The People vs. Andy Reid: The Evidence

Posted November 14, 2012

The number of indictments we have against Andy Reid are numerous. For example, the complete eradication of the team's identity. There's also the horrendous drafts and personnel decisions. Yet there are some in the court of public opinion who would still appeal our verdict of Reid being fired. They say look at his resume and of course the tired "careful what you wish for" excuse.

Today I'm going to show everyone that numbers don't lie. I'm here to give some DNA evidence if you will. I'd like to thank Cold Hard Football for these numbers.

First, we have Scorability. This measures offensive efficiency, or how effectively teams turn yards into points. The Eagles currently 31st in this category. You get this number by dividing Yards Gained on Offense by Points Scored. The Eagles have gained 3306 yards but have a measly 154 points to show for it. So they need 21.54 yards of offense to score ONE point. For a TD and PAT they would need to 150.8 yards to score. That's 1.5 football fields and a lot of wasted effort.

What about the defense? Not much better. For this we have Bendability. This measures defensive efficiency, or how hard teams make opponents work to score points. The Eagles rank 25th. Bendability is defensive yards given up divided by points yielded. Opponents have only needed 13.76 yards of offense to score 1 point on the Eagles. Or 96.32 yards for a TD and PAT. Too easy.

The Chiefs actually rank the lowest in both categories but they don't have the talent. It's understandable. The Eagles, on the other hand, are perfectly talented, but have failed miserably in execution.

To sum it all up, the best and most well-coached teams will rank high in both of these stats and vice-versa. Poor red zone offense and defense, bad penalties, turnovers and under-achieving special teams all conspire to hijack a team's efficiency -- and even its season. 

The Eagles are the living embodiment of inefficiency: a lot of empty wasted yards on offense that don't translate into points paired with a lot of cheap scores surrendered on defense

It's situation football that separates smart, contending teams from dumb pretenders.

This kind of poor situational football is a losing formula for any team no matter the level and reason enough for Reid's dismissal as head coach. 

  • [not displayed: comment from locked account]
  • I think all of us besides possibly one barker agree it is time to move on. Reid is not even close to the same coach that helped take the Eagles to all those NFC championships and division titles. His game has gotten old, he's too stubborn to change and he may have let his personal problems get in the way of being a good coach in the NFL. He will be gone at the end of the year and I'll be looking forward to seeing how Lurie and Roseman handle the change. Nothing we can do but hope they make the right choice.
  • [not displayed: comment from locked account]
  • When it comes down to it I don't think you will ever get those "be careful what you wish for" people to ever change despite how much evidence is presented to them. They live their sports life in fear. That will never change.
  • [not displayed: comment from locked account]
  • There is always a chance for something worse later, but there is also a chance for something better. I am one of those people who believe once a conclusion is made (like Reid can't win the big one here) there is no reason to go any further in that direction. In fact the longer we take to move from the direction the longer it will be before we can get where we want to be. Anymore Reid will be a waste for both parties.
  • We heard the "careful what you wish for" comments ad nauseum before the McNabb trade especially from the national media. Annoyed me then and it annoys me now. 11 years same quarterback same results. 14 years same coach same results...time to move on!
  • [not displayed: comment from locked account]
  • In this case Reid came first so I guess I would have to give it to the chicken.
  • I agree with you and that has crossed my mind before. Reid has had some success without McNabb when he was injured and he had the 10-6 season in 2010 but it hasn't beem sustained without McNabb.
  • [not displayed: comment from locked account]
  • It is possible but you will never get some of those fans who believe McNabb carried the Eagles on his shoulders (not going to type it, Eazy) to ever admit that. McNabb was a good quarterback who had some faults just like Reid was good coach who had shortcomings of his own. Maybe the faults of both these men were just too much to overcome when it mattered most. Seems that way to me.
  • McPologists. There you go.
  • There has been a massive effort to sell people on their talent. I havent really seen it since 2010. They lack depth and the lines & schemes stink. Or ot could be just the coach stinks.
  • ...and it could be that the coach and the quarterback stink.
  • possibly but time will tell.
  • One mediocre season last year and one bad one right now, the coach and QB look clueless and the QB is a turnover machine...I think time has already told.
  • You keep saying how bad McNabb was when he was in Washington. He was on pace to record or did record the highest yardage in Redskin history so Im not sure why you think he was so bad.
  • A lot of his yards were probably losses where he had to throw because the Redskins were behind, hollywood. Check back on his numbers that season. He started 13 games and I'm pretty sure they were the first 13 before he was benched. If that is the case he did throw for 3,300 yards but he only had 14 TDs and 15 picks. He couldn't get his team in the endzone which is what matters when winning games, isn't it? The Redskins NEVER scored more than 19 in his 5 wins and the 19 was an overtime win. The most points he put up were in the second Philly game (28) when the Eagles blew Washington out right from the start. The McNabb led Redskins only averaged 16.5 points per game and as we see here in Philly that is just not enough.
  • Its funny the players thought it was a mistake to get rid of him in DC. But yet you keep calling him a failure there. You know more than the players? He had no RB or WR and the OLine stunk.
  • You told us all right here on yardbarker that he would win with Shanahan, hollywood. Players almost never call each other out nor do they want to admit that aren't getting it done. What do you expect them to say? Listen to you anyway with all your silly, oddball predictions and comments that go against all things human let alone the media and the analysts who diagnose and discuss football for a living.
  • His record as a starter. His coach basically calling him fat and stupid. His being demoted to third string! His subsequent release. The fact the fan base was glad he left. Is there anything else you want to know?
  • Hollywood brings up empty yards and ignores facts.
  • Fact is Im alot closer to DC than you and I didnt hear the fans or players ever say anything bad about him. You are once again misleading readers in the yard.
  • [not displayed: comment from locked account]
  • Are you really going to try to say the Redskin fans weren't happy to see him go?...and you state that I try to mislead? Do you really pay attention to football or are you just trying to lead a crusade against Lurie and the Eagles for some strange reason? My brother lives outside of DC in Virginia and he told me that many of the fans were upset with the trade to aquire McNabb...why the hell would they change their view after 5-8 as a starter and 16.5 points per game? I'm pretty sure that the only Redskin barker we see in this yard (beery, I think) isn't a McNabb fan at all. You fib, fib.
  • [not displayed: comment from locked account]
  • The team hasn't been the same since JJ passed. I'm all for change if it will help in the long run. And hopefully the next coach we get lights a fire under this team. I'd still love to see a 3-4 defense installed. Almost every year the top defenses are of this type, and perhaps it's time to change philosophy altogether?

