Found October 09, 2013 on Fox Sports:
The question isn't whether it's a surprise that, five games into the season, the Jets are a full three wins ahead of the Giants in the insignificant-but-significant two-horse race that is New York football. The question is: Did anyone think that the Jets would be better than the Giants? A single person? Would anybody, in August 2013, have been willing to put down money on the Jets ending the season with a superior record? I'm guessing not. And this isn't through any great sin or ignorance of the football-spectator world-at-large. It's because, at the beginning of the season, the Giants were only one year removed from a Super Bowl win and coming off a disappointing, but still capable, 9-7 season. The Jets, meanwhile, were a spiraling mess, consumed by a quarterback controversy during training camp, freshly without the best defensive player in franchise history, their coach the constant object of criticism. The rest of the roster was a mix of unproven youth -- not exactly a positive on a team well known for busting its defensive prospects -- and curiously picked vets; the leaders, guys like David Harris, Calvin Pace, Antonio Cromartie, Nick Mangold, and Santonio Holmes, were all either coming off injuries, underachieving seasons, or changes to their position-mates. But it all came back to the quarterback spot. For the past two years, Mark Sanchez had been the albatross hanging around Rex Ryan's neck. It's not worth the time recounting how bad Sanchez truly was, other than to mention that at least one metric rates him as the worst quarterback to ever start four seasons for one team. Ever . No matter how well Ryan did with the rest of his team, that poor judgment threatened to override his accomplishments, because anyone watching couldn't help but think: How does he not see it? Fortunately for Rex, the issue was made moot by Sanchez's injury. (Remember that controversy? That was fun.) And through five games, Geno Smith has done a few things beyond getting the Jets to 3-2, which, after all, involved plenty of help from Lavonte David. First of all, he's thrown touchdown passes, a technique that Mark Sanchez was never quite able to get the handle of; 4.5 percent of his pass attempts have been for touchdowns, higher than three out of four of Sanchez's seasons, including last year. It's a small sample size, but his completion rating is 60 percent, a full five points better than Sanchez's career mark. And, most importantly, he's shown improvement, and over a short period of time, too, culminating with Monday's wizardry against the Falcons: 16/20, 199 yards and three touchdowns. Everything about that performance was positive: a terrific completion percentage; great efficiency in his yards per attempt; and three scores compared with no turnovers. Smith's been dogged by turnovers so far, including and especially in a three-interception fourth quarter that crushed the Jets' surprisingly good shot at an upset win over the Patriots; after Week 4, his 11 giveaways were tied for the league lead. But the Falcons game was a step forward, and if Smith can continue along on that sort of developmental path -- coupled with the continued dominance of a shockingly firm front seven -- the Jets will legitimately compete for a playoff spot. Week 5 was a turning point in another way, too. You know who Smith was tied with after Week 4 for most turnovers in the league? Eli Manning. And when Smith was winning the game against Atlanta with zero giveaways -- well, the day before, since Jets-Falcons was a Monday-night affair -- Eli Manning added another three interceptions, moving into sole possession of both most interceptions this season (12) and most total turnovers (14). Manning's best quality has never been protecting the ball -- he threw 25 interceptions in 2010, a number he's on pace to beat significantly this year, followed by 16 in 2011 and 15 in 2012 -- but his turnovers this season are happening at an almost unprecedented rate: He's on pace to throw 38 picks in 2013, which would be the second-most, behind George Blanda's 42 INTs in 1962 (AFL, Houston Oilers). That was more than 50 years ago. There's nothing more emblematic of the shift in the Giants' and the Jets' New York standing than their records. But the performance of their two quarterbacks -- one a rookie who barely won the starting job and the other a two-time Super Bowl champion -- is a close second. As Geno and Eli go, so does New York City football.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

New York Jets quarterback Geno Smith hasn’t had an easy road to the NFL

The bar for rookie quarterbacks is at an all time high after the seasons that Robert Griffin III, Andrew Luck and Russell Wilson had last year. This season the New York Jets entered the year being looked at as a joke. The Jets had question marks all over their offense, especially at the quarterback position. Many predicted the Jets would be the worst team in the league at the...

Rookie Review: Geno Smith Lives Up to Pre-Draft Hype with Impressive Victory on Monday Night ...

Leading up to the 2013 NFL Draft, most draft analysts and NFL teams were excited by the talent West Virginia’s Geno Smith possessed and displayed throughout his college career. Smith showed the ball placement, confidence, and athleticism to step in early in his career and have success. But, for reasons that may stem from his college scheme or his “character concerns...

Not a good sign for Geno Smith

Rookie New York Jets quarterback Geno Smith has been very impressive so far this season, but this front page headline on New York’s Daily News is eerily similar to the one featuring Mark Sanchez after his debut with the Jets.  Hopefully this is just a coincidence and Smith will continue to develop and finally get that awful Sanchez taste out of the mouths of Jets fans. [via Imgur...

