone by 4, in my last post. I'm starting to see him more than Geno Smith as #1 now. Besides, we all know about Andy and linemen!
  • I was always thinking of possible trades. If we can land another pick at the top of the second that would be huge. Say we miss on joeckel n star. We get warmack who is a monster. Draft Reid with the earlier second rounder ( I think Elam isnt gonna be good) n Barrett jones with the second 2nd. If we do trade back to say 9 I would bet on Kelly drafting dion Jordan to be his 3-4 OLB which isn't a bad thing just reshapes my draft a little
  • I can see that. Plus it gets us something out of Foles. If we can turn a 3rd round QB we can't use into a 2nd round pick, just by sliding 5 spots in the 1st...Yeah, I'd be all about that.
  • and Foles for that matter

    Update: February 20, 2013
    I said earlier dont trade down use the pick on Joekel/Star/Geno in that order. If you get Geno trade Foles and Vick. problem solved.
  • Holy crap did you write trade Foles and Vick??????
  • Truthfully, if your going in a whole new direction like Geno Smith why would you need either of them? Vick to teach bad habits and Foles to create distraction? Might as well give the ball to Dixon for a few games and then put in Geno and have Trent or someone better for backup.
  • Wow that is the most sensible thing I have ever read from you.
  • [not displayed: comment from locked account]

Report: Kings have had discussions with John Calipari

De’Andre Johnson charged with misdemeanor battery

Russell Wilson on salary: If it's $25M or $1.5M, I'll be ready to go

Luke Ridnour reportedly traded for fourth time in a week

Scottie Pippen: I was LeBron James before LeBron James


Report: Marc Gasol only visiting with Memphis Grizzlies

Draymond Green to meet with Warriors at onset of free agency

Panthers rookie WR: We're going to be the dynamic duo

Examining Bo Ryan's legacy at Wisconsin

World Cup semifinals preview: US-Japan, Germany-England

Tim Duncan to help Spurs pitch LaMarcus Aldridge

Popovich won't call free agents at midnight, he'll be in bed

Joe Buck explains why he quit Twitter

Should the White Sox and Indians become sellers?

Fan bases most deserving of a Super Bowl 50 win

2015 NBA Draft grades: Eastern Conference

Report: Redskins urged by major group to change team name

Under the radar NBA free agents

Michael Sam, boyfriend Vito Cammisano broke up?

Top seven storylines entering free agency around the NBA

Former FSU mascot killed in argument over gumbo recipe

Royals slipping in ASG voting, lose two more starters

Fred Smoot: I played with gay players, 'everyone knew'

All Sports News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

NBA Draft grades: Eastern Conference

Under the radar NBA free agents

Michael Sam, boyfriend broke up?

Mickelson linked to money laundering?

Reminiscing on 'Love & Basketball' 15 years later

Selecting the 2015 NL All-Stars

The Sixers' latest horde

Projected landing spots for NBA's top free agents

MLB changes format for Home Run Derby

Revis to work out with Patriots DBs

Peterson: I'm still NFL's best RB

Kobe gives great quote on friendship

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.