    I just checked and out of the top 15 defenses (points allowed per game) 12 of the 15 were 3-4. Coincidence? Probably not.

    I'd LOVE to see Cowher coach this team. My slogan if/when Andy is dumped:

    The chin for the win!! :D
  • I'd kill to get Sean Payton, but he ain't leaving the Saints. I mean why would he?
  • Unfortunately I don't think Cowher has a shot in Philly for two reasons. The first is Lurie has already stated after Ray Rhodes he will never again go with a defensive minded coach and the second is I think Cowher is looking to coach the Panthers.
  • stop whining about JJ. There is plenty of talent out there only the Eagles dont have it

Bears to bench Jay Cutler, start Jimmy Clausen

Wes Welker once pulled funny UGG prank on Tom Brady

Wil Myers heads to Padres in 11-player, 3-team trade

Bo Pelini calls Nebraska AD a ‘c–t’ and ‘p-ssy’

49ers release Ray McDonald

Take your pick: Colin Kaepernick or Derek Carr


Reports: Michigan makes huge offer to Harbaugh

Heat lose a key player with McRoberts out for rest of season

Belichick: Ryan is 'buttering me up' with Hall of Fame praise

Marshall: Bears need to gel and do some kumbaya

Red Sox appear content with rotation despite lack of true ace

Iguodala gets technical for mocking Conley travel

Report: Celtics in serious trade talks involving Rondo

WATCH: Brandon Jennings makes mind-boggling play

WATCH: Drake intros Raptors on 'Drake Night'

Brian Billick owns Browns fan over Johnny Manziel criticism

WATCH: Did Flyers' Giroux wipe boogers on linesman’s back?

Royals sign Edinson Volquez to 2-year deal

12 candidates to replace Paul Chryst at Pitt

Brad Halsey claimed he was on cocaine for Bonds record HR

Wade Miley confident in health, diet after trade from D-Backs

When bowl results mean more for one school than another

Ray Rice, Adrian Peterson lead in 2014 athlete Google searches

Max Scherzer next domino to fall in free agent market

All Sports News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.

Brian Billick owns Browns fan

C's in serious trade talks about Rondo

Pelini has profane words for Nebraska AD

When bowl results mean more for one school than another

Four can't-miss match-ups in NFL's Week 16

RG3 quits social media for season

Each NFL division’s MVP

Five NFLers who must step up in Week 16

Most impressive college hoops teams

Five reasons why FSU is going to win the CFB Playoff

Boxer admits to dive in Rourke bout

FCC heard about Brady's swearing?

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.