Pittsburgh Steelers vs. New York Jets: 3 Bold Predictions

The Pittsburgh Steelers are coming off their bye week.  They are 0-4. The New York Jets are coming off a come back victory over the Atlanta Falcons.  They are a surprising 3-2. Here are three bold predictions:Geno Smith will have less interceptions than Ben RoethlisbergerGoing into last week Smith was tied for a league high 11 turnovers including eight interceptions.  Roethlisberger...

NY Daily News Calls Geno Smith a “Star” Same Way They Did Mark Sanchez (Photo)

After a chaotic off-season where everyone had written them off, the New York Jets have started the 2013 season 3-2 and second place in the AFC East. Starting QB Geno Smith didn’t have the best preseason, so no one foresaw the kind of performance that Smith has given of late. Now Bleacher Report has gotten wind of something that might disturb Jets fans and take away from the pleasant...

Geno Smith, DeSean Jackson earn Players of the Week

Geno Smith's Monday night performance not only won over critics and headline writers it also earned him the AFC Offensive Player of the Week award for Week 5. Smith completed 16 of 20 passes for 199 yards and three touchdowns but it was his poise down the stretch leading the New York Jets to a 30-28 last-second victory over the Atlanta Falcons that most likely earned him the...

Film Review: Geno's latest game-winning drive

BY SEAN DONOVANRookie quarterback Geno Smith has a lot yet to prove as the New York Jets' franchise quarterback, but he showed this week that he won't be one to shy away from a big stage.Smith's steady hand keyed a late scoring drive that edged the Jets over the host Atlanta Falcons on Monday Night Football, 30-28. After the game, Smith described what was going through...

New York Jets Stun the Atlanta Falcons: 3 Things We Learned

The New York Jets traveled to Atlanta to meet the Falcons. The Jets entered the game a 10-point underdog. They left the game with a two point win. Who knew?Here are three things we do know:Geno Smith are you for real?Last week against the Tennessee Titans, Smith committed two turnovers. It started with an interception with his first pass from scrimmage and just got worse.What a...

Smith, Folk lead New York Jets past Falcons 30-28

Geno Smith wasn't flustered. Not after all the mistakes in his first four games. Not after the Atlanta Falcons went ahead on a touchdown with less than 2 minutes remaining. Looking like a wily ol' veteran instead of a rookie, Smith calmly guided the New York Jets to another victory. Smith threw three touchdown passes and directed a drive that set up Nick Folk's 43-yard...

Initial Reaction – Hello World! New York Jets Drop Falcons 30-28

In what was arguably their best regular season win since the beginning of the 2011 season, the New York Jets knocked off the Atlanta Falcons on Monday Night Football, 30-28. Yes, those New York Jets are 3-2. Rex Ryan, the lame duck coach who is just waiting to be fired. Geno Smith, the bum rookie who should be benched for Matt Simms…and the rest of the gang continues to win football...

Off The Wire: Week 6

Off The Wire: Week 6 spotlights some New York Jets and digs up some dirt on a couple of guys that are doing well in the absence of key players on their team. Some of these players have been waiting to break out, so let’s see if you agree. Quarterback— Geno Smith passed for 199 yards and three touchdowns in Monday’s underdog triumph at Atlanta. He completed 16 passes in 20 attempts...

NFL Picks and Predictions: New York Jets at Atlanta Falcons

The final game of week five for the 2013 NFL season gets underway this evening. This Monday Night Football game features one team which is really underachieving and one team that seems to be surprising the NFL world. The Atlanta Falcons enter this game with a 1-3 record and have lost three games by a combined 17 points. The New York Jets, starting a rookie quarterback have really...

Jets By The Numbers: Week 5

Week 5:  @ Atlanta Falcons Geno Smith went 16 for 20 (67%), 199 yards, and 3 TD, as well as rushing 3 times for 21 yards. Bilal Powell led the way on the ground with 38 rushing yards on 12 carries. Geno’s two favorite targets, in Week 5, were Jeff Cumberland (3 rec, 79 yards, 1 TD) and Jeremy Kerley (5 rec, 68 yards, 1 TD). The defense held Atlanta to 299 passing yards...

New York Jets Win MNF Thriller in ATL

Nobody thought the Jets stood a chance to complete at a high level this season. In fact, Pro Football Spot contributors dubbed the Jets a last place team, bar none. It was presumed that Gang Green would struggle to mount a pathetic total of two wins in 2013, courtesy of ill-informed fandom seemingly generated from an infamous highlight: the Butt Fumble.The Jets surpassed PFS predictions...

Steelers Versus Jets: Bad Momentum Versus Good Momentum

By Jeremy Hritz Dick LeBeau’s defense has had much success against rookie quarterbacks, losing only two games against Troy Smith and the Baltimore Ravens in 2007, and in 2012 against Brandon Weedon and the Cleveland Browns. Heading into Sunday’s game against the New York Jets, LeBeau and his boys will line up across from former Mountaineer Geno Smith in hopes of not only increasing...
All Sports News